Exercise And Health Article Critique

PAGES
2
WORDS
684
Cite

Weight Loss Learning Disabilities and Juvenile Delinquency

Popular vs. scientific press: Weight loss studies

The popular media often sensationalizes the cautious findings of scientific research, in an effort to catch the casual reader's attention at all costs -- even if the cost is the truth. This can be seen in the CNN piece "Exercise lengthens your life -- even if you're overweight," a title designed to communicate an unequivocally positive message in an America where the majority of the population is overweight or obese. CNN reports the findings of a recent scientific journal article in which researchers suggest that moderate exercise can add years to a person's life, regardless of weight status. Although the CNN article does not directly misstate the findings of the original journal article on which it was based, it neglects to mention some of the caution of the studies' authors regarding an excessive BMI.

The actual findings of the article do suggest that some form of exercise is better than no exercise...

...

Specifically, it was found that physical exercise in the form of 75 min/wk was associated with a gain of 1.8 years of a subject's lifespan vs. no exercise at all. However, higher levels of activity were associated with greater gains -- with a gain of 4.5 years for 450+ min/wk (Moore et al. 2012: 1). The positive benefits of exercise were reflected in increased longevity for all participants, regardless of BMI group.
In the CNN piece, one of the senior authors of the study is quoted as saying: "if you are active, the results suggest that you ... have more of a benefit than someone who is not heavy but not active" (Hagan 2010). However, strictly speaking, that is an incomplete summary and was not what the researchers actually discovered. The benefits are potentially greater for someone who is thin and physically active and the title of the CNN article misleadingly suggests that moderate exercise for an overweight person is 'enough' to reap the full health benefits. In the actual text of the article itself, the study notes "we…

Sources Used in Documents:

References

Hagan, Caitlin. (2012). Exercise lengthens your life - even if you're overweight.

CNN. Retrieved: http://thechart.blogs.cnn.com/2012/11/06/exercise-lengthens-your-life-even-if-youre-overweight/

Moore SC, Patel AV, Matthews CE, Berrington de Gonzalez A, Park Y, et al. (2012).

Leisure time physical activity of moderate to vigorous intensity and mortality: A large pooled cohort analysis. PLoS Med 9(11): e1001335.


Cite this Document:

"Exercise And Health" (2013, April 05) Retrieved April 19, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/exercise-and-health-101906

"Exercise And Health" 05 April 2013. Web.19 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/exercise-and-health-101906>

"Exercise And Health", 05 April 2013, Accessed.19 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/exercise-and-health-101906

Related Documents

Physical activity is good for getting rid of stress and this is predominantly true of yoga. On account of the awareness required, ones daily troubles, both large and small, seem to melt away throughout the time they are doing yoga. This supplies a much-needed break from ones stressors, as well as aiding in putting things into perception. The importance yoga places on being in the moment can also aid

Health Benchmarking Discuss barriers to health and safety benchmarking Barriers to carrying out a safety health bench marking exercise "Health and safety benchmarking is a planned process by which an organization compares its health and safety processes and performance with others to learn how to: reduce accidents and ill-health; improve compliance with health and safety law; and/or cut compliance costs" (Health and safety benchmarking: Improving together, 1999, HSE: 1). Just like assessing one's

Heart rates in children may reach 220 or even 225 before puberty, but tend to fall to around 200 in their late teens, so the coach should not worry on finding such high rates in exercising youngsters." (Sharp, 1) This is a demonstration of the distinct physical response of the youth's body, justifying a framing of youth physical activity as separate, different and demanding its own specific scientific attention. This

Health Benefits of Exercise Everyone knows that exercise is good for health, but not many people exercise on a regular basis. Today, in the United States, there are very many obese people, who are basically inactive and who do not exercise. It must be acknowledged that exercise is indeed beneficial to the long-term as well as the short-term health of a person, and unless one undertakes some form of exercise on

Health Care Law Ethics
PAGES 1 WORDS 383

Healthcare Health Care Law Ethics Health care over the years has become one of the most important debates to take place within the United States of America. This fact holds particularly true for the major part of the Obama Administrations whose New Health Care policies has been criticized extremely (Zhi Qu, 2010). The world, however, is still waiting for the final curtain to rise and to witness the climax which would be

Health of Indigenous Australian Using Ecological and Holistic Health Paradigm Patterns of health and illness Physical Health Mental Health Spiritual Health Social Health Impact of Broader Environments Natural Built Social Economic Political Critical Reflection Health is a basic component of human life that comprises of multiple facets. The description of health has witnessed dramatic change during past few years, as it has become a holistic phenomenon. Previously, it was considered that a healthy person is the one who does not suffer from any