Preservation Of Captain Smith By Pocahontas 1825 Term Paper

Length: 5 pages Sources: 2 Subject: Native Americans Type: Term Paper Paper: #95911179 Related Topics: Indian Removal Act, Assimilation, Art Of Protest, Nationalism

Excerpt from Term Paper :

Captain Smith by Pocahontas

Antonio Capellano's sculpture The Preservation of Captain Smith by Pocahontas (1825) is still in the Capitol Rotunda along with other works of the same period such as William Penn's Treaty with the Indians and The Landing of the Pilgrims, although they no longer resonate with audiences in the same way as they did in the 19th Century. In the 20th and 21st Centuries, more sophisticated and educated viewers at least would realize that these are all the product of an era of Western expansion and a highly romanticized view of history that is heavily tinged with racism and white nationalism. When these sculptures were first commissioned by the U.S. government, the early republic was engaged in westward expansion that would result in the destruction, displacement or removal of most Native Americans, a process that most white Americans of the era regarded as necessary and beneficial. All of the official public art and sculpture of the time adhered strictly to the standard narrative of the progress of Christianity and white civilization, which would overawe and overpower the Indians. Native American would literally be forced to bow down to the superior power, drive and intelligence of this white civilization, which Pocahontas is depicted as recognizing when she saves Smith from being clubbed to death. She realizes that the only real choice for the Natives is to adapt and assimilate to the white world or face eventual destruction. In addition, she also accepts that Smith is a heroic white man, physically, intellectually and sexually superior to Indian males, although in the 19th Century this was also highly problematic because of the implication of interracial sex, 'half-breed' offspring and miscegenation of the races.

Sculpture and paintings depicting American Indians in the 19th Century followed certain predictable themes and patterns, particularly the idea of the destruction and disappearance of a supposedly inferior race by the Western march of white civilization. Two sculptures that once decorated the Capitol, Horatio Greenough's The Rescue and Luigi Persico's Discovery of America, both commissioned by the government in 1836, were so explicitly racist that Congress finally removed them in 1958 after years of protests by Native Americans. The Rescue was finally destroyed in a moving accident in 1976 and never repaired, although few in contemporary times have ever mourned its loss. In the 19th Century, however, these sculptures "embodied...


At the time, the main controversy in Congress was over whether an Italian immigrant like Persico should be receiving federal patronage at all, which is why Greenough's sculpture was also commissioned. Persico portrayed Columbus stepping boldly ashore to claim the Americas for Europe, with a mostly nude female 'savage' kneeling before him and gazing at his face in awe, terror and wonder. Columbus was "the superior of the Indian princess in every respect," just as Smith was over Pocahontas, and he also had a vision of empire than spanned continents (Fryd 99). This was the era of Manifest Destiny after all, with the annexation of Texas and Oregon and the conquest of the northern half of Mexico, while the place of the Native Americans in this vast scheme of things had been decided by the Indian Removal Act of 1830 -- passed by the same Congress not very long before it commissioned these sculptures.

Greenough modeled The Rescue after the Laocoon, only in his work a gigantic and powerful white pioneer had captured a lithe young Indian who had been threatening physical and sexual violence against his wife and daughter. This youth was also "surprised and awestruck by the pioneer's strength and restraining power," as Greenough intended (Fryd 106). In a letter to Secretary of State John Forsythe in 1837, he explained that his sculpture conveyed the same message and symbolism as William Penn's Treaty with the Indians and Preservation of Captain Smith by Pocahontas in that he had "endeavored to convey the idea of the triumph of the whites over the savage tribes" (Fyrd 107). John Smith's captivity narrative was the first in North America, and somewhat unusual in featuring an adult male instead of women and children, but several thousand more followed it over the next 200 years, including Mary Rowlandson and Peter Williamson. By the 19th Century these captivity narratives had become standardized and sensationalized, with a particular emphasis on rape, mayhem and senseless cruelty and violence to attract a mass audience.…

Sources Used in Documents:


Fryd, Vivien Green. "Two Sculptures for the Capitol" in Mary Ann Calo (ed). Critical Issues in American Art: A Book of Readings. Perseus Books, 1998: 93-108.

Scheckel, Susan. The Insistence of the Indian: Race and Nationalism in Nineteenth-Century American Culture. Princeton University Press, 1998.

Tilton, Robert S. Pocahontas: The Evolution of an American Narrative. Cambridge University Press, 1994.

Cite this Document:

"Preservation Of Captain Smith By Pocahontas 1825" (2012, April 09) Retrieved March 21, 2023, from

"Preservation Of Captain Smith By Pocahontas 1825" 09 April 2012. Web.21 March. 2023. <>

"Preservation Of Captain Smith By Pocahontas 1825", 09 April 2012, Accessed.21 March. 2023,

Related Documents
Westward Expansion and Manifest Destiny
Words: 4448 Length: 12 Pages Topic: American History Paper #: 93891455

" In other words, republicanism in an expanding state would inevitably lead to more despotic, aristocratic, and monarchical regimes. Hence, if the U.S. were to follow a policy of expansion, it would, at least, theoretically conflict with its republican origins. Interestingly, one of the leading proponents of republicanism, Thomas Jefferson had become the third U.S. President after an unexpected electoral crisis in the elections of 1800. He was a great champion

Westward Expansion Represents As Much
Words: 664 Length: 2 Pages Topic: American History Paper #: 76165250

Moreover, Westward expansion also meant putting off the resolution of slavery. Slavery continued in the United States until the 1860s. In fact, Westward expansion was one of the issues that gave rise to the deep rifts between north and south, between free and slave states. How to address slavery in newly acquired territories became one of the most poignant political and social issues in nineteenth century America. Yet another

Westward Expansion the Idea of
Words: 644 Length: 2 Pages Topic: American History Paper #: 6833103

While Taylor believed that the Union was not threatened by this decision, it became alarmingly apparent that the North and South ideas would differ greatly. The conflict had escalated regarding the slavery laws and the newly added territories that some of the Southern senators at the time -- Jefferson Davis, John C. Calhoun, and William H. Seward -- would fight for "equal position in the territories," to protect the

Westward Expansion and the Growth
Words: 1248 Length: 4 Pages Topic: American History Paper #: 48945853

Mercifully, this period oversaw the end of the horrible Catch-22 known as debtor's prison, were people were imprisoned for debt, and then kept in the prisons for life because they had no way of earning money to free themselves from their financial obligations. Also, Dorothea Dix "compiled a comprehensive report on the state of the mentally ill in Massachusetts. The report claimed that hundreds of insane women were chained like

Native Americans and Westward Expansion
Words: 401 Length: 1 Pages Topic: Native Americans Paper #: 63362934

Although they reacted with sorrow, they also attempted to preserve their culture. For example, some even ground the bones of their ancestors and sewed them into their clothing (Watson 1999). A similar story of Native American's peaceful reactions that were exploited by force is the history of Chief Joseph. This early recruit to Christianity was the chief mediator of peace between whites and his tribe, the Nez Perce, but when

Imperialism Westward Expansion: Laying the
Words: 852 Length: 2 Pages Topic: American History Paper #: 63842335

For instance, the United States aided in the installation of Fidel Castro in Cuba, and then initiated a trade embargo against him when his policies did not meet their expectations. Ronald Reagan's involvement in the Iran-Contra affair suggested United States imperial action in both Latin America and the Middle East. Furthermore, while the United States' intervention in Latin America after the 1800s has been primarily motivated by a desire