Verified Document

Business Research The Unethical Research Behavior Discussed Essay

Business Research The unethical research behavior discussed was conducted by Wyeth, and is symptomatic of the systemic issues that the pharmaceutical industry has with respect to research. The article details a case involving Wyeth that resulted in class action litigation. The ethical issue in this case is fraudulent research. The allegation is that Wyeth fabricated research by using "vendors to produce ghostwritten manuscripts and place them into medical journals." The research produced was therefore entirely fraudulent, but passed off in medical journals as legitimate research. The objective of placing this research in the journals was to legitimize the new drug that Wyeth was about launch, Prempro, a menopausal hormone therapy.

The larger issue is publication planning, described by Fugh-Berman (2010) as "the process by which pharmaceutical, biotech and medical device companies produce and release articles in medical journals and posters at meetings to establish key marketing messages." These companies use academics to produce the articles. For both the company and the academic, such practice represents a significant breach of ethics. The ghostwriters have a duty of care as academics to only produce research that stands up to academic rigor, but instead are falsifying results to match pre-determined marketing messages. For the companies, they also have a duty of care to their customers and to the FDA to only sell products that have a tangible benefit, and one that the...

These individuals "brought claims related to the development of breast cancer while taking…" Prempro. Had Wyeth and its ghostwriters conducted proper research rather than falsified it, they would have had a better sense of the risks involved in the use of Prempro. Additionally, the research would have shown these risks, allowing physicians to make better decisions with respect to prescribing Prempro. As a result of the falsified research, thousands more women were prescribed this drug than otherwise would have. While this brought financial benefit to Wyeth, it also brought significant negative health outcomes to the victims (specifically, it contributed to the development of breast cancer).
The unethical behavior had a number of effects. It affected the company in a few ways. First, it generated significantly more income for the company than if the research had not been falsified. Beyond that, however, there are negative effects as well. The first of these is the class action suit, which could result in significant damages awarded. Punitive damages in particular could outweigh the financial benefits that Wyeth saw as a result of the falsification. Moreover, the company has damaged its reputation in light of the falsifications coming to light.

The…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited:

Fugh-Berman, A. (2010). The haunting of medical journals: How ghostwriting sold "HRT." PLOS Medicine. Vol. 7 (9) Retrieved October 31, 2012 from http://www.plosmedicine.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pmed.1000335
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Unethical Business Research Practices What Unethical Research
Words: 939 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Unethical Business Research Practices What unethical research behavior was involved? The antitrust case brought by Wal-Mart and other retailers against Visa and MasterCard in the U.S. Eastern District court, was settled in 2003 for $3 billion and primarily involved a dispute concerning the efficient pricing of access to payment information, including security data that confirmed or refuted the transactional identities of cardholders (Roberds & Schreft, 2009). In their pleadings, Wal-Mart and other

Business Using Gelso 2006 , Harlow
Words: 16758 Length: 60 Document Type: Term Paper

Researchers have an occasion to further organizational science and to make research practical by producing information that can impact changing organizational forms and circumstances. Pragmatically, academic researchers are not likely to get access to a company that is going through change unless the practitioners believe the research will be helpful (Gibson & Mohrman, 2001). There have been a number of calls to augment the significance and effectiveness of organizational science

Business' Environmental Responsibilities and Stewardship:
Words: 4956 Length: 15 Document Type: Research Paper

In addition, we might ask ourselves if the richer nations have or not a greater responsibility as far as the research and development in the area of sustainable energy are concerned. (Reid, environmentalleader.com) Believing that there are such energy sources or consumption policies which would allow the planet's resources to be maintained for a longer period, while making sure that all the nations are provided with a comfortable living is

Business Ethics in the Fire
Words: 3000 Length: 10 Document Type: Research Paper

2). These are important issues because fire chiefs are routinely confronted with actual ethical dilemmas that involve conflicting or competing public and private values as well as corresponding conflicting professional responsibilities (Haraway & Kunselman, 2009). This point is also made by Pammer and Killian (2003) who cite the expanded responsibilities of both fire chiefs and line personnel in recent years. According to these authorities, "A successful fire chief today

Business Ethics Focus on Merrill Lynch According
Words: 4347 Length: 15 Document Type: Essay

Business Ethics Focus on Merrill Lynch According to Laura Hartman and her co-writer, Joe Desjardins in the work entitled "Business Ethics: Decision Making for Personal Integrity & Social Responsibility" philosophical ethics may be clearly differentiated from theological ethics because theological ethics attempted to disseminate the well-being of an individual on a religious basis while the ethics of an individual's philosophy is such that provisions of justifications that can be applied to

Business Theory Relationship Between Stakeholders,
Words: 4990 Length: 15 Document Type: Research Paper

As the proceedings of the past few years have shown, these labors, regrettably, have not prevented companies from engaging in unethical behaviors that lead to larger corporate disgraces. As a result there is augmented force to make accessible more structured power and ethics programs so that companies are more accountable to the societies in which they function. Understanding the setting of business ethics can be very difficult. The field is

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now