Sign Up Now
Get instant access to over 1 million+ study documents
OR
Already registered? click here to login
By creating your account, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and student honor code.
Captain John Smith
Was John Smith a writer that scholars and researchers today can rely on for an accurate recounting of history? Can his account of events be trusted? What were his strengths and weaknesses as a writer? What is the reason that he writes in the third person? These are questions that will be addressed in this paper.
According to scholarly research that has been published about Smith and about his writing, he was not a very good writer and indeed he plagiarized in many of his writings, although it is also true that in some instances he mentioned the name of the author that he had "borrowed" from at the end of the piece. He would sometimes mention the author he was copying from at the end of the writing, but readers cannot know exactly what text he stole from whom because he did not footnote or otherwise make clear through quotes that it was another person's work.
The late Everett H. Emerson, who was a leading member of the Society of Early Americanists, and a respected editor and historian, writes that it is "difficult not to have strong feelings about Captain John Smith" (Emerson, 1971, p. 7). In his book Captain John Smith,...
But while Emerson admits that in one sense Smith "wrote well," Emerson adds, "nearly everything is flawed" (p. 7). Smith "very much needed an editor," Emerson asserts; in fact Smith did have an editor and that helped produce what Emerson describes as Smith's "most consistently good piece, 'The Description of Virginia'" (p. 7). Emerson writes (p. 7) that Smith's literary weaknesses are only too apparent: obscurity resulting from omission of necessary words, lack of sense of form, bad grammar, an inability to present reports objectively."
On page 98, Emerson places Smith's descriptions of his travels to Tartary (a region in eastern Europe occupied by Mongols in the 13th & 14th centuries) side-by-side with copy written by Friar William of Rubruck four hundred years earlier. Clearly Smith stole descriptions word-for-word from Friar William. Moreover, Smith "lost immediacy" in his writing because he used the third person, Emerson asserts (p. 100). Why did he use the third person? Emerson believes that Smith was…
Works Cited
Emerson, Everett H. (1971). Captain John Smith. New York: Twayne Publishers, Inc.
Smith, Bradford. (1953). Captain John Smith: His Life & Legend. New York: J.B. Lippincott
Company.
Vaughan, Alden T. (1975). American Genesis: Captain John Smith and the Founding of Virginia. Boston: Little, Brown and Company.
However the text was also written to promote both the New World colonies and Smith himself, and these strains often appear stronger than the push towards historical objectivity. It could be said, then, that the real purpose behind the writing of the General History was to advance Smith's own career and image back in England, rather than to provide other people of his day an accurate description of life
John Smith Founding the Virginia Colony John Smith John Smith founding Virginia Colony Barbour,(1969) a historian whose studies mostly have been on the Virginia colony and its' earliest founder, describe John Smith as a fellow author, explorer and an English solider, who before his death in 21st June, the year 1631 was knighted by Prince Bathory of Transylvanian for defeating and killing the Turkish commanders. Barbour further ads on that John Smith would
That means that out of every five children who are now living in the United States, one lives in poverty. That is one too many. This is just unacceptable. Poverty does not only have a direct effect on the financial backing for these children and their families, but it has much higher physical, social, and emotional complications. Children who grow up poor, as a result have had worse access
Captain Smith by Pocahontas Antonio Capellano's sculpture The Preservation of Captain Smith by Pocahontas (1825) is still in the Capitol Rotunda along with other works of the same period such as William Penn's Treaty with the Indians and The Landing of the Pilgrims, although they no longer resonate with audiences in the same way as they did in the 19th Century. In the 20th and 21st Centuries, more sophisticated and educated
There is a record of a similar account found in a chronicle of the Spanish voyager to the new world Hernando De Soto (134). Afterward, in Smith's account, Smith says that Powhatan told Smith he was now a 'friend' which would be an unusual way of describing a man Powhatan actually rather than ritually intended to kill. Powhatan then invited him to return to the English settlement to find
Like the Jamestown colony, the Plymouth colony also had dealings with the Native Americans. In order to maintain peace, however, the colonists made a treaty with the Native Americans. Upon finding a Native American who could speak English, the Plymouth colony succeeded in passing a peace treaty with the Native Americans, which, among other things, allowed the colonists and the Native Americans to make a security pact. Other than