Skip to main content
Essay Undergraduate 2,248 words

Mourning Becomes Electra: Myth, History, and Repetition

~12 min read 6 sections Literature · Literary Analysis
Abstract

This essay examines Eugene O'Neill's Mourning Becomes Electra (1931) as a conscious re-enactment of Aeschylus's Oresteia, arguing that the play's power derives less from its mythic framework than from its engagement with historical mourning. The paper traces how O'Neill transposes the aftermath of the Trojan War onto post–Civil War America, using April 1865 and allusions to Walt Whitman's Lincoln elegy to anchor the drama in native political mythology. It further explores how O'Neill replaces Aeschylus's externalized chain of revenge with an internalized, Freudian psychology of repetition compulsion, ultimately suggesting that theater itself functions as a site of ritual re-enactment of both mythic and historical tragedy.

Key Takeaways
  • Introduction: A Play Without Electra: O'Neill's title signals ritual re-enactment over plot
  • The Oresteia's Opening Image and O'Neill's Imitation: Parallel opening images of war's unending aftermath
  • April 1865: The Civil War as the Trojan War: Historical setting links Mannon's homecoming to Lincoln's death
  • Civic Myth, Lincoln, and the House of Atreus: O'Neill ties Greek founding myth to American political mythology
  • Internalized Psychology and the Chain of Re-Enactments: Freudian psychology replaces external revenge with internalized repetition
  • Conclusion: Justice, Mourning, and Repetition Compulsion: Theater as ritual repetition of mythic and historical tragedy
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾

What makes this paper effective

  • It opens with a striking, counter-intuitive observation — that the titular character does not exist — and immediately converts this puzzle into a thesis about ritual re-enactment rather than plot-driven narrative.
  • It sustains a layered comparative argument, reading O'Neill simultaneously against Aeschylus, against American Civil War history, and against Freudian psychology, without losing the thread of its central claim.
  • Close reading of specific stage directions (lilacs, the Greek Revival portico) and dialogue passages grounds the theoretical argument in textual evidence, lending the essay analytical credibility.

Key academic technique demonstrated

The paper exemplifies comparative literary analysis across classical and modern drama. By systematically mapping O'Neill's characters and plot events onto Aeschylean counterparts while simultaneously tracking departures from that model, the essay shows how a modern work both inherits and revises its source material — a method central to influence studies and intertextuality.

Structure breakdown

The essay moves from a provocative framing observation, through close reading of parallel opening images in Aeschylus and O'Neill, to the historically specific setting of April 1865, then outward to civic and political mythology, before turning inward to Freudian psychology, and finally arriving at a conclusion that synthesizes justice, mourning, and repetition. Each section advances the argument rather than merely describing plot, and the conclusion revises the thesis upward to make a claim about theater itself as ritualized repetition.

Essay 2,248 words

Introduction: A Play Without Electra

It must have come as something of a shock for the original audience of Eugene O'Neill's Mourning Becomes Electra in 1931 to take their seats, open their programs, and discover that this extremely lengthy trilogy of plays does not actually contain a character named "Electra." This may seem like an obvious point, but it is one worth considering as we approach O'Neill's American analogue to the Oresteia of Aeschylus — the title essentially gives away the plot. Yet this would have been precisely the case with the original audience in fifth-century Athens for a Greek tragedy: they arrived already knowing the myth of Electra or Oedipus or Medea, and so what was being witnessed was, in some sense, a ritual re-enactment rather than a plot-driven narrative. Even the rare Greek tragedy that does introduce surprise into its plot, like the Orestes of Euripides, does so precisely because the audience is expected to know the normative version of the mythic story.

So in some sense, O'Neill's self-awareness that Mourning Becomes Electra is a re-telling or a ritual re-enactment is almost the most authentic thing about its status as an imitation of Greek tragedy — as with the original audience for a Greek tragedy, O'Neill's audience can more or less guess what will happen in the drama simply by hearing the title. In O'Neill's case, however, I would like to suggest that the drama acquires its resonance less from the Electra and more from the mourning, as it were: the play's status as a re-telling is actually intended to use myth in order to understand history. Mourning Becomes Electra relies on its mythic re-enactment to speak to its original audience: based on a play about the aftermath of the ten-year-long Trojan War, it is set in the immediate aftermath of the U.S. Civil War, and written a little over ten years after the conclusion of World War One. What O'Neill's play is ultimately about, then, is the ritual of mourning as a form of compulsive re-enactment: if his play is a re-enactment of Aeschylus, it also invites us to imagine every war as a re-enactment of the Trojan War.

5 Sections Hidden · 1,160 words
The Oresteia's Opening Image and O'Neill's Imitation260 words
O'Neill follows Aeschylus in beginning the drama with a highly ambiguous image — one that suggests that the conclusion of a war is not the conclusion of its aftereffects. In the Agamemnon, the first play of the Oresteia, this opening…
April 1865: The Civil War as the Trojan War310 words
The setting is April 1865. If ever there were a historical moment with the significance for…
Civic Myth, Lincoln, and the House of Atreus200 words
In some sense, then, what both Aeschylus and O'Neill are keen to capture in their tragic trilogies is the sense of history, or even the fatalism of history. Ultimately the myth that undergirds the Oresteia is a civic founding…
Internalized Psychology and the Chain of Re-Enactments230 words
O'Neill's replacement of external revenge with internalized psychological suffering owes a great deal to Sigmund Freud's theories of how human psychology responds to the trauma of war. The shell-shock and post-traumatic stress that Freud described through the concept…
Conclusion: Justice, Mourning, and Repetition Compulsion160 words
But in all these cases we get the profound sense that O'Neill's play is not just a re-enactment of the mythology of Aeschylus's trilogy, but also a play about re-enactments. The Trojan War is replaced with the American Civil War, but…
Key Concepts in This Paper
Ritual Re-Enactment Repetition Compulsion Greek Tragedy Civil War Aftermath House of Atreus Founding Myth Freudian Psychology Mourning and Justice Oresteia Parallel American Drama
Cite This Paper
PaperDue. (2026). Mourning Becomes Electra: Myth, History, and Repetition. PaperDue. https://www.paperdue.com/study-guide/mourning-becomes-electra-myth-history-repetition-185459

Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.