Ethics of Virus Research Self-Replicating Essay

Download this Essay in word format (.doc)

Note: Sample below may appear distorted but all corresponding word document files contain proper formatting

Excerpt from Essay:

Intent to perform a greater good would not affect the possibility of being exposed to a prison sentence of up to 20 years and a fine of up to $250,000, plus possible penalties under state law.

Montana compares this legislation with that of the regulation of firearms. It is not the mere possession of malicious code that is criminalized, but the use and the damage to computer systems and association economic losses that are the focal point of the law. Computer code, even MMC, is considered intellectual property and carries legal protections similar to books or sound recordings. It is also considered a form of speech and therefore is also offered protection under the Constitution's First Amendment. However, this protection is limited, just as 'free speech' is limited, especially in instances when this speech interferes with the protection of the public welfare -- as is the case with the release of a worm or virus. Although Bush, Ford and Boulatov's virus would have benefits, damage and economic impact would occur and the public welfare would be in jeopardy.

Current laws would have to be changed significantly to allow Bush, Ford and Boulatov's recommendation to take place. Intent would have to be factored into the law. The scope of the effects of the released MMC would have to be regulated as well. International legal cooperation would have to be secured, as this new controlled burn type MMC would affect users around the globe. Obviously, the issue would no longer be as black and white as it is legally today.

Safeguards that Would Need to be Put Into Place:

The primary safeguard that would need to be put into place would be regulation of who is releasing this new controlled burn type MMC. Leaving the writing and release of this code to anyone and everyone would give carte blanche to virus authors who could release virulent code under the auspices of this new program. Attacks just under the limit of legislated effects would be rampant. Therefore, it would make sense to either limit release to either operating software developers, where MMC would only be allowed as it applied to their own product, or licensing and monitoring certain software developers, to help avoid abuse. An additional safeguard that could be put in place would be the requirement that a patch be made available for the worm or virus, to those vulnerable to the threat, prior to its release. Of course, these safeguards do not counteract the ethical concerns with this recommendation.


In the end, Bush, Ford and Boulatov's comparison of the virtual environment to the natural environment is an interesting concept. The theory that, like forest fires, worms and viruses could be utilized to ensure diversity and resiliency has merit. However, the ethical concerns contradict the overriding ethical code to do no harm while also introducing relationships with possible conflicting interests. Current law does not allow for this controlled burn type MMC release, and as such an alternative including increased education and awareness or mandatory patch updates may be a less ethically-challenged solution. Even if the law were changed to allow for a 'greater good' intent to be legalized, safeguards would need to be put into place to ensure 'legal' MMC release wasn't rampant and patches were available to users.

Works Cited

Ford, R., Bush, M., & Boulatov, a."Internet Instability and Disturbance: Goal or Menace?" Proceedings of the 2005 Workshop on New Security Paradigms. 2005: p. 3-8.

Frohmann, B. "Subjectivity and Information Ethics." Journal of the American Society for Information Science & Technology. 59(2) Jan 2008: p. 267-277.

Johnson, M. & Rogers, K. "The Fraud Act 2006: The E-Crime Prosecutor's Champion or the Creator of a New Inchoate Offence?" International Review of Law, Computers & Technology. 21(3) Nov 2007: p.. 295-304.

Ledin, G. "Not Teaching Viruses and Worms is Harmful." Communications of the ACM. 48(1) Jan 2005: p. 144.

Malibiran, B. "Are We Ready for Another Love Bug?" Ateneo Law Journal. 53(1) Jun 2008: p. 32-104.

Montana, J. "Viruses and the Law: Why the Law is Ineffective." Information Management Journal. 34(4) Oct 2000: p. 57-59.

National Information Infrastructure Protection Act of 1996. 2009. United States Department of Justice. April 11, 2009 .

Panko, R. "Slammer: The First Blitz Worm." Communications of AIS. 2003(11) 2003:…[continue]

Cite This Essay:

"Ethics Of Virus Research Self-Replicating" (2009, April 11) Retrieved December 7, 2016, from

"Ethics Of Virus Research Self-Replicating" 11 April 2009. Web.7 December. 2016. <>

"Ethics Of Virus Research Self-Replicating", 11 April 2009, Accessed.7 December. 2016,

Other Documents Pertaining To This Topic

  • City of Hope Team Develops

    The development of a bio-economy capable of supplying the world's energy demand is where the synthetic biologists wish to take this the next step. Additionally, biologists are able to develop a sort of biological acolyte from the principles of synthetic biology, involving synthesizing DNA in combination with the raw building blocks of genetics. A new platform for different biological life form is essentially, what these biologists have discovered. According to

  • Nanomachines the Science of Molecular Size Machines

    Nanomachines The Science of molecular size machines and its engineering designs and constructions until late 1980s were not considered practicable. Nanotechnology, according to the leading exponents of that time were neither feasible nor viable, due to the fact of total structural difference of the constituent of nano-molecular device i.e. Atoms from the mechanical objects of every day life. The essential components of engineering mechanics i.e. cogwheels, gears or motors could not

  • Nanotechnology All Manufactured Products Are Made From

    Nanotechnology All manufactured products are made from atoms, with the properties of these products based on how atoms are put together. By rearranging coal atoms, diamonds are formed. Similarly, by rearranging the atoms in sand and adding some trace elements, electronic chips are developed. In time, it will be possible to more readily connect the fundamental building blocks of nature. The word "nanotechnology" is used to describe when the characteristic dimensions

  • Cloning the Term Cloning Is

    and, that is, for how much longer should this experimentation be tolerated given the animal suffering involved and the deliberate creation of abominations of nature. Currently, many countries around the world have banned the use of reproductive, human cloning on ethical grounds, while allowing research to continue in the area of therapeutic cloning and reproductive cloning of animals. Of course, there are also countries that are permitting the development of

  • Cloning Is the Production of

    Scientific research and specifically cloning is protected as a first amendment right, coupled with the benefits available with this technology, and the unimaginable benefits that can be reaped in the future, cloning is the hope of the future, despite the worries of critics. References After Dolly: The Uses and Misuses of Human Cloning." The Futurist 40(4) Jul-Aug 2006: p. 62. InfoTrac database. Thomson-Gale. University of Phoenix, Phoenix, AZ. July 5, 2006

  • Corporate Social Responsibility in Indian Pharmaceutical Industry

    Corporate Social Responsibility in Indian Pharmaceutical Industry An Exploratory Study Outlook of CSR in India History of CSR in India Philanthropy in Indian Society Modern Form of CSR in Indian Society Profile of Indian Pharmaceutical Industry Rationale for Selection CSR Activities by Indian Pharmaceutical Companies Major Influences Over CSR Activities Scope of CSR Activities Comparison of Indian & Western Pharmaceutical Companies This research paper is concerned with the recent practices of Indian pharmaceutical companies in the field of corporate social responsibility. For

  • Effect of Forgiveness on Health

    forgiveness on human health. In its simplest form, the purpose of the study is to evaluate human psychological stress that might constitute a risk factor for heart disease. Further, the study will also evaluate the impact of forgiveness on heart disease. However, such a simple dissertation clearly demands further definition. What, exactly, do we signify when we speak of heart disease? What is properly considered as forgiveness? What impact

Read Full Essay
Copyright 2016 . All Rights Reserved