Waltz's Man, the State, and War: Three Images Explained
This paper analyzes Kenneth Waltz's foundational work Man, the State, and War (1959), examining his three "images" as competing explanations for the causes of war. The first image attributes war to human nature; the second locates its causes in the internal structure of states, with particular attention to liberal capitalism and Marxism-Leninism; and the third argues that international anarchy — the absence of a central authority — is the primary driver of conflict. The paper contrasts Waltz's systemic approach with Morgenthau's pessimism about human nature, and concludes by explaining the security dilemma and its role in generating arms races and war.
- Introduction: Waltz vs. Morgenthau: Contrasting Waltz's systemic optimism with Morgenthau's pessimism
- The First Image: Human Nature and War: Human nature as the root cause of war
- The Second Image: Domestic Structure and State Behavior: Internal state organization as a driver of conflict
- Liberal Capitalism and Marxism-Leninism as Second-Image Theories: Two major ideological frameworks and their limits
- The Third Image: International Anarchy: Anarchy and the absence of world government
- The Security Dilemma and Its Consequences: Arms races and war arising from systemic insecurity
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- It follows Waltz's own organizational logic — moving through each image in sequence — which makes the argument easy to track and demonstrates command of the source text's structure.
- The paper uses concrete historical examples (World War I, the Peloponnesian War, the rise of Athenian power) to illustrate abstract theoretical claims, grounding IR theory in recognizable events.
- It fairly represents competing theories — liberal capitalism, Marxism-Leninism, and structural realism — before explaining why Waltz privileges the third image, showing comparative analytical thinking.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates theoretical triangulation: it presents multiple competing explanatory frameworks for the same phenomenon (war), evaluates the evidence for each, and argues for the superiority of one. This technique is central to IR scholarship and shows the student can engage with theories not just descriptively but critically.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens by contrasting Waltz with Morgenthau to establish stakes, then proceeds through the three images in order. The second image receives the most space, with detailed treatment of liberal and Marxist-Leninist theory including Lenin's imperialism thesis. The paper closes with the third image, introducing anarchy and the security dilemma as Waltz's core contribution. A single bibliographic entry grounds the analysis in the primary source.
Introduction: Waltz vs. Morgenthau
The purpose of Man, the State, and War is to challenge theories that do not locate the causes of war within the international system. Unlike Hans Morgenthau, who does not believe international relations can change because human nature cannot change, Kenneth Waltz argues that by changing the nature of the system, meaningful changes can be made in international relations. To make his case, Waltz presents three hypotheses, or "images," each offering a different explanation for the causes of war.
The First Image: Human Nature and War
The first image holds that human nature is the cause of war. If human nature is evil, corrupt, and power-hungry, then the same must be true of state behavior, since states are made up of and governed by people. Bad people do bad things. Because human nature cannot be changed, war cannot be eliminated, and the best we can do is manage conflict through a proper understanding of the balance of power.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.