Academic Tenure Literature Review

Length: 3 pages Sources: 1+ Subject: Teaching Type: Literature Review Paper: #36490991 Related Topics: Academia, Teaching Assistant, Administrative Law, Oakland
Excerpt from Literature Review :

Tenure -- Literature Review

Academic tenure is a system that many universities and colleges use to protect a senior academic's contractual right to a lifetime job unless terminated for just cause. It is typically reserved for academics who have made Assistant or Full Professor, and requires following a strict hierarchical rubric that demonstrates a strong record of published research, teaching, and administrative services. Most institutions allow for a certain period of time to establish this record; although there are a number of non-tenure track positions still available within the university system (Adjust Professor, Lecturer, Research Professor, etc.) (Amacher, 2004). The idea of academic tenure, at least in the United States, is primarily intended to guarantee the right to academic freedom, in that it protects the academic when they publish or dissent from prevailing or common opinion, or spend time and research on topics that may be politically unfashionable or controversial. With tenure (e.g. job security), the academic knows that they can peruse any line of inquiry that interests them and as long as their research is robust and publications peer reviewed, can safely exhibit academic freedom. Additional, with tenure, a professor cannot be pressured by the administration or others to mitigate grades or curriculum simply to satisfy certain student enrollment objectives or pressure from alumni (Chait, 2002)

In the early 19th century, university professors had no employement rights, serving largely at the whim and pleasure of the university's Board of Trustees. They were expected to hold certain political and academic ideas, and most certainly to create an atmosphere in which sons from wealthy alumni were able to succeed academically. It was a 1903 case from the University of Texas, in which Professor G.B. Halsted was dismissed after 19 years of service that accelerated the adoption of academic tenure (DeGeorge, 1997). Halsted was a supreme intellectual, some say a mathematical genius with degrees from Princeton and Johns Hopkins. He began teaching...

...

However, in 1903 he was fired after publishing several articles critical of the university for hiring a candidate less than qualified as his assistant. While he completed his career at smaller colleges, the national attention brought to the case became a public debate on the issue of tenure (School of Mathematics University of St. Andrews, Scotland, 2006).

The tide in academia was certainly changing, Harvard, Columbia, and the University of Chicago had enough meddling from donors and the board and by 1915 the American Association of University Professors' (AAUP) adopted a standard of principles that eventually led to a tenure program designed specifically to protect academic freedom. This continued to evolve throughout the war years and beyond; but became quite problematical during the late 1940s and early 1950s, when many academics found themselves at odds with the House Un-American Activities Committee and the policies of Senator Joseph McCarthy. Since universities are often the bastion of liberalism, academic ideals often found themselves in conflict with the Vietnam War, as well as policies of the 1960s and certainly the Nixon years (O'Neil, 2003).

However, it was two landmark Supreme Court cases that changed the way academic tenure was viewed from 1972 to the present day. Board of Regents of State Colleges v Roth (408 U.S. 564) and Perry v Sindermann (408 U.S. 593). Both of these cases held that an academic's claim to entitlement is, but its very nature, more than a subjective expectancy of continued and uninterrupted employment. Instead, a contractual relationship must be a part of the relationship. Further, these two found that tenure is a property interest in the academic institution, so due process applies

(Beerman, 2006). Whether a result of these decisions or simply a gradual change in both the expectations and cultural views on the contributions of academia, there has been a steady decline on tenure track positions in the United States. In 1975, for instance, tenured positions made up about 60% of the total faculy positions in America's colleges and universities; while this number was down to 30% by 2005. In essence, in 2005, 68% of college and university instructors were neither tenured nor eligible for tenure and almost 50% were part-time employees (Percent of Teachers with Tenure, 2008).

Tenure is usually awarded for instructors hired in tenure-track positions. Over the…

Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited

Board of Regents of State Colleges v. Roth, 408 U.S. 564 (U.S. Supreme Court June 29, 1972).

Perry v. Sindermann, 408 U.S. 593 (U.S. Supreme June 29, 1972).

Percent of Teachers with Tenure. (2008, June). Retrieved March 2011, from Department of Education Statistics: http://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d08/tables/dt08_264.asp

Issues in Higher Education. (2011, January). Retrieved March 2011, from American Association of University Professors: http://www.aaup.org/AAUP/issues/
Finn, R. (1996, October). Academic Job Security Threatened as Anti-Tenure Wave Sweeps U.S. Retrieved March 2011, from The New Scientist: http://www.f1000scientist.com/article/display/17257/
Hilsenrath, J. (2005, October 24). Novel Way to Assess School Competition Stirs Academic Row. Retrieved March 2011, from The Wall Street Journal Online: http://gsppi.berkeley.edu/faculty/jrothstein/hoxby/wsj.pdf
Horn, J. (n.d.). On the Ineffectiveness and irrelevancy of Tenure. Retrieved 2011 March, from Academic Questions: http://www.horn_on_the-ineffectivness-irrelevancy-of-tenure-2[1].pdf
School of Mathematics University of St. Andrews, Scotland. (2006, June). George Bruce Halsted. Retrieved March 2011, from St. Andrews School: http://www-history.mcs.st-and.ac.uk/Biographies/Halsted.html


Cite this Document:

"Academic Tenure" (2011, March 28) Retrieved November 27, 2021, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/academic-tenure-11130

"Academic Tenure" 28 March 2011. Web.27 November. 2021. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/academic-tenure-11130>

"Academic Tenure", 28 March 2011, Accessed.27 November. 2021,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/academic-tenure-11130

Related Documents
Tenure and Organizational Effectiveness Tierney
Words: 2162 Length: 7 Pages Topic: Business - Management Paper #: 51067467

Term effectiveness of a vast sense, there are no standards of the continent to measure the effectiveness of institutions, and has raised the effectiveness of the community colleges and led to the emergence of several different views including: the pattern of managerial leadership that determines the effectiveness of the educational institution, and the quality of leadership Education adopted by the senior management of educational institutions of great importance to

Tenure and Post-Tenure Review: Annotated
Words: 2294 Length: 7 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 65672486

Indeed, regardless of how the discussion is framed, this power struggle between administrators and educators remains a constant and relevant force. Still, some research comes to support this idea that tenure helps to promote inequality across certain lines. For instance, Evans et al. (2008) remark on the gender and race lines that permeate the educational hierarchy. According to Evans et al., "sixteen percent of faculty in undergraduate and graduate

Tenure Bibliography "Tenure." National Education
Words: 1414 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 77238549

http://chronicle.com Similar to ERIC, the Chronicle of Higher Education website provides links to many articles and studies concerning tenure and post-tenure review on both sides of the issue. The vast majority of these articles were produced by the Chronicle itself, for its print and online subscribers. Given that most of the subscribers to the Chronicle are almost certainly employed in the realm of higher education, the balanced views presented by the

Tenure Has Become a Civil
Words: 1316 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 9582298

If both parties agree, another alternative dispute resolution method may be used. Specific reasons must be in writing for any decision to terminate the tenured faculty member. The post-tenure review process is mandatory when an administrator is faced with deciding whether to terminate a tenured faculty member with allegations of dating an 18-year-old student and receiving evidence of phone records and witness documentation of the faculty member being seen with

Tenure K-12 and Higher Education
Words: 2234 Length: 7 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 77536816

Tenure and Higher Education Does Tenure Work in Education or is it Outdated? My position is that Tenure still works. The topic tenure has formed much intense discussion in current years. There is an argument by few that tenure is an outdated idea and concept, and, therefore, if institutions remain competitive, then for this purpose they actually need to be more expert as well as flexible to appoint and dismiss the teaching

Tenure and Post-Tenure What Are
Words: 718 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 24241278

" Secondly, an "established custom within academe" would make it possible, together with the "expectations" would then facilitate the relationship between the faculty and its employees. The most surprising insight about tenure is that it is a relatively "late arrival to the American system," as noted by Altbach et al. (2001, p. 12). It was formally implemented only in 1940. The system in the United Sates therefore accounts for only 60