This essay compares Flannery O'Connor's "A Good Man is Hard to Find" and Raymond Carver's "Cathedral," examining how each author uses setting and extraordinary circumstances to convey thematic messages. O'Connor places her characters in a violent, fatal encounter that exposes unexpected similarities between the self-righteous grandmother and the murderous Misfit. Carver, by contrast, uses a quieter domestic setting in which a narrator's discomfort with a blind visitor gives way to an unexpected moment of self-discovery. Together, the two stories illustrate how situations — dramatic or mundane — can force characters and readers alike toward new understanding.
Authors often go to remarkable lengths to convey a message to their readers. One effective method is to change a character's setting or situation in ways that allow the reader to grasp the author's intended meaning. Two stories that illustrate this literary technique are "A Good Man is Hard to Find" by Flannery O'Connor and "Cathedral" by Raymond Carver. Both authors use extraordinary situations to show how characters — and readers — can learn from the circumstances in which they find themselves.
In "A Good Man is Hard to Find," O'Connor uses the extraordinary situation of a family's sudden, violent death to bring readers to the realization that people are not always what they seem. O'Connor contrasts the overbearing Misfit with the grandmother to illustrate how two seemingly very different people can share surprising similarities. The grandmother is not evil in the conventional sense, but she is self-righteous and manipulative. She warns her family to beware of the Misfit, yet her own stubbornness leads them directly into his path. When the family finally encounters him, the grandmother is the only one who sustains a real conversation with the killer.
"Both characters share stubbornness and moral conviction"
"Jesus thrown everything off balance. If He did what He said, then it's nothing for you to do but throw away everything and follow Him, and if He didn't, then it's nothing for you to do but enjoy the few minutes you got left the best way you can — by killing somebody or burning down his house or doing some other meanness to him. No pleasure but meanness." (O'Connor 1088)
It is through this horrible act of violence that both the grandmother and the reader come to understand that things do not always work out as planned, and that some stories do not have a happy ending. O'Connor's use of a fatal, unavoidable confrontation strips away the grandmother's pretensions and forces a moment of raw, mutual recognition between two people who would never otherwise have acknowledged what they share.
In "Cathedral," Carver utilizes a far less dramatic setting to convey his message. The narrator is uneasy about the visit of Robert, a blind man, and does not know how to behave when they first meet. It is only through an unexpected conversation about cathedrals that the narrator discovers something meaningful about Robert — and about himself. The domestic setting is significant precisely because it is the ordinary space in which an extraordinary moment of understanding takes place, and the narrator's epiphany emerges from that ordinary environment.
The mood of the home shifts gradually from negative to positive as the evening unfolds. Sight becomes the story's central motif, since the entire narrative revolves around what it means to truly see — and that is ultimately what brings the two men closer together. Because the narrator attempts to help Robert visualize a cathedral through touch and description, he discovers something about himself that is, in his own halting words, "really something" (Carver 228). The story demonstrates that some of the most significant insights in life cannot be anticipated or planned.
"A Good Man is Hard to Find" and "Cathedral" are two stories that bring readers to understanding through the use of setting and circumstance. Each has a point to make about human personality: if we allow ourselves to remain open, we can always learn something from someone. The grandmother must learn that she is not as superior as she believed, and that she and the Misfit have more in common than either would care to admit. The narrator in "Cathedral" learns that he can benefit profoundly from spending time with a blind man. Taken together, both stories affirm that genuine understanding — of others and of ourselves — often arrives through the most unexpected encounters.
You’re 83% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 1 section.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.