Supernatural Elements and Witchcraft in Shakespeare's Macbeth
This paper examines the role of supernatural elements across Shakespeare's dramatic works, with particular focus on the three witches in Macbeth. Drawing on historical documents such as Pope Innocent VIII's Bull Summis desiderantes (1484), the paper argues that belief in witchcraft was widespread and credible in Shakespeare's era, extending even to educated elites. The analysis traces how the witches' prophecy functions as a concrete dramatic catalyst rather than mere metaphor, spurring Macbeth's descent into murder and moral ruin. The paper also considers the theological dimension of witchcraft belief as a response to the problem of evil, and concludes that a purely skeptical or allegorical reading of Shakespeare's supernatural elements distorts the playwright's intent.
- Introduction: The Supernatural in Shakespeare's Works: Overview of supernatural themes across Shakespeare's canon
- Historical Belief in Witchcraft: Pope Innocent VIII and the Bull Summis Desiderantes: Papal document reveals widespread Elizabethan-era witchcraft belief
- Witchcraft, Theodicy, and the Problem of Evil: Witchcraft as explanation for why God allows evil
- The Three Witches and Their Prophecy in Macbeth: Witches' prophecy catalyzes Macbeth's murderous ambition
- Witchcraft Beyond the Lower Classes: Witchcraft belief spanned all social classes in Shakespeare's time
- Conclusion: The Supernatural as a Real and Concrete Force: Supernatural in Shakespeare demands literal, not merely symbolic, reading
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper grounds its literary analysis in primary historical documents — particularly Pope Innocent VIII's papal bull — lending scholarly credibility to its claims about period belief in witchcraft.
- It moves fluidly between close textual analysis of Macbeth (including direct quotation from the First Folio) and broader cultural and theological context, keeping the argument anchored in evidence throughout.
- The paper anticipates the modern reader's skepticism and addresses it directly, strengthening its argument by acknowledging the gap between contemporary and Elizabethan worldviews.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates effective use of historicist literary criticism: rather than reading Shakespeare's supernatural elements through a modern symbolic lens, it reconstructs the intellectual and cultural environment in which the plays were written and performed. By citing contemporary documents alongside the literary text, the author shows that the witches in Macbeth functioned as credible, frightening agents of evil for original audiences — not as metaphor, but as dramatic reality.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a broad survey of supernatural elements across Shakespeare's canon before narrowing to Macbeth as the central case study. It then introduces historical evidence (the papal bull) to establish period belief in witchcraft, pivots to the theological concept of theodicy, analyzes the witches' prophecy scene directly, addresses the cross-class nature of witchcraft belief, and closes with a synthesis that defends a non-metaphorical reading of the supernatural in Shakespeare.
Introduction: The Supernatural in Shakespeare's Works
The supernatural is a theme that runs throughout Shakespeare's plays. The ability of supernatural forces to drive the action of Shakespeare's dramas is almost unparalleled — supernatural elements often take on a power and efficacy that the forces of the natural world could never replicate, and supernatural events frequently have as great an impact on worldly affairs as everyday human activity. The examples in Shakespeare's works are numerous: Prospero's powers and his spirit Ariel in The Tempest, the Ghost of Hamlet's father in Hamlet, Margaret's curse in Richard III, and the power of prophecy in Julius Caesar.
Of all these instances of the occult and the supernatural and their peculiar effects on the living, perhaps no example is more famous than Macbeth and its witches. The play depicts Macbeth and Banquo's encounter with the witches very early in the action, and the strange prophecy they deliver seems to drive much of the drama that follows. Indeed, the witches' cauldron spell — with its bouncing trochaic meter — is, alongside Macbeth's "Out, out, brief candle" soliloquy, one of the most quotable moments in the play. The supernatural aura surrounding the work has grown so notorious that actors refuse to say the name "Macbeth" while rehearsing it, referring to it only as "The Scottish Play."
It is important to remember, however, that in Shakespeare's time witches were not merely the stuff of fairy stories and Halloween costumes. Belief in the supernatural was real and pervasive, and the idea that both men and women could appeal to occult methods and black arts to fulfill their worldly desires was widely held. Many documents from Shakespeare's era illuminate common belief in witchcraft, explain its elements, and offer procedures for bringing witches to trial. This belief reflects the overwhelming power the witches seem to exercise in Macbeth, and demonstrates that their influence is not in the least theoretical but a real and forceful spur as Macbeth grapples with his own desire to advance his worldly station through the murder of Duncan.
Bibliography
Innocent VIII. "Bull Summis desiderantes, Dec. 5th, 1484." Medieval Sourcebook: Witchcraft Documents [15th Century]. Apr. 11, 2003. http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/source/witches1.html
Shakespeare, William. Macbeth, 1623 First Folio Edition. Apr. 11, 2003.
"Witches." The Background of Ideas. Shakespeare's Life and Times. Apr. 11, 2003.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.