Verified Document

Controversial Issue Debate Public Safety Vs. Civil Essay

¶ … controversial issue debate Public Safety vs. Civil Rights. Prepare a word paper cultural diversity race relate public safety efforts law enforcement security services The debate over the confrontation between public safety and civil rights is nowadays considered a subject that may take the headlines in most newspapers and news television channels. This is largely due to the fact that more and more cases of abuse or racial discontent are placed in the framework of this wide debate over the need to feel secure in public but at the same time to ensure the civil rights of citizens, regardless or race, ethnicity, or color of their skin.

One of the main elements of the debate focuses on the ability of law enforcement mechanisms such as the police to have the mandate to react depending on immigration status. More precisely, "the discussion of cross-deputization (mandating that police officers enforce immigration policies) is often framed as a referendum on civil rights and racial politics. Those who oppose cross-deputization often maintain that asking police to target individuals based on their immigration...

Those who support cross-deputization, on the other hand, argue that enforcing immigration laws is necessary to maintain a culture of lawfulness and to preserve public safety" (Epstein and Goff, 2011). The question arises on the actual rights of the citizens and if these rights are more valuable than the need to protect public safety.
After the 9/11 events, immigration policies have sharpened to such an extend as to limit the possibilities of such attacks to take place again. In this sense, in the public opinion's eyes a discontent with immigrants and in particular those of Muslim origin increased dramatically. The perception became rather focused on the belief that Muslims are representatives of a terrorist concept and means of action. Therefore, the need to further improve the abilities to ensure public safety increased.

There have been numerous cases in which immigrants were targeted and mocked as a result of discriminatory actions. One clear example was the 2005 cartoon scandal in Europe that triggered a wide attention on the way in which the freedom of…

Sources used in this document:
References

Epstein, L. And Phillip Atiba Goff. (2011) "Safety or Liberty?: The Bogus Trade-Off of Cross-Deputization Policy" Analyses of Social Issues and Public Policy, Vol. 11, No. 1, pp. 314 -- 324. Available at http://cple.psych.ucla.edu/images/uploads/safety_or_liberty_epstein_goff.pdf

House of Representatives. (2009) "Public Safety And Civil Rights Implications Of State And Local Enforcement Of Federal Immigration Laws" Committee On The Judiciary House Of Representatives One Hundred Eleventh Congress. First Session. April 2, Available online at http://judiciary.house.gov/hearings/printers/111th/111-19_48439.PDF
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Civil Liberties, Habeas Corpus, War Terror Subtopics:
Words: 1862 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Civil Liberties, Habeas Corpus, War Terror subtopics: Explain historical evolution habeas corpus, including English American traditions. The explanation evolution American tradition include general meaning habeas corpus U. Habeas Corpus The principle of habeas corpus promotes the idea that a person needs to be brought before a court in order for him or her to be judged before he or she is provided with a sentence. Habeas corpus is Latin for "that you

Controversy Over Lincoln's First Emancipation
Words: 3426 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

" Without a fundamental leg of the Southern structure taken out from underneath the Confederacy, Lincoln gained a strategic advantage. He did so using complete military preconceptions in order to carefully avoid breaking the peacetime rules and regulations set forth by the American Constitution. Thanks to the free labor of the slaves, the South had more than enough white men willing to fight. Tons of able-bodied young men enlisted and left

Capital Punishment the Issue of
Words: 2158 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

What happens at this point is the issues are then prioritized, and the death penalty can potentially be considered less important than personal taxes, abortion, or whatever other issue the voter deems as important. This results in an extremely clouded concept of what the majority of the population actually supports in this country -- not just on the death penalty, but any issue. Ultimately this point of this argument,

1st Amendment Issues a Highly Controversial Decision
Words: 655 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

1st Amendment Issues A highly controversial decision rendered on January 21st of this year by the Supreme Court, affirming the right of corporations and other organizations to enjoy consideration as "persons" and the 1st amendment protections afforded by that status, threatens to undermine the foundation of this country's democratic process. With their closely contested 5-4 decision in the case of Citizens United v. FEC, the high court's conservative members have

Law Enforcement Priorities and Public Sector Leadership
Words: 5421 Length: 18 Document Type: Essay

Undocumented Immigrants in Gainesville The city of Gainesville has a population of about 54,000 and of these, approximately 3,200 are illegal aliens. The law enforcement community in this city is charged with protecting these undocumented aliens on the one hand and enforcing illegal immigrant laws on the other. To the extent that undocumented residents are afraid that the police will enforce the latter may be the extent to which they are

State of Habeas Corpus in 2014 America
Words: 1856 Length: 5 Document Type: Research Paper

Civil Liberties, Habeas Corpus, GWOT The legal right known as "habeas corpus" is what protects a citizen from being suddenly seized and arrested for no reason, and locked up without trial. It is considered to be a foundation of the modern legal system, and without it there is no guarantee that arrest, imprisonment, or even capital punishment may not be practiced essentially on a whim. The right is officially enshrined in

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now