Wage Equity for Women: Gender Pay Gap and Comparable Worth
This paper examines wage equity for women in the context of human resource management compensation policy, focusing on two central issues: equal pay for equal work and comparable worth. Drawing on Taylor's (1989) foundational argument, Perry and Gundersen's (2011) workforce data, and the National Women's Law Center's (2013) policy analysis, the paper traces persistent gender-based pay disparities across age groups and education levels. It explores structural factors—including occupational self-segregation, family obligations, and employer loopholes—that sustain the pay gap, and evaluates policy remedies such as strengthening equal pay laws, raising minimum wages, and implementing family-friendly workplace policies.
- Compensation and the Gender Pay Gap: HRM compensation goals and procedural justice defined
- Comparable Worth and the Equal Pay Act: Equal Pay Act critique through comparable worth lens
- Workforce Trends and Pay Differentials: Progress for women alongside persistent pay gaps
- Family Obligations and Occupational Self-Segregation: How family roles drive women into lower-paying jobs
- Policy Remedies for Pay Equity: Legal reforms, minimum wage, and family-friendly policies
- Summary: Core issues and recommended remedies recapped
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Efficiently synthesizes three distinct sources—a foundational theoretical argument, current workforce data, and a policy report—into a coherent analytical narrative.
- Distinguishes clearly between two related but separate problems (equal pay for equal work vs. comparable worth), keeping the reader oriented throughout.
- Uses specific statistics (the 93% vs. 75% pay differential by age group) to ground abstract policy arguments in concrete evidence.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates effective source integration: rather than summarizing each source in isolation, it weaves them together so that each successive citation builds on or complicates the previous one. Taylor (1989) establishes the theoretical frame, Perry and Gundersen (2011) supply empirical evidence, and the National Women's Law Center (2013) translates both into actionable policy — a classic funnel structure from theory to evidence to application.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens by defining compensation within HRM and introducing procedural justice. It then critiques the Equal Pay Act through the lens of comparable worth, surveys current workforce trends and pay differentials by age and education, examines the role of family obligations and self-segregation, and concludes with a multi-pronged policy framework. A brief summary recaps the two core issues and their respective remedies.
Compensation and the Gender Pay Gap
Compensation is one of the main functions of human resource management (HRM), with the goals of meeting an organization's objectives, maximizing an organization's investment in its labor force, and rewarding employees for their contributions. Ideally, HRM should implement a compensation policy that provides equitable and consistent treatment for all employees, thereby improving productivity, employee retention, and loyalty. The term procedural justice has been used to describe this process and represents, for example, whether an employee perceives a compensation policy as equitable and fair.
Comparable Worth and the Equal Pay Act
Based on Taylor's (1989) analysis, the Equal Pay Act of 1963 fails to address procedural justice because it ignores jobs with "comparable worth." The Equal Pay Act requires equal compensation for equal work, but Taylor (1989) points out that jobs with equal value to an employer or society also deserve equivalent rates of compensation, regardless of whether those comparable jobs entail the same education, skills, responsibility, and tasks. The standards used to determine comparable worth are internal and external equity, which represent pay rates that accurately reflect differences in job content within an organization and across an industry, respectively. The use of these standards, however, becomes problematic when evaluating whether there is evidence of gender discrimination within a female-dominated profession.
References
National Women's Law Center. (2013). 50 Years & Counting: The Unfinished Business of Achieving Fair Pay. Retrieved from
Perry, J., & Gundersen, D. E. (2011). American women and the gender pay gap: A changing demographic or the same old song. Advancing Women in Leadership, 31, 153–159.
Taylor, S. H. (1989). The case for comparable worth. Journal of Social Issues, 45(4), 23–37.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.