Authors, Y.H. Lin And S.M. Article Critique

Length: 10 pages Sources: 3 Subject: Health - Nursing Type: Article Critique Paper: #16276987 Related Topics: Medication Errors, Administration, Data Collection, Ethical Considerations
Excerpt from Article Critique :

B. This study used cross-sectional design and may tend to under-select individuals who have been exposed. This is known as "late-look bias." The possibility of nurses recalling MAEs over their careers may result in reporting of, or remembering information that is not accurate.

C. The instrument developed by authors used expert validity, but more research is needed to determine the construction validity and use the appropriate interventions to decrease MAEs (Lin & Ma).


Research questions

Rather than a hypothesis, the Lin and Ma (2009) study was guided by the following research questions:

A. What is the self-reported incidence of MAEs throughout a nurse's career in Taiwan?

B. What is the willingness of nurses to report MAEs?

C. What factors are related to nurses' willingness to report MAEs?

The first research question, though, differs from the authors' stated purpose which was to "explore the prevalence of MAEs and the willingness of nurses to report them," suggesting that they may not completely understand the important differences between the terms "prevalence" and "incidence," an oversight that may have also fundamentally affected the interpretation of their findings.


Operational definitions

The authors do not provide a list of definitions of key terms used in their study, bu they do operationalize the term "medication administration errors" (MAEs) as referring to "medication errors that occur during the process of administering a drug. This usually involves a nursing action in which the patient receives or is supposed to receive a medication" (Lin & Ma, 2009, p. 239).



The setting for the research was appropriate for the purposes of the study. In this regard, the setting was southern Taiwan wherein participants were working at 14 hospitals (differentiated by hospital funding: public, which included five city hospitals, one veterans general hospital, and two armed forces general hospitals; three private hospitals; and three nonprofit medical centers) that were situated in the university region in southern Taiwan (Lin & Ma, 2009).



The Lin and Ma (2009) study used a cross-sectional design which was regarded as appropriate for their research goals.


Sampling methods

The sampling method used by Lin and Ma (2009) was convenience sampling, comprised of respondents attending bachelor's degree programs at a university in southern Taiwan who were employed at 14 different hospitals in the region. The quality of the researchers' findings, though, could be improved by incorporating a randomization element in future studies (Neuman, 2003). Of the 650 surveys distributed, 605 respondents returned the instruments in time for inclusion in the study's data analysis, representing a 93.1% response rate, which is regarded as being a superior response rate (Neuman, 2003). The exclusion criteria used by the researchers included current employment in one of the following positions:

A. Supervisory position;

B. Advanced practice nurse; or,

C. Dean of a department (Lin & Ma).

All of the respondents were females with registered nurse degree; the respondents had a mean age of 29.35 years and almost 60% (59.8%) had graduated from a junior college (Lin & Ma).


Data collection

The researchers used the following data collection instruments which were considered appropriate for the purposes of the study:

A. A custom-designed MAEs Unwillingness to Report Scale. The unwillingness to report MAEs scale was developed by Lin and Ma based on empirical observations, professional experience and their critical review...


According to Lin and Ma, "This scale contains 11 items related to the reasons nurses do not want to report the MAEs. The instrument measures dichotomized answers about the reasons for unwillingness to report errors (yes: indicated nurses agreed with the reason and therefore did not want to report; no: meant the inverse of yes). Content validity was based on a comprehensive literature review, conducted by nine experts" (2009, p. 239).

B. Medication Errors Etiology Questionnaire, and,

C. The Personal Features Questionnaire.

Following the slight modification of the willingness to report questionnaire through the sole addition of the question, "When medication errors occur, should they be reported to the department?," the researchers conducted a pilot test consisting of 20 registered nurses to evaluate the respondents' comprehension levels and the amount of time that was typically required to complete the instrument (which was determined to be about 20 minutes). The researchers provide support for their assertion that their modified custom survey instrument was reliable and valid, but do not provide any specific evidence of this for review. Notwithstanding this omission, based on the results of their pilot test, the researchers deemed their instruments satisfactory and the surveys were thereafter distributed as described in the sampling methods section above. Following completion of the survey distribution, the survey instruments were returned to the researchers' mailbox in an unspecified location.

The data collected and analyzed showed that an overwhelming majority (87.7%) of the surveyed nurses reported a willingness to report MAEs, but only provided that there were no adverse consequences involved; however, Lin and Ma did identify some differences in nurses' levels of willingness to report such medication administration errors with respect to their job position, nursing grade, type of hospital, and hospital funding type, leading them to conclude that, "This study demonstrates that reporting of MAEs should be anonymous and without negative consequences in order to monitor and guide improvements in hospital medication systems" (Lin & Ma, 2009, p. 244). This conclusion, though, appears to fly in the face of common sense. After all, if one or two nurses are committing 99% of the medication errors on a nursing unit, it would just make good sense to identify these practitioners so that corrective actions -- of whatever type -- could be taken as quickly as possible. Indeed, the data collected by Lin and Ma may indicate that nurses would prefer anonymity to avoid accountability, but so doubtless so too would countless other professionals, including educators, accountants, politicians, and virtually every other profession as well. The healthcare setting is not like most other professions either. For instance, if a pizza restaurant fails to add pepperoni, lives will not be at stake. Certainly, this is not to trivialize other professions, but it is to highlight the fact that in healthcare, like the military or law enforcement, lives are at stake and there is no room for allowing repeated medication administration errors to continue to occur because the practitioners responsible for them remain unknown. Although something must first be measured in order to improve it, measuring medication administration errors without identifying their source is an overly simplistic approach that ignores the bottom-line cause of many errors in the first place -- the same individual or individuals who may need further training or remedial education in order to avoid the significant adverse clinical outcomes that can results from many types of medication administration errors.


Ethical considerations

The authors report that their study had been approved by their institutional review board, all respondents were assured that their participation in the research project was completely voluntary and their anonymity was assured. The researchers deemed return of the completed survey as sufficient informed consent, but did not specifically obtain an informed consent form from each respondent nor did they describe any protections of the data they used during the analysis process.


Gebhart, F. (2008, May 12). N.C. hospital loses CMS certification over drug…

Sources Used in Documents:


Gebhart, F. (2008, May 12). N.C. hospital loses CMS certification over drug and other errors.

Drug Topics, 152(6), 12.

Lin, Y-H & Ma, S-n. (2009). Willingness of nurses to report medication administration errors in southern Taiwan: A cross-sectional survey.

Wakefield, B.J., Uden-Holman, T. & Wakefield, D.S. (2005). Development and validation of the medication administration error reporting survey. In Advances in patient safety: From research to implementation. Henriksen, K., Battles, J.B., Marks E.S., et al. (eds).

Cite this Document:

"Authors Y H Lin And S M " (2011, September 24) Retrieved September 17, 2021, from

"Authors Y H Lin And S M " 24 September 2011. Web.17 September. 2021. <>

"Authors Y H Lin And S M ", 24 September 2011, Accessed.17 September. 2021,

Purpose of

The documents we provide are to be used as a sample, template, outline, guideline in helping you write your own paper, not to be used for academic credit. All users must abide by our "Student Honor Code" or you will be restricted access to our website.

Related Documents
Case Study Tina's Story
Words: 2559 Length: 9 Pages Topic: Psychology Paper #: 36815831

Tina's Story There is a considerable of variation in the occurrence of MDD among U.S. youth as reported by research studies on depression in adolescents. Fleming and Offord (1990) conducted a critical review and found that currently the occurrence depression ranges from .4-5.7%, with a mean occurrence of 3.6%. Similarly another study in which the sample were high school students (between the ages of 14-18 years), the results revealed that the

Organizational Accountability Review of Taiwan's Disaster Management...
Words: 5800 Length: 20 Pages Topic: Government Paper #: 99826794

Organizational Accountability Review of Taiwan's Disaster Management Activities In Response To Typhoon Morakot Taiwanese System of Government 174 Responsibility of Emergency Management in Taiwan 175 Disasters in Taiwan 175 Citizen Participation 189 Shafritz defines citizen participation as follows: 192 Public Managers, Citizen Participation, and Decision Making 192 The Importance of Citizen Participation 197 Models of Citizen Participation 199 Citizen Participation Dilemmas 205 Accountability 207 Definitions of Accountability 207 The Meaning of Accountability 208 The Functions of Accountability 213 Citizen Participation and Accountability 216 Accountability Overloads

Efforts to Achieve Healthy Aging Ping-Chung Leung
Words: 3711 Length: 12 Pages Topic: Death and Dying  (general) Paper #: 36806414

Efforts to Achieve Healthy Aging Ping-Chung Leung Institute of Chinese Medicine, The Chinese University of Hong Kong, HKSAR. Abstract: Longevity is a blessing as long as good health is not lost. However, the tendency to have a decline on normal physiological activities is inevitable because of the natural processes of degeneration at all levels: molecular, cellular and organic. Hence, the elderly people frequently suffer from cardiovascular problems and skeletal deteriorations that gradually develop

Malaysia Is Characterized by the
Words: 14609 Length: 53 Pages Topic: Economics Paper #: 76653907

1.2 Purpose of the Study The purpose of this study is two-fold as follows: 1. To identify the optimum approach and metrics for measuring the efficiency of Malaysian banks; 2. To analyze archival financial performance data using the optimum approach for measuring the efficiency of Malaysian banks to determine historic efficiency levels in an effort to identify opportunities for improvement in the future. 1.3 Importance of the Study The importance of the study directly relates to the

Hygiene As a Pivotal Method of Preventing
Words: 3599 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Healthcare Paper #: 7707917

Hygiene as a pivotal method of preventing infection in a health care setting Hand Hygiene as a Pivotal Method of Preventing Infection in a Healthcare Setting Carpetti, G.M., Sandri, F., Trridapallli, E., Galleti, S., Petracci, E., & Faldella, G. (2007). Nosocomial infection in very low birth weight infants. American journal of infection control, 36(6), 430-435. To increase the chances of survival of VLBW infants, there are continued improvements in neo-natal management. However, the

Foreign Exchange Risk Management in
Words: 5032 Length: 15 Pages Topic: History - Israel Paper #: 86866079

In addition, a series of joint ventures in which West German steel firms joined with East German firms and Krupp, Klockner, and Thyssen of Germany was pursuing other developmental initiatives in eastern Europe as well. Likewise, Arbed of Luxemburg was involved in steelmaking facilities in the former East Germany. According to Mangum et al., "The rising market for improved galvanizing for automobiles, appliances, canning, and other uses is producing