Sinclair's Oil! vs. There Will Be Blood: Naturalism Compared
This paper examines Upton Sinclair's novel Oil! alongside Paul Thomas Anderson's film adaptation There Will Be Blood, situating both works within the tradition of American literary naturalism. Beginning with Frank Norris's short story "A Deal in Wheat" as a framework for understanding naturalist determinism, the paper traces how each work depicts characters shaped by greed, environment, and social forces. It argues that while Anderson's film foregrounds the naturalistic struggle between two corrupt individuals—oil baron Daniel Plainview and preacher Eli Sunday—Sinclair's novel prioritizes a broader social-realist critique of capitalism, labor exploitation, and the tensions between capitalism and socialism, as filtered through the perspective of Bunny Ross.
- American Literary Naturalism and Its Key Themes: Naturalism defined via Norris and determinism
- Naturalism in Upton Sinclair's Oil!: Joe Ross as naturalist product of environment
- Title Differences and Thematic Focus: Titles signal novel's realism vs. film's focus
- Anderson's Film and Naturalist Characterization: Plainview and Eli Sunday as corrupt exploiters
- Key Scenes of Determinism in There Will Be Blood: Baptism and bowling alley scenes analyzed
- Social Realism vs. Naturalism: Novel and Film Compared: Novel's socialist breadth vs. film's character study
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Uses Frank Norris's "A Deal in Wheat" as a theoretical springboard before moving to the main comparison, grounding the argument in a recognizable naturalist tradition.
- Deploys direct quotations from both the novel and the film to support claims about naturalist and social-realist elements, giving the analysis textual authority.
- Draws a clear structural contrast between the film's narrow character focus and the novel's broad social panorama, preventing the comparison from becoming vague.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates comparative literary and film analysis anchored to a theoretical framework (naturalism and determinism), citing Lars Ahnebrink's definition to formalize the critical lens before applying it to specific scenes and passages. This move — establish the theory, then test it against the text — is a reliable undergraduate technique for organizing comparative arguments.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a definition of naturalism, then illustrates it with Norris before turning to Sinclair. It next introduces the film adaptation and the significance of the differing titles. Subsequent sections analyze key scenes in Anderson's film through a naturalist lens, and the paper closes by contrasting the film's character-driven naturalism with the novel's social-realist scope. A brief concluding evaluative statement rounds out the argument.
American Literary Naturalism and Its Key Themes
Like Realism, literary Naturalism attempts an objective depiction of human beings in the context of their social and natural environment. The difference between the two is that naturalism also adopts a philosophical attitude toward mankind: humans are no more than "beasts" whose character and behavior are deeply influenced by their environment, heredity, and instincts. Thus, naturalist writers focus on the "natural" instincts of men that make them products of their environment. A human being is inevitably dependent on and bound to her or his social and natural environment. As an integral part of their extraneous context, individuals lose their individuality and become a homogenous mass.
One of the best-known naturalist writers in American literature is Frank Norris. His short story "A Deal in Wheat" is built around a single narrative thread: the price of wheat and how it can ruin or, on the contrary, save the life of Sam Lewiston and his wife Emma. The almost ridiculous importance that an economic detail like the price of wheat has in the life of an individual emphasizes the philosophical stance of the naturalist writer. The naturalists ironically suggest that human beings are not permitted to develop spiritually and are left prey to their environment, which clutches them in its grip. This is what explains the abrupt introduction of Norris's story, which presents the fall of the wheat price as a real tragedy:
"The time was late in the summer, the place a ranch in southwestern Kansas, and Lewiston and his wife were two of a vast population of farmers, wheat growers, who at that moment were passing through a crisis — a crisis that at any moment might culminate in tragedy. Wheat was down to sixty-six." (Norris)
"A Deal in Wheat" thus portrays the workings of social systems and the way they catch the individual in their cogs, relentlessly dragging him into their swirl: "But Lewiston never forgot. Dimly he began to see the significance of things. Caught once in the cogs and wheels of a great and terrible engine, he had seen — none better — its workings." (Norris) Sam Lewiston is nearly ruined to absolute poverty by the wheat dealers who dupe him, but in the end he miraculously manages to revive and save himself and his family from disaster. The schemes employed by those involved in the deal are significant because they emphasize the lengths to which businessmen go to accomplish their purpose, thus becoming almost inhuman: "Took it abroad! Say, he's just been running it around Chicago, like the supers in 'Shenandoah,' round an' round, so you'd think it was a new lot, an' selling it back to you again. 'No wonder we couldn't account for so much wheat.' 'Bought it from us at one-ten, and made us buy it back — our own wheat — at one-fifty.'" (Norris)
Works Cited
Campbell, John. American Realism and Naturalism. Washington State University.
Sinclair, Upton. Oil! New York: Penguin, 2007.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.