The Sopranos as a Mirror of American Moral Decline
This essay examines David Simon's argument that The Sopranos reflects a distorted moral code embedded in American society — one in which personal economic gain justifies any action, regardless of harm to others. Drawing on Simon's Tony Soprano's America (2002), the paper explores how Tony Soprano functions as a fictional stand-in for the real-world "power elite," whose self-serving ethics undermine ordinary Americans through physical, economic, and moral harm. The essay also evaluates Simon's broader claim that media glorification of criminals normalizes deviant behavior, while arguing that most Americans ultimately reject Tony's moral framework in favor of law, order, and justice.
- Introduction: The Sopranos and the American Moral Code: Simon argues Sopranos reflects corrupted American moral values
- The American Dream and the Pressure to Succeed at Any Cost: Achievement pressure drives ends-justify-means morality
- The Power Elite and Tony Soprano as Its Symbol: Tony mirrors real power elite operating outside ethical norms
- Media, Violence, and the Glorification of Criminals: American media has long glorified outlaws and criminal figures
- Physical, Economic, and Moral Harm Caused by the Tony Soprano Code: Tony's code produces three distinct categories of societal harm
- The Enron Connection: Real-World Power Elite in Action: Enron scandal illustrates how real power elite mirrors Tony
- Conclusion: Why Tony Soprano's Moral Code Must Be Rejected: Society must reject predatory morality to protect ordinary citizens
✍️ How to write this paper — guide & tools ▾
What makes this paper effective
- It uses a specific academic source (Simon, 2002) consistently throughout, grounding literary analysis in sociological argument rather than pure opinion.
- The two-part structure mirrors the essay prompt's format while building a coherent argument: first analyzing Simon's thesis, then evaluating Tony Soprano's moral code on its own terms.
- The paper balances textual evidence with counterargument — it credits Simon's strengths while pointing out what he omits (lawmen, justice, majority civic values), which demonstrates critical thinking.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates source-driven analysis with evaluative critique: the student carefully summarizes Simon's claims using direct quotations and page citations, then steps back to assess where Simon's argument is incomplete or overstated. This approach — engage, explain, then evaluate — is a standard move in undergraduate analytical writing and prevents the essay from becoming a simple book report.
Structure breakdown
Part I establishes Simon's theoretical framework: the corrupted American Dream, the pressure to succeed at any cost, the concept of the power elite, and the historical role of media in glorifying criminals. Part II applies that framework to Tony Soprano's specific harms — physical, economic, and moral — with the Enron case serving as the central real-world parallel. The conclusion argues that Tony's moral code, however prevalent among the powerful, is fundamentally incompatible with a just and civilized society.
Introduction: The Sopranos and the American Moral Code
David Simon argues that The Sopranos is a reflection of a moral code prevalent in American society. This code, based on a twisted version of the American Dream, essentially holds that anything is acceptable as long as it furthers one's economic prosperity. No matter who gets hurt or which laws are broken, as long as it benefits the individual personally, it is considered acceptable. Simon argues that the lead character, Tony Soprano, is a representative of the "power elite" in the United States — a group that acts strictly for its own benefit with little regard for the collateral damage it causes. The moral code exemplified by the characters in The Sopranos is a representation of the twisted perversion of the American Dream that some less honorable members of American society adopt; unfortunately, those members also make up its most powerful and influential ranks.
The American Dream has always been to prosper without the interference of a government that seeks to regulate and control. However, the American system has always regarded individual rights as the highest priority, and therefore the government sometimes has a duty to protect its citizens from the predations of other citizens. While Tony Soprano may feel that this interference limits his ability to achieve the American Dream — and thus simply ignores the law — those laws are necessary to protect others from people like him.
The American Dream and the Pressure to Succeed at Any Cost
Everyone in America deserves the chance to achieve the American Dream, regardless of "race, age, gender, class, or level of education" (Simon, 2002, p. 17). Simon views the American Dream through the lens of The Sopranos and, while he also defines it as "universal," he points out certain unattractive aspects of that dream. Simon claims the American Dream is oriented toward achievement — which is true — but asserts that in The Sopranos, and by extension American society, this orientation toward goals often clouds people's judgment, creating pressures that cause many to put ends above means. In other words, the American Dream's expectation that everyone can succeed puts pressure on people to do just that: succeed at any cost and without regard for how success is achieved.
Success in America is often measured in terms of money, or what Simon calls "the fetishism of money" (Simon, 2002, p. 17). As wealth in the United States becomes increasingly concentrated in the hands of the "power elite," this inequality has altered the moral codes surrounding the acquisition of wealth. Tony Soprano, according to Simon, is a representation of this shift in moral values and reflects the new American morality permeating the nation. Many Americans feel that because the wealthy hold all the money, all the power, and make the laws to benefit themselves, breaking the law is more an act of rebellion against an unjust system. Tony Soprano is a manifestation of this idea — he feels this way and rationalizes his own reprehensible behavior as part of what Simon calls "Good American Values" (Simon, 2002, p. 19).
The Power Elite and Tony Soprano as Its Symbol
As Tony Soprano justifies his actions in terms of a moral code that is mirrored in the real world by what Simon calls the "power elite," it is important to understand what the author means by this term. According to Simon, the "power elite" is more than a conspiracy theory — it is a fact. He makes a compelling case that this elite exists among the highest ranks of corporate America, the military, and the political establishment, and he demonstrates how this group has caused concrete harm to individual Americans. This group operates by a uniquely self-serving code of moral ethics — one that Simon shows to be selfish, harmful, and often illegal, and one that Tony Soprano appears to share.
In a society that has unrealistic expectations of success and an insufficient supply of legitimate means to obtain it, people often become alienated and detached. This alienation can take the form of escapism through mass media, as people retreat into entertainment when real life becomes difficult. When they encounter what the media presents as "success," many confuse the media's interpretation of morality with what is actually acceptable in real society.
References
Simon, D. (2002). Tony Soprano's America: The criminal side of the American Dream. Westview Press.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.