Spirit Catches You And You Essay

The family would certainly have been more comfortable if the hospital made more of an effort to understand their culture and beliefs. The Lees were treated as if they were indignant and unresponsive to the needs of their child which was not the case at all. The hospital could have enlisted the help of affluent Hmong natives who have become more accustomed to American traditions. This person could have helped both parties, the Lees to understand medical necessities and the hospital staff to understand the importance of cultural traditions. Both parties could have used a trusted intermediary, Fadiman (1997) refers to this as a "cultural broker" (p. 265).

Another factor that would have made this experience easier for the Lees would have been if the medical professionals had an understanding of some of the important religious rituals and beliefs of their culture. Of particular importance to the Hmong is the concept of death. The doctor's told the Lees several times during Lia's last hospitalization that she was going to die in a few hours. For the Hmong, predicting a death is unthinkable, they believe that it makes the dab come closer to the dying person. The Hmong believe that it means that one is accepting of the person's death (Fadiman, 1997).

The Lee family is completely illiterate. They are unable to read either English or Hmong but they can write their names, a skill they had to learn in order to immigrate to the United States. The family can speak Hmong but that is the extent of their ability to communicate with others. Therefore, when attempting to communicate with the Lees hospital staff could benefit from an understanding of Hmong culture and language. Medical information would be more easily communicated to the Lees if the conditions that they were attempting to describe existed in Hmong language. The reality that there were often not Hmong equivalents made communication...

...

However, if the health care providers had been able to learn about Hmong culture they may have been better able to explain the situation to them. This would have also helped to ensure that the manner in which they did explain things was not misinterpreted or offensive in nature.
There are certainly better ways that the situation could have turned out for all invested parties. However, it is always easier to determine how we would handle a situation when we are observing it from the outside looking in. The doctors in the situation truly believed that they had made the best choices for Lia's medical care particularly given their perception of the parents as non-complaint. However, in many cases it was doctors' culture that made it difficult for them to open themselves to the beliefs and traditions of the Lees.

While the Lees understood the need to treat Lia when her symptoms were severe, they were not looking for the same complete resolution of symptoms as the doctors as they believed that Lia had special divine powers. It would have been helpful to the Lee's if the doctors were able to learn enough about their culture and wishes to appreciate the rituals and their place in the Hmong community. There were many times when the hospital staff struggled with the Lee's unnecessarily and could have allowed them to perform their own rituals finding a level of intervention that all parties could deal with. Aftercare services could have been more structured including visiting nurses to ensure that the family could dispense Lia's medication as well as incorporating Hmong remedies into the treatment plan. There is evidence that Lia has defied modern medicine even if the life that she continues to lead is less than optimal.

Sources Used in Documents:

References

Fadiman, a. (1997). The spirit catches you and you fall down. New York: Farrar,

Straus, and Giroux.


Cite this Document:

"Spirit Catches You And You" (2010, June 06) Retrieved May 10, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/spirit-catches-you-and-you-10504

"Spirit Catches You And You" 06 June 2010. Web.10 May. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/spirit-catches-you-and-you-10504>

"Spirit Catches You And You", 06 June 2010, Accessed.10 May. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/spirit-catches-you-and-you-10504

Related Documents

Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down by Anne Fadiman is a groundbreaking book about cross-cultural communication in health care. The book is about Lia Lee, who was the first in her Hmong family to be born in the United States. Her parents spoke no English. When Lia Lee was three months old, she had her first seizure. Due to misdiagnosis, a string of unfortunate events prevented Lia Lee from

Spirit Catches You and You
PAGES 4 WORDS 1206

Within this clash of cultures, the Lee family did not know how to cope with the medical system in place to help Lia and her epilepsy. When they refused to give her the medications, Lia was removed from the home and placed in foster care. When the foster care parents gave her the prescribed medication, her condition worsened in several important ways. The foster parents believe that Lia's parents realized

Spirit Faidman, Anne. (1998) The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux. The title of Anne Fadiman's book on the implications of multiculturalism in modern nursing sounds more like a religious testimony than a textual asset to the modern nursing profession. However, Faidman tells a tale of Biblical proportions, and the emotional nature of The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down is epic in its

Yet the nightmare continued, because the communication problems were not resolved. During the next four years, her anticonvulsant medicines were changed about 25 times, which would have been hell for any family. The Lees questioned the value of so many prescriptions, especially with their Hmong mindset, and did not follow directions. Of course, this was exacerbated by the fact that they did not understand the dosages. The doctors inaccurately concluded

Then, if the parents did not listen to the doctors, they assumed more of the responsibility of what happened. How could the doctors expect the medicine to be taken correctly when the parents did not read, did not know mathematical symbols and were given change after change. They were blindsided by their own diagnosis and the arrogance that everyone would follow their treatment exactly. Nor can the doctors be

They cannot ignore the socioeconomic issues of adversity so often present and, where necessary, need to act as advocates, mediators and social brokers (Compton, Galaway, & Curnoyer, 2005). The concern is that the issue of healthcare for culturally diverse individuals is so complex, there are no exact rights and wrongs. For example, in Fadiman's book, no person(s) can be said to be ultimately correct or incorrect in his/her behavior or