Music as Motivation in Running essay

Download this essay in word format (.doc)

Note: Sample below may appear distorted but all corresponding word document files contain proper formatting

Excerpt from essay:

Music Motivation

Music as a Motivator in Running: A Literature Review and Experimental Research Design Proposal

Ever since Sony first introduced the Walkman, listening to music on the go has become something that many individuals take for granted during a variety of activities. When tapes went out of style the Discman and competing portable CD players came along, and then the iPod and other portable mp3 players arrived on the stage. One demographic that has a very high proportion of portable music listeners is joggers and runners -- indeed, people engaged in exercise of any sort simply for the sake of that exercise are often plugged into their music device as a motivating force. This has led to many studies regarding the motivational role music plays in running, though some questions still remain. This paper will examine several studies on this topic and propose a further experiment to increase knowledge in this area.

One study conducted in 2004 examined what effect the specific type of music had on motivation during running, finding that it didn't really matter what type of music was playing for runners in terms of their self-stated motivation (Tenenbaum et al. 2004). Slightly less than a third of study participants reported feeling better initial focus and increased motivation to continue running, although the researchers observed no physiological changes brought about in participants when listening to the various types of music or no music at all (Tenenbaum et al. 2004). The conclusion reached in this study is that music might be psychologically motivating, but it doesn't have a physical effect on runners (Tenenbaum et al. 2004).

Other researchers have focused more on the technology aspects of the motivational music issue in running and athletics, rather than the physiological or psychological features. Wijnalda et al. (2005) set out to design an effective computer-assisted personalized music system specifically designed for use by athletes and exercisers, primarily focused on running. Through the course of this technology's development and the research concerning the interface's construction, certain details regarding how runners interact with music and what motivational elements they perceive have been brought to light, and the research indicates that while slightly different motivational effects are reported, runners and other users of this product all experienced greater enjoyment of the activity (Wijnalda et al. 2005).

Biehl et al. (2006) take this type of research even further: having conducted research that suggests the type of music does indeed have an impact on the runner based on several factors, including personal music preferences and the pace or rhythm of the music, this group of researchers attempted to develop a computer assisted technology that would actually adjust the music soundtrack as the runner runs. By measuring the pace of the runner and certain other physiological features, and comparing these readings with data collected regarding the individual runner, the DJogger attempts to play music that will be the most motivating for the specific runner at the specific point in their workout/run (Biehl et al. 2006). This research suggests that, while a direct relationship between music and running performance might not exist, music can be a motivating force that triggers a decision to increase performance.

Another study involving a larger cohort of elementary school students found that interest in running was the primary predictor of motivation in both the short- and long-term, and that (possibly as expected) interest waned the longer the running program was in force at the school (Xiang et al. 2006). That is, even students that started out with high degrees of motivation were demonstrating lower motivation and generally lowered running performance further on in the year-long study due to reduce interest levels (Xiang et al. 2006). Though this study did not directly observe the effects of music on motivation during running, it has certain implications for an understanding of this subject. As interest is a primary motivating factor in running, and as music has been found in other studies to contribute to longer retention of interest, it would seem that music could indeed be motivating to runners.

In one of the most direct studies conducted on music and its effect on running performance, Simpson and Karageorghis (2006) tested a panel of volunteer runners engaging in a series of four hundred meter sprints: once with music they had previously labeled motivational, once with music that was not considered motivational, and once with no music. The evidence supported the hypothesis that motivational music would improve running performance over the no-music control sprints, but the researchers were surprised to find that music identified as non-motivational actually created an improvement of the same level among the study's participants (Simpson & Karageorghis 2006). This places creates a greater level of uncertainty as to whether the type of music matters insofar as its motivational effect.

Methodology

From an examination of the previous literature conducted as to the motivational force, if any, that music provides to runners, it is clear that there are many ambiguities. Different studies have come to completely different results, and thus almost any research conducted in this area will be a positive force in the growth of knowledge and the certainty of that knowledge. Still, a particular focus is needed to make any proposed research truly effective and trustworthy, and for that reason the proposed research will focus on the type of music and any change in motivational force that arises out of changes in the type of music played. This can also help increase the understanding of whether or not music has a motivational effect on running overall, and possibly of how that effect is achieved in individual runners.

To begin with, this study will attempt to collect a broader selection of subjects than has heretofore been present. Subjects will be recruited from local gyms and athletic clubs, with information regarding the study made available through each gym's service desk and subject contact information collected by gym personnel to protect privacy -- only individuals that want to participate and volunteer contact information will be made known to the researcher. Certain minimum health criteria will be established in order to ensure subject safety during the experiment, but other than this subjects will consist of the broadest possible array of ages (though all participants must be over eighteen), races, and genders. This will make the results of this study more comprehensive and more generalizable.

Following the selection of participants through the use of voluntarily submitted contact forms and the administering of basic health tests by a licensed physician, the participants will need to be informed about as many of the details of the study as is deemed possible without influencing the results of the study. Explaining the full parameters of the study would likely lead to an impact on the results due to subconscious biases created; for example, if participants are told that their motivational responses to different types of music are being measured, they might create an unintentional bias in favor of one type of music or another, or become conscious of changes in motivations or performance and attempt to even them out so as not to influence the study, and actually end up influencing it by doing so. Instead, participants should only be told exactly what they will be doing, not the specifics of what is going to be measured or how those measurements are going to be interpreted.

What these participants will be doing is running on a treadmill on three successive mornings, under instructions not to eat or drink anything other than water between waking and arriving at the testing laboratory, so as to ensure consistency. Participants will then run on a treadmill listening to either one of two piece of music or no music at all, completing both pieces of music and the no-music run by the end of the three-day study period. While running, the participants will be connected to equipment monitoring perspiration, heart rate, blood flow, and other relevant physiological factors. The distance ran in every twenty minute period will also be measured, and the results of all of these measurements will be compared.

Increased motivation will be determined by increases in the distance run, the obtaining of an optimum heart rate sooner in the running process and the maintenance of this heart rate for longer in the running period. It is hypothesized that the type of music listened to will have no effect on the motivation, while listening to music of any sort will increase motivation as perceived through these factors. Participants' experiences will also be recorded in a qualitative manner in order to establish any trends in the perception of music's effects on running and motivation by the runners themselves, adding supplemental information to the quantified data that will supply the main information of the research. Through statistical analysis of the results it can be determined whether or not any observed trends are actually of a significant enough proportion to have meaning outside the population of the research study itself. Demonstrating the degree of correlation can also point to…[continue]

Cite This Essay:

"Music As Motivation In Running" (2011, April 11) Retrieved December 7, 2016, from http://www.paperdue.com/essay/music-as-motivation-in-running-13280

"Music As Motivation In Running" 11 April 2011. Web.7 December. 2016. <http://www.paperdue.com/essay/music-as-motivation-in-running-13280>

"Music As Motivation In Running", 11 April 2011, Accessed.7 December. 2016, http://www.paperdue.com/essay/music-as-motivation-in-running-13280

Other Documents Pertaining To This Topic

  • Music Education or Cross Platform

    Aristoxenos, two centuries after Pythagoras released his model, sought to discredit the standing theories held by Pythagorean devotees. In his works, he established that numbers are not relevant to music, and that music is based on perception of what one hears, not any mathematical equation. Descartes as well as Vincenzo Galilei (Galileo's father) both also discredited the music-to-math theories that formed the revolutionary basis for Pythagoras' music work, but not

  • Heroin and Music in Sonny s Blues

    Sonny's Outline James Baldwin. "Sonny's Blues." Junky. Keith Richards. Life. Question Under Investigation: What is the relationship between music and drugs in James Baldwin's "Sonny's Blues" and why does the character of Sonny need the two things? James Baldwin utilizes the concepts of music and drugs in a similar way, as a means by which the character of Sonny can escape from his real life which he find intolerable, as indicated in the very title

  • Improve Student Motivation This Is

    For example, let's say that a student has tremendous amounts of respect for their history teacher. While at the same time, they do not like their math teacher. These two contrasting views will have a negative impact on how they will deal with a host of situation. As, the student is more willing to listen to ideas of teachers they like and respect. Whereas those educators, that are often

  • Morality Then and Now the

    This is the perfect way to end this poem. The ending is in fact effective and consistent. The entire time, the duke speaks about how it was to have his wife besides him and how much he did not agree with her behavior. He then makes an insinuation that it was him in fact that had her killed. The ending leaves the reader in a sort of shock. The lines,

  • American Pie and Cultural Significance

    Semiotically, however, the term evolved in the region to symbolize a characteristic aspect of shared cultural attitudes related very directly to the motivation for the murder of the civil rights activists. Finally, the 1970s counterculture heavily emphasized illicit recreational drug use: The birds flew off with the fallout shelter Eight miles high and falling fast Again linking the 1950s with the 1970s, the semiotic relevance of high very likely corresponds to

  • Human Resources Also Contribute to

    Employee selection helps an organization to employ competent workers. Job descriptions within an organization help to define the physical and mental requirements of a job position, the qualities and attitudes desired for an open position, and also help to define the undesired characteristics of an employee ("Human Resource Management," 2011). Interviews conducted will further help to determine a candidate's aptitude, achievements, and general intelligence. Human resources play an important

  • Video Games Are the Background

    Robert thought that this was actually very cool. He liked the idea of picking all of his favorite characters from all of his favorite games and making up his own new game. That would be so cool. And then he could make all of the characters do exactly what he wanted them to do. Like the Viking Warrior standing in his room. He could take out his laser sabre and


Read Full Essay
Copyright 2016 . All Rights Reserved