Sign Up Now
Get instant access to over 1 million+ study documents
OR
Already registered? click here to login
By creating your account, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and student honor code.
Sun Tzu and Clausewitz on War
War on Terror: The Relevance of Historical Perspectives on War
Sarah Miller (2012) evaluated the relevance of historical texts for explaining contemporary society's efforts to combat terrorism. The two texts chosen for her essay are On War by Carl Von Clausewitz and The Art of War by Sun Tzu, with the first published in 1832 and the second about 2,500 years ago. Miller (2012) seemed surprised that the older text appeared to be more relevant and attributes this to the philosophical lens through which Sun Tzu explained the art of warfare. By contrast, the value of Clausewitz writings is limited by his emphasis on warfare tactics relevant mainly to the time period in which he lived. Miller (2012) used these points and others to argue that Sun Tzu offered the most value for governments tasked with combating a terrorist threat, in part because modern terrorist organizations defy the traditional definition of an enemy used by Clausewitz.
One of the first points discussed by Miller (2012) is the different ways Clausewitz and Tzu view warfare as either a political tool or a necessary evil, respectively. Although Miller (2012) favors Clausewitz's perspective, the War on Terror seems to be less political than more traditional armed conflicts. For example, diplomatic pressure, trade sanctions, and weapons of mass destruction inspections cannot be imposed on Al Qaeda in the same way they were imposed upon Saddam Hussein; however, Miller (2012) describes how the U.S. government bribed warlords in Afghanistan to reject Taliban control. Political considerations are therefore inextricably linked to armed conflicts with terrorist organizations, but I disagree with Miller (2012) that Sun Tzu downplayed the importance of politics. For example, the first of seven conditions determining victory or defeat is which combatant has the moral high ground (Tzu, 1994).
References
Miller, S. (2012). Are Clausewitz and Sun Tzu still relevant in contemporary conflicts? Retrieved from http://www.e-ir.info/2012/07/20/are-clausewitz-and-sun-tzu-still-relevant-in-contemporary-conflicts/.
Tzu, S. (1994-2000). The Art of War by Sun Tzu. Translated by Lionel Giles. Retrieved from http://classics.mit.edu/Tzu/artwar.html.
Apolitical Ecology What is apolitical ecology? Logically it would seem that anything apolitical would be non-political. Ecology without politics would then be an approach to environmental and conservation concerns without any ideology attached to that approach. To wit, an example of apolitical ecology would seem to be those who objectively review the empirical data for climate change objectively. Over 190 scientists have been working on data related to the overheated planet
House at Pooh Corner Paula T. Connolly makes the point about A.A. Milne's Winnie-the-Pooh and The House at Pooh Corner that the escapism of the text is, in its own way, inherently political: to posit the existence of an Edenic locus amoenus like the Hundred Acre Wood necessarily implies the existence of a world that requires escaping from. We can see an interesting demonstration of the dynamics Connolly describes in the
768). Yet the widespread slaughter of people in the name of total war was a principle varying point between Asian and Western powers during the 19th century. Despite whatever moral and philosophical objections Clausewitz might have raised to total war, he certainly saw value in involving as much of a population as possible in its martial efforts. In this respect, he conceived of war from a decidedly nationalistic viewpoint, in
Fallout A section of commentators have taken issue with the manner in which the federal government denied suspected terrorist the due process of law as stipulated under the constitution. The government even commissioned the establishment of a torture chamber in Guantanamo Bay. This amounts to gross violation of human rights and civil liberties. There is another clause in the patriot act dubbed "enhanced surveillance procedures," which allows federal authorities to gather
Investment in the "global economy" remains a domestic matter: The fact is, the total amount of the world's capital formation that is generated from foreign direct investment (FDI) has been less than 10% for the last three years for which data are available (2003-2005). In other words, more than 90% of the fixed investment around the world is still domestic. And though merger waves can push the ratio higher, it
The contention that politics by innuendo, unethical conduct, and moral decay are somehow strictly modern phenomena is patently false. If anything, increased public scrutiny, partially made possible through new technologies, may make it more difficult for such ethical abuses to take place for long. Bibliography Adams, G.B. (1993). Ethics and the Chimera of Professionalism: The Historical Context of an Oxymoronic Relationship. The American Review of Public Administration, 117-139. Anechiarico, F. (1994). Visions of