Verified Document

Parents Definitely Have A Case, Essay

Toxcio's experts, on the other hand, believe that evidence is incomplete and that further, costly studies need to be implemented to show the connection. It seems to me that (a) if the biophysicist is indeed as credentialed and qualified as said and (b) if her studies are as empirical as stated from peer-reviewed scientific journals, bearing reliable evidence, than the families do, indeed have a case. This is because even thoguh further research may need to be conducted (as per Toxico's scientists) to assess strength of the research, the evidence that exists at the moment seems to show an almost undisputed association between the children's cancer and the toxic emission.

Secondly, the biophysicist also reinforces her case with other empirical evidence -- and empirical evidence is that which is required by the courts - of the significant statistical incidence of this rare cancer in the neighborhood. In both cases, her testimony lies on popularly accepted, empirical, and reliable scientific evidence and measures. These are the matrices requested by both state and federal court systems.

Even though they are "learned and well-credentialed biophysicists" and their assumptions will, accordingly, be listened to a court of law, a the end of the day, their failure to produce popular and solidly acceptable scientific evidence to support their assumptions will not allow Toxico to win the case. Since deductions and inferences are listened to but not accepted as conclusive evidence, it seems to me that the families have high prospects of winning their civil suit and criminal prosecution against Toxico in both New York and federal courts. This is particularly so since Toxcio violated federal and state requirements in inappropriately burying their toxic containers in the first case. I would advise the families to go ahead.
Sources

WILLIAM DAUBERT, et ux., etc., et al., PETITIONERS v. MERRELL DOW PHARMACEUTICALS, INC. 1993

The People of the State of New York, Respondent, v. George Wesley, Appellant, Court of Appeals of the State of…

Sources used in this document:
Sources

WILLIAM DAUBERT, et ux., etc., et al., PETITIONERS v. MERRELL DOW PHARMACEUTICALS, INC. 1993

The People of the State of New York, Respondent, v. George Wesley, Appellant, Court of Appeals of the State of New York., 1994.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Parents Matter, Don't They " Multitudes of Research
Words: 2061 Length: 6 Document Type: Research Paper

Parents Matter, Don't They?" Multitudes of research have been done to answer this seemingly simple question. The question is really quite basic; which has the most profound affect on a child's behavior and personality, nature or nurture (heredity vs. environment)? Behaviorists argue that the parents' actions and methods of child rearing have a direct bearing on the outcome. Environment definitely makes a difference. Some geneticists, however, strongly disagree. According to

Case Study: Struggling Reader
Words: 3505 Length: 11 Document Type: Term Paper

Working with the individual child in my case study was definitely enlightening in terms of understanding the struggling reader more generally. I think probably the most salient fact I learned about Jake -- the one which really occasioned the most generalized breakthrough in terms of my own understanding about this sort of educational difficulty -- was to observe specifically and intimately the differences in Jake's experience. Vlach and Bursie (2010)

E Coli Case Study the
Words: 851 Length: 3 Document Type: Case Study

coli outbreak, with no known restaurant our social event being in common with any cases. This suggests that a grocery store supplier most likely had a contaminated batch of either lettuce or alfalfa. This E. coli, was most likely transmitted by a food handler somewhere along the grocery supply chain. Produce suppliers should be targeted as the next probable source of the virus. Question 8A Finding controls for this study would

Performed by the Student. The Case Study
Words: 2373 Length: 7 Document Type: Case Study

performed by the student. The case study took place in the classroom environment, as part of the students part time job in Early Childhood Education, where there are normative and special education students present. The case study objectives involved problem solving, strategy implementation, and differentiated instruction. The specific area of focus in the case study is difficulty with literacy or reading. This was a challenging situation because the case study

Life Span Case Study Project:
Words: 3503 Length: 13 Document Type: Case Study

Interview No. 3 - "Bill" (age 54 years): The interview with Bill took place immediately following the conclusion of the interview with Anne who left the dining room after being thanked for her participation and the refreshments. Bill is a semi-retired disabled veteran of the U.S. Air Force with Vietnam-era service; he continues to work part-time as a pizza delivery driver. Because the couple's ownership of a shared computer with high-speed

Vaccine and Austism Parents Have Every Right
Words: 654 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Vaccine and Austism Parents have every right to be concerned about their child's health and well- being and for this reason; it's not very hard to fathom why they got seriously worried over an important research study that established a link between MMR vaccine and autism. The research was not ordinary. It was published in one of the most prestigious medical journals of Britain, The Lancet, and was written by a

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now