Essay High School 577 words

Slavery as a Cruel and Inhumane Institution in America

~3 min read

Abstract

This essay presents a moral and social critique of slavery in America, arguing that the institution is fundamentally inhumane, contradicts Christian teachings and America's foundational ideals, and damages the broader economic system by eliminating wage-paying jobs. The paper challenges pro-slavery arguments and examines slavery's degrading treatment of enslaved people, its incompatibility with religious values, and its negative impact on non-enslaved workers seeking employment.

📝 How to Write This Type of Paper Writing guide — click to expand

▼

What makes this paper effective

Presents three distinct arguments (inhumanity, religious contradiction, economic damage) to build a multi-faceted critique of slavery
Uses concrete examples—family separation, physical violence, forced labor—to illustrate abstract moral claims
Directly addresses and refutes pro-slavery defenses (the "investment" argument, selective biblical interpretation)
Frames slavery within American identity (as contradicting the nation's founding ideals of freedom and opportunity)

Key academic technique demonstrated

The paper employs argumentative essay structure with multiple supporting claims. Each body paragraph advances a distinct line of reasoning (ethical, theological, economic), and the conclusion synthesizes these arguments by naming them explicitly. This approach demonstrates how to sustain a persuasive argument across several independent but complementary foundations.

Structure breakdown

The essay follows a classical five-paragraph structure: introduction stating the thesis and three supporting reasons; three body paragraphs developing each reason separately; and a conclusion that restates the thesis and summarizes all three arguments. The introduction is particularly strong because it previews the full argument, signposting exactly what the reader will encounter.

The Inhumanity and Cruelty of Slavery

Humans and animals are two distinct beings, yet slavery constituted the ownership and degrading of human beings to nothing more than animals—treated often far worse. Slaveowners claim they are kind and treat their slaves well since they are "investments," but this claim could not be further from the truth. Slaves are treated like less than animals, toiling and working to extremes for all hours of the day and night, working far more than any human should have to work for no pay, no civil or political rights, and no dignity whatsoever.

The commodification of human beings was systematic and brutal. Much like cattle auctioned at market, slaves were auctioned off and separated from their families and friends. Children were frequently separated from their entire families and never saw them again. Beyond this devastating family destruction, slaveowners often beat and whipped their slaves—many times to the point of serious injury or death. Some slaveowners would beat their slaves harshly for any reason whatsoever; some especially sadistic slaveowners beat their slaves for entertainment. While slaveowners may attempt to display a facade of kindness toward their slaves, their actions reveal the true nature of the institution.

Slavery's Contradiction to American and Religious Ideals

Since the very first colonies came to the New World, America was envisioned as a perfect, God-like society, as free from sin as possible. However, slavery pulls America farther away from its God-worshipping roots and its original goal. Slavery is in no way, shape, or form a holy or righteous thing in the eyes of God.

Those who defend slavery attempt to cite biblical passages they claim support the institution, but these citations rely on selective interpretation. Biblical supporters of slavery distort verses meant to be interpreted differently, making it seem as though the Bible and God himself support slavery—a fundamentally false claim. God preaches above all that one should be a kind and loving child who loves his neighbor as he loves himself. Slavery contradicts entirely all of God's teachings and the foundational values upon which the nation was founded. The institution stands as a direct affront to Christian morality and American ideals of freedom.

Economic Harm and Job Displacement

America has long been known as the land of opportunity, and the option to have a paying job has drawn thousands to this country for years. However, slavery limits this opportunity significantly. Since slaves exist to perform labor without compensation, slavery reduces the amount of wage-paying jobs available to free workers, as enslaved people perform the same labor for no pay whatsoever.

Therefore, slavery damages the welfare of others beyond the slaves themselves. Slavery degrades the economic and employment system, taking away job opportunities from those who need them. The institution creates an unfair economic advantage for slaveholders while simultaneously harming the economic prospects of non-enslaved workers seeking fair wages for their labor.

Conclusion: Slavery as an Unjust Institution

Slavery is a peculiar institution, certainly, but without a doubt a cruel and unjust one. Those who support slavery will argue that it is not cruel, that the Bible and God support the practice, and that it does not negatively affect anyone. These are all false statements. Slavery is an extremely inhumane practice, it defies God and the Bible in nearly every way, and it negatively affects the opportunities available to other American citizens. The evidence is overwhelming: slavery cannot be defended on moral, religious, or economic grounds.

You’re 96% through this paper. Sign up to read the full paper.

130,000+ paper examples AI writing assistant Citation generator Cancel anytime

Key Concepts in This Paper

Slavery Inhumane Treatment Family Separation Wage Labor Religious Contradiction American Ideals Economic Damage Moral Critique