Servant Leadership Does Service-Learning Experience essay

Download this essay in word format (.doc)

Note: Sample below may appear distorted but all corresponding word document files contain proper formatting

Excerpt from essay:

Conceptually, many agree as to what constitutes a servant leader, although many variations of these characteristics can be found in the literature. The terms "servant" and "leader" may seem contradictory, which is one of the greatest barriers to operationalizing the concept of the servant leader in modern organizations. The following will examine key literature regarding the ability to operationalize the concept of the servant leader.

What Distinguishes the Servant Leader?

The largest body of literature on the servant leader comprises those articles that attempt to define it at its most basic level. The concept of the servant leader is abstract and subjective at best. Several themes arise in an attempt to define the servant leader and their distinguishing characteristics. Lists of subjective characteristics often serve as the basis for the definition of the servant leader. Whether a person actually possesses these traits, or how many of the traits are required to make one qualify as a servant leader are often left up to the judgment of the reader. These problems with the definition of a servant leader permeate research on the topic.

The servant leader can be defined using traits, actions, or outcomes, depending on the theorist with which one tends to agree. These traits have been refined many times over the past 30 years. Many common themes and characteristics tend to repeat themselves throughout the literature. Among them, the theme of self-sacrifice is the most common reoccurring theme in the literature. The servant leader is expected to sacrifice personal or professional gain if it will benefit the group (Matterson & Irving, 2006).

All agree that the servant leader is a servant first, and a leader second (Matterson & Irving, 2006). Other traits vary according to author and topic. However, as a whole they paint the picture of the servant leader as a certain personality type with special traits such as altruism, trust, vision, credibility, appreciation for others and the means to empower them (Matterson & Irving, 2006). The servant leader has an identifiable set of characteristics. These characteristics will be used in the development of the survey instrument for this study.

Are Servant Leaders Born or Made?

The central issue of this research study is to investigate whether servant leaders are born or made. When a person graduates from college, they take an oath to give back to their community and their university, but only the true servant leader will make good on that promise (Grizzell, 2008). Somewhere in the educational process, the concept of serving others is lost in the competition for personal gain and position upon graduation. The focus tends to be on the ability to provide oneself an advantage over the others, not on succeeding for the good of the community (Grizzell, 2008). There is a disconnect in the message sent by university education and the development of the servant leader.

The educational process typically refers to the "technical" portion of the learning process. However, sufficient support exists that leaders can be made through a developmental process that allows individuals to become empowered in controlling issues that are important to them (Grizzell, 2008). This can only happen if "personal development" becomes an accepted part of the curriculum.

Greenleaf (1977) calls the desire to serve begins with a "natural" feeling that one wishes to serve. This definition suggests that one must first possess an innate feeling in order to be a leader. Although Greenleaf does not state so directly, he implies throughout his work that certain people are gifted with the qualities of the servant leader. This leads to the logical question of whether these qualities can be "taught" to those that do not naturally possess them. Greenleaf's position tends to suggest that the tendency to be a servant leader must already be present in order for those traits to be seen outwardly.

Several cultural aspects of the servant leader were found in the literature. For instance, an examination of leadership in Bedouin cultures, with their tribal roots, finds generosity and concern for others as key virtue necessary for tribal chiefs. Self-sacrifice for the sake of the tribe is embedded in Bedouin culture (Sarayrah, 2004). These values later became key concepts in Muslim traditions as well (Sarayrah, 2004).

Another example of the need for a servant leadership approach appears in first and second generation Chinese-American protestant churches. A recent study found that in order to manage the needs of followers effectively, church leadership needed to take a servant-leader approach. More aggressive styles of leadership were not culturally compatible with the Chinese culture, particularly among first genera6tion Chinese immigrants (Baldomir, 2008).

A recent study of servant leadership across cultures reveals several common themes. Large corporate scandals, including Enron and Worldcom scandals increased the importance of the topic of servant leadership (Hale & Fields, 2007). These scandals raised the demand from the public for leaders that they could trust. In a study that compared the experiences of person in Ghana with those in the United States, it was found that those in Ghana reported experiencing servant leadership behaviors significantly less than those in North America (Hale & Fields, 2007). This study also revealed that vision was associated with servant leadership more frequently for the Ghana population than for those in North America (Hale & Fields, 2007). Both populations considered service and humility to be important leadership qualities (Hale & Fields, 2007).

This group of studies concern the connection between culture and servant leadership found significant differences in leadership expectations and leadership attitudes among the various cultures. Certain cultures were found to embody the attitude of the servant leader as a basic tenet of their society. Others have only recently paid significant attention to need to foster servant leaders in their business leaders. These differences in culture support the theory that servant leadership could be learned. Culture is a learned trait, which suggests that in cultures where servant leadership is high, this trait was instilled through social learning in the culture. The existence of differences among various cultures concerning servant leadership supports the position of this research that servant leadership could be fostered through student experiences.

Service Leadership and Morality

Religion and business education seldom cross in the academic world. However, they cannot be separated when the research involves service learning. Many academic texts consider service learning to be a part of the student's moral development, further emphasizing the concept that leadership differs from management. The leader must often make moral decisions regarding the welfare of his or her charges. The service leader is more likely to make decisions that are in the best interest of those whom they serve, rather than what is best for their own personal gain. Service leadership is a desired trait in future managers, which translates into a preferred set of moral rules that must be taught and embraced by the student.

Service leadership often requires the leader to recognize the good and bad in all of their experiences. This recognition is referred to as self-transcendence. The leader deliberates and evaluates the potential benefits and harms of their actions, only then can they make a just decision on the correct action to be taken. Academic literature refers to this concept as self-transcendence (Wei, 2007). Self-transcendence and servant leadership are closely related. The servant leader must achieve self-transcendence in order to make the correct decisions for the group.

Literature regarding self-transcendence reference the need and process involved in internal changes within the student, often mentioning God's love and role in these changes (Wei, 2007). Transcendence can happen on an intellectual and on a religious level. Research indicates that student's can achieve self-transcendence through service learning experience (Wei, 2007). This research coincides with the theories and assumptions that form the basis of the proposed research.

The findings of this research indicated that the service-learning experience at a university resulted in achievement of self-transcendence in the areas of intellectual and moral conversion (Wei, 2007). These findings support the hypothesis of the proposed study and indicate that the servant learning experience results in changes within students that are consistent with the service leadership model. This study did not explore the mechanism or process of those changes, but it did indicate that they had occurred.

Gorman, Duffy, & Hefferman (1982) also explored the connection between the service learning experience and the moral development of college students. This study explored a similar topic to the proposed research. It examined whether the service learning experience would have a measurable effect on principled thinking. This study focused on Kohnberg's Moral Development Theory, particularly stages 5 and 6. This stage is important in the provision of the principles of consensus government and basic human rights. These concepts are essential for the development of social cooperation. In stage 6 of Kohlberg's theory, people are viewed as ends-in-themselves, rather than as tool for the attainment of some other good (Gorman, Duffy, & Hefferman, 1982).

The findings of this study indicated that students who engaged in community service work demonstrated an increase in…[continue]

Some Sources Used in Document:

"baldomir.pdf" 
"mair.pdf" 
"waddell.pdf" 

Cite This Essay:

"Servant Leadership Does Service-Learning Experience" (2009, July 29) Retrieved December 7, 2016, from http://www.paperdue.com/essay/servant-leadership-does-service-learning-20275

"Servant Leadership Does Service-Learning Experience" 29 July 2009. Web.7 December. 2016. <http://www.paperdue.com/essay/servant-leadership-does-service-learning-20275>

"Servant Leadership Does Service-Learning Experience", 29 July 2009, Accessed.7 December. 2016, http://www.paperdue.com/essay/servant-leadership-does-service-learning-20275

Other Documents Pertaining To This Topic

  • Servant Leadership Defining Servant Leadership the Principles

    Servant Leadership Defining Servant Leadership The principles of Servant Leadership were laid out by founder Robert Greenleaf in his important 1970 book, The Servant as Leader. Greenleaf, to his great credit, wanted to stress the point that leaders should first serve, and later lead through service. The leaders who have power but have not led, and use the power to push his or her own viewpoints and agenda, are not the kind

  • Applying Servant Leadership Within a

    Initially, I had to point out when people were saying things that would indicate a connection between group members. However, once those connections were established, the group members moved rather rapidly towards directly relating with one another. Another result of the group meetings is that the group members initially appeared very focused on the past. Small groups tend to do postmortems of old failures, archaeologizing (digging in the past for

  • Selfless Service and Servant Leadership

    I get no reward financially for making this happen, but by selflessly serving I am rewarded in my spirit and my heart knowing that dog won't have to be locked up in a kennel anymore. My eyes light up when the family with one little boy and a little girl now have a friendly, healthy and fun dog in their home! QUESTION THREE: I want to continue on the path

  • Lay Principals Servant Leadership and Catholic School Core Values...

    Catholic School's are ministries of the Catholic Community that exist to provide education rooted in the Catholic faith and Christian values. Such schools are developed to offer assistance to families regarding the intellectual, spiritual, and physical development of their children. The Congregation for Catholic Education [CCE], 1998) explains the function of Catholic schools as "a place of integral education of the human person through a clear educational project of which

  • Leadership in Organizations Organizational Leadership

    Leadership, according to La Monica (1938), is when a person has authority that is recognized by others, and the person has followers/subordinates under them, who believe that the person will assist them in attaining certain goals (carrying out specific objectives for the followers). Furthermore, anyone that is willing to assist and help others could be referred to as a leader (p.8) Leaders see what others do not Most leaders have

  • Leadership Experiences Leadership Stands Out as One

    Leadership Experiences Leadership stands out as one of the most discussed topics in both business and organizations. It is almost impossible to turn on a television, open a newspaper, or attend a conference without an issue touching on leadership occurs. Several definitions have been put forth in a bid to explore the concept and elements of leadership. However, there seems to be a consensus on the aspect that leadership enlists the

  • Leadership Has Become a Prominent

    According to the Ohio State University (2004), both could be equally appropriate in terms of overall company outcomes, as they are very similar in terms of valuing and inspiring follower excellence. When considering the motivation towards leadership for each type of leader, the contrast is sharper. The servant leader, for example, leads from a motivations basis of egalitarianism. The leader's fundamental belief is that he or she is no better than


Read Full Essay
Copyright 2016 . All Rights Reserved