Willa Cather and Henry Adams on the True Artist
This essay examines the parallel views of Willa Cather and Henry Adams on what constitutes a true artist. Drawing on Cather's short story "The Sculptor's Funeral" and Adams's autobiography "The Education of Henry Adams," the paper argues that both writers identify the conflict between materialism and artistic aspiration as the central challenge facing creative individuals. Cather illustrates through contrasting characters how conformity and monetary concern can destroy an artist's spirit, while Adams draws on his own life to show that genuine artistry demands curiosity, perseverance, and indifference to social approval. Together, their works form a cohesive vision of the artist as someone who must rise above financial and societal pressures to remain true to an inner creative calling.
- Introduction: The Question of True Artistry: Cather's interest in defining the true artist
- Cather's Vision: Materialism vs. Artistic Ideals: Art versus money as central conflict in Cather
- Conformity as the Enemy of the Artist: Conformity destroys the artist's spirit
- Contrasting Characters in The Sculptor's Funeral: Jim Laird and the Sculptor as foils
- Henry Adams and the Artist's Inner Life: Adams on curiosity, perseverance, and indifference to fame
- Shared Convictions: Cather and Adams in Dialogue: Common ground between Cather and Adams
- Conclusion: Both writers define artistry beyond material success
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper builds its argument through direct textual evidence, quoting both primary texts and secondary critics to support each claim about artistic character.
- It draws a clear and meaningful parallel between two seemingly different writers — a fiction writer and an autobiographer — showing that their core convictions about artistry converge.
- The use of contrasting characters within Cather's story (Jim Laird vs. the Sculptor) gives the argument a concrete, illustrative anchor that grounds the abstract theme of artistic integrity.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates comparative literary analysis by reading two works across genres — short fiction and autobiography — against a shared thematic lens. Rather than treating each work in isolation, the student synthesizes critical commentary with close reading to show how both Cather and Adams arrive at the same conclusion about what separates a true artist from someone who surrenders to social and material pressures.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens by establishing Cather's central thesis in "The Sculptor's Funeral," then unpacks her argument through the themes of materialism and conformity before turning to the contrasting characters who embody those ideas. The second half introduces Henry Adams, traces his parallel convictions about curiosity and indifference to public opinion, and closes by synthesizing the two writers' shared vision of authentic artistry.
Introduction: The Question of True Artistry
Willa Cather was seriously interested in the question of what exactly makes a person a true artist. Her short stories, including "The Sculptor's Funeral," revolve around this thesis as she attempts to unearth the defining characteristics of a genuine artistic temperament. In her effort to highlight the traits that set an artist apart from the rest of society, Cather examines the conflict between materialism and artistic aspiration — a conflict she regards as the single most important force affecting an artist's life and soul. As Arnold observes, "The story stands as one of Cather's most powerful treatments of the conflict between artistic ideals and materialistic value systems" (Arnold 1077).
In this story, Cather carefully illuminates the true spirit of an artist in order to prove that without possessing such a spirit, the artist risks ruining his own life and doing a complete injustice to his talents. Cather maintains that it is only when an artist accepts the fact that he will be misunderstood — that a majority of people will never grasp his passion for art — that he can rise above those considerations and achieve his artistic goals.
Cather's Vision: Materialism vs. Artistic Ideals
Cather's work insists that an artist should not be concerned with monetary gain, because his true purpose in life is to express himself through his art. The materialistic value system that dominates ordinary society represents, in her view, a fundamental threat to creative integrity. Poupard captures this well: "Cather's passionate idealism and her disdain for materialistic aspiration leave little doubt that, in her view, it was only perfection that should concern the true artist" (Poupard 91).
Cather does not present this conflict as abstract or philosophical. She grounds it in the lived choices of her characters, making clear that every compromise an artist makes with the material world carries real consequences for his creative soul.
References
Arnold, Marilyn. "Willa Cather." Critical Survey of Short Fiction, vol. 3. Ed. Frank N. McGill. Englewood Cliffs: Salem Press, 1981. 1075–1081.
Brown, E.K. "Troll Garden, Goblin Market (1902–1905)."
Poupard, Dennis, ed. Introduction to "Willa Cather." Twentieth-Century Literary Criticism. Detroit: Gale Research Company, 1983. 90–91.
Adams, Henry. The Education of Henry Adams. 1838.
Cather, Willa. The Sculptor's Funeral.
Already a member? Log in
Unlock the rest of this paper
135,000+ research papers · AI writing tools · Plagiarism & AI detection
7-Day Pass
Does not renew
Get 7-Day PassMonthly
Renews at $12.99/month until canceled
Start MonthlyAnnual
Renews at $99/year until canceled
Start Annual- Unlimited AI writing tools
- Plagiarism and AI text detection tool
Plan details
Unlimited AI writing tools are for individual, non-automated use and are subject to our Terms of Service and abuse-prevention measures.
TextChecker scans: 3 during the 7-Day Pass, or 5 per month with Monthly and Annual.
Prices exclude applicable tax.
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.