Social Security in the U S Essay

Download this Essay in word format (.doc)

Note: Sample below may appear distorted but all corresponding word document files contain proper formatting

Excerpt from Essay:

In 1940, an amendment to the BNA was passed, followed by the first institution of unemployment insurance in Canada. The Marsh Report offered a comprehensive social security plan for Canada that included old age pensions paid for by employment taxes, as well as a public health plan. The Canadian Social Security system continued to grow, subject to the political whims of the time, until the 1970s. After this time, reforms were called for, as the system was growing too expensive (the Canadian Encyclopedia).

Both the Canadian Social Security system and the United States Social Security system currently face the problem of rising costs and increased spending. According to United North America, the United States publicly spends 1.8% more than Canada on Social Security and related programs than Canada, with Social Security comprising 6% of the U.S. budget as compared to 4.2% of the Canadian budget (United North America). Does this equate to a higher standard of living for retirees in the United States over those of their Canadian cousins?

Unlike the United States, which has only the contributory (though non-voluntary) Social Security system, Canada has two programs in place to assist seniors. The first, OAS (Old Age Security) is non-contributory. The only factors needed to qualify for this benefit, typically around $500 a month, is old age, and a number of years spent living in Canada, currently 20 years post 18th birthday (HRSDC.ca). This program is meant to primarily assist the lowest income seniors, with benefits decreasing for seniors of income of $66k, and disappearing completely for seniors who make $110k. The second program, the CPP (Canadian Pension Plan), is contributory, like the United States Social Security system. Also, like the U.S. Social Security system, the CPP provides survivor and disability benefits.

The primary difference between Canada's CPP and the U.S.'s Social Security is in the maximum tax rate. The maximum tax rate under the CPP is 9.9%, up to $42,100, shared equally between employee and employer. By contrast, the maximum tax rate under Social Security is 12.4% up to $106,800. The maximum tax under Social Security is three times that of the CPP. Because the amount taxed is lower, benefits received under the CPP are also lower. Under the CPP, the monthly income at age 65 is roughly $960; under Social Security, the average benefits are $2,366 at age 66 (TFB, 2011).

The primary difference between the two systems of interest to macro-economists is the way the two systems are funded. While both are in trust, the Social Security trust fund loans 100% of its funds to the U.S. government; when Social Security needs money to pay out benefits, taxpayers have their taxes raised accordingly. In contrast, the CPP is a true trust, with diversified investments in stocks, bonds and real estate (TFB, 2011).

Given the current economic climate, the resistance of the general populace of the United States to any increase in taxes, and the overwhelming demand for a safety net to protect the most vulnerable citizens, it behooves those in power to take a closer look at the Canadian retirement system of the OAS and the CPP. Reforming Social Security in the U.S. By creating two systems instead of one, one of which a basic safety net for all citizens, the other, a contributory program with investments diversified in marketable securities instead of loaned to the federal government, could prove to be both more secure in the long-term and more pragmatic in the present. Change must be done slowly, but to ensure the long-term economic security of both the United States as a nation and our citizens as individuals, change must indeed happen.

References

"Canadian Pension Plan and Old Age Security." Human Resources and Skills Development, Canada.

Retrieved from: http://www.hrsdc.gc.ca/eng/oas-cpp/index.shtml. 4/1/2012.

"Comparisons between Canada and the United States of America." Chart. Retrieved from:

http://www.unitednorthamerica.org/simdiff.htm. 4/1/2012.

"Historical Background and Development of Social Security." Social Security Online, U.S. Retrieved

from: http://www.ssa.gov/history/briefhistory3.html. 4/1/2012.

"The History of Social Security in Canada." The Canadian Encyclopedia. Retrieved from:

http://thecanadianencyclopedia.com/articles/social-security. 4/1/2012.

Leigh, Wilhelmina. "Social Security at 75: Strengthen it, Don't Cut it." The Franklin and Eleanor

Roosevelt Institute. Retrieved from:

http://www.newdeal20.org/2010/07/02/social-security-at-75-strengthen-it-dont-cut-it-14102/.

4/1/2012.

"Social Security Reform: The Progressive Case." The Cato Institute. Retrieved from:

http://www.cato.org/pubs/policy_report/cpr-18n5-5.html. 4/1/2012.

TFB. "Retirement Income: OAS and CPP in Canada vs. Social Security in the United States."

Retrieved from:

http://thefinancebuff.com/retirememnt-income-oas-cpp-in-canada-vs.-social-security-in-us.html[continue]

Cite This Essay:

"Social Security In The U S " (2012, April 04) Retrieved December 11, 2016, from http://www.paperdue.com/essay/social-security-in-the-us-55949

"Social Security In The U S " 04 April 2012. Web.11 December. 2016. <http://www.paperdue.com/essay/social-security-in-the-us-55949>

"Social Security In The U S ", 04 April 2012, Accessed.11 December. 2016, http://www.paperdue.com/essay/social-security-in-the-us-55949

Other Documents Pertaining To This Topic

  • U S Social Security System Editorial U S Social

    U.S. Social Security System Editorial: U.S. Social Security System Precisely, Social Security is called Old Age, Survivors, and Disability Insurance (OASDI) government program that provide financial benefits to retirees, spouses/children of deceased workers, and disabled workers (Aaron 2011). This U.S. program is financed through a payroll deduction (FICA) tax imposed upon eligible workers. Interestingly, the first social security program originated in Germany in 1889 by Chancellor Otto von Bismarck (Kotlikoff 2011). Although

  • Social Security Privatization Is a Bad Idea

    Social Security Privatization is a Bad Idea It is possible to use a Toulmin-based argument structure to help explain why privatizing Social Security would negatively impact both the results as well as the effectiveness of the program itself. Using this structure, the argument is broken down into six separate sub-headings as it is discussed further. Claim: Social Security should be left in the hands of the U.S. Government and not be privatized. Grounds There

  • Social Class System in the U S Classism

    SOCIAL CLASS SYSTEM IN THE U.S. Classism' refers to distribution of national wealth is such a manner that it benefits the highest social class, the elites, and leads to the creation of social hierarchy. "Classism is made up of falsehoods about the frugality and seriousness of the upper class and the profligacy and frivolity of the lower" (Dugger, 1998). While in the Britain and other imperial countries, social classes took birth

  • U S Patriot ACT We Deserve

    " (Lindsey, 2004, p.1) it is interesting to note that one of the young protestors stated: "[the world leaders] are sitting over there on Sea Island having their little party only talking about how to fix things, but we are over here actually doing something to make things better" -- Laurel Paget-Seekins (Lindsey, 2004, p. 1) the U.S.A. Patriot Act has been touted to do just this - or to

  • U S Foreign Policy on Terrorism

    International Terrorism Discussion Questions on International Terrorism Explain the origins and evolution of long-term separatists and ethnic and nationalistic terrorism. Also, provide group names and their respective parts of the world. Ethno- separatist/nationalist terrorism is not specifically a modern phenomenon. Historically, two Jewish movements in Judaea that desired to provoke the local population to rise against the Roman occupiers used ethno-racial terrorism. However, it was only in 60s and 70s that terrorism came

  • U S Nursing Shortage Background History

    First, nursing schools must be able to compete with clinical employers because there is little incentive to pursue a teaching career when first-year nurses can earn as much as their professors. Second, it will likely be impossible to eliminate the nursing shortage as long as American nursing schools are unable to accommodate thousands of qualified students annually. Finally, because FENs are likely to continue playing such a large role

  • Foreign Relations of the U S

    A second lesson was found in Kennedy's management of the crisis. The basic lesson learned was that, in the midst of such a crisis, leaders need time away from the glare of the media to resolve their own thinking and communications, and they need the self-confidence to limit their objectives to only what is needed to resolve the crisis, not "win" it. It is believed that the Soviet's lesson was that


Read Full Essay
Copyright 2016 . All Rights Reserved