Captain Corelli Madolin Reaction Paper

PAGES
2
WORDS
785
Cite

Captain Corelli Mandolin The novel and movie Captain Corelli Mandolin is a story that is talking about the Italian and German occupation of Cephallonia (a Greek island in the Mediterranean Sea). Throughout both works are a series of themes that are discussed. To fully understand these ideas requires looking at: the scenes of war, if this is an anti-war novel, the dilemma of a good Nazi, the personalities of the Italians vs. The Germans, the character that was most liked and what this taught everyone about history. Together, these different elements will highlight the various themes in the film and the book.

What scenes of war touched you the most and why did you choose these scenes?

The scene that is the most touching is when the Italian Aqui Division refused to surrender to the Germans. After running out of ammunition, they were forced to accept defeat. This is when the Germans massacred 5 thousand prisoners and sent 3 thousand to Germany. This scene is important, because it is showing how the Italian soldiers became swept up in a cause they disagree with. Instead of continuing to support these policies, they chose to fight the Germans (knowing it will result in their...

...

Then, once they honorably surrendered, is when they are brutally murdered by Germans. ("Captain Corelli's Mandolin," 2001) (De Berniere, 2011)
If the novel is actually an anti-war novel, why do you think that is so?

The novel is discussing anti-war themes. The reason why, is because it is showing the soldiers (who are supposed to be fighting on the same side) as ordinary people. The only difference is that there are shifting views about: the meaning of the war and the actions that are taken. This is where everyone can see the sheer brutality of what is happening. As the Germans are depicting evil and the Italians are representing someone who has become disillusioned with the Axis powers. This is the point when these difference will become clear (leading to the fighting and massacre in the end). These elements are demonstrating how the novel and the movie are taking an anti-war theme. ("Captain Corelli's Mandolin," 2001) (De Berniere, 2011)

What is the dilemma for the Good Nazi?

The biggest dilemma for the good Nazis is they have to be able to maintain their allegiance to the cause. The problem is many of the atrocities they witnessed…

Sources Used in Documents:

References

Captain Corelli's Mandolin. (2001). Rotten Tomatoes. Retrieved from: http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/captain_corellis_mandolin/

De Berniere, L. (2011). Captain Corelli's Mandolin. New York, NY: Random House.


Cite this Document:

"Captain Corelli Madolin" (2012, May 10) Retrieved April 23, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/captain-corelli-madolin-111728

"Captain Corelli Madolin" 10 May 2012. Web.23 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/captain-corelli-madolin-111728>

"Captain Corelli Madolin", 10 May 2012, Accessed.23 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/captain-corelli-madolin-111728

Related Documents

Italian-Americans -- 1930s The American experience for Italian immigrants (with particular emphasis on the 1930s) is the salient topic for this paper. The materials presented from scholarly sources in this paper show the positive and negative impacts experienced by Italian-American immigrants; those sources will also be critiqued and analyzed in the context of the experiences, including impacts such as discrimination that Italian-Americans went through during the 1930s. Italians Arrive in the United

[footnoteRef:5] Although Cavour could not pursue Napoleon III to continue war with Austria due to Napoleon III facing pressure domestically and abroad, there were long-term gains made by him. Kingdom of Piedmont was recognized by many world powers. Pope's power along with hat of Austrians was significantly reduced after wars in 1950s and 60s. Nonetheless, it was due to the valor of Giuseppe Garibaldi that enabled the unification to be

The biggest reason for this was financial. Farming takes time to sow, grow and harvest, and there was simply not time for that; the Italian immigrant needed to make as much money as he could in the least time possible; farming simply would not work (2008). Farming also implied a certain amount of permanence, which was not the plan for many Italian immigrants (Mintz 2007). Land in America was also

Italian-Americans The standard history of the Italian-American experience, La Storia by Jerre Mangione and Ben Morreale, speaks of the "five hundred year" span of that experience. This is a somewhat whimsical reference to the Italian (specifically Genoese) explorer Christopher Columbus: although Columbus' 1492 voyage of discovery did indeed bring an Italian into North American waters, one can hardly call Columbus an "Italian-American." However the annual federal holiday of Columbus Day was initially

Even the better aspects of the Corleone family are shown in a light that makes them seem contrary to the personalities and wills of other, more "typical" Italian-Americans. That is, their positive qualities are shown in the film to be aberrations; departures from the Italian-American norm. Don Corleone's initial reluctance -- refusal, in fact -- to become involved in any way with the drug trade makes him appear noble, yet

People were traveling to lands like Jerusalem or Egypt, the Greek Islands and to cities like Barcelona, Lisbon or Bruges. Merchandise and aliens were bringing along traditions and civilizations different from their own. Another factor that influenced a cultural unity in Italy during the Renaissance was according to Welch the claim of being the inheritor of Rome every major Italian city had. The culture of the antiquity, Latin or Greek