Care Or Conflict: Lateral Violence In Nursing Research Paper

Length: 6 pages Sources: 6 Subject: Health - Nursing Type: Research Paper Paper: #49285613 Related Topics: Patient Care, Workplace Bullying, Patient Advocacy, Theory Of Caring
Excerpt from Research Paper :

¶ … Violence


A long-standing epidemic, which is recognized and addressed after 25 years, may be as serious as the diseases, which the healthcare industry has been zealously combating. It is called lateral violence or LV. It is hostility in both verbal and physical forms dealt by nurses upon fellow nurses under them, on the same level and among themselves. Six authors discuss its causes, forms, frequency, the victims, and approaches to this malady that distorts the very caring and compassionate image of the nursing profession.

The phenomenon sounds as new as it is repulsive and horrible, but it has been reported for more than 25 years (Farrell, 1997; Roberts, 1983 as qtd in Sheridan-Leos, 2008) but catching real attention only now. It is known as horizontal violence or hostility, bullying, aggression, verbal abuse and as ":nurses eating their young (Griffin, 2004 as qtd in Sheridan-Leos)." There is as yet no exact or universal terminology adapted to concisely describe all the actions performed within lateral violence or LV as it represents a full range of expressions of antipathy among nurses, open or secret, whether under them or to themselves (Bartholomew, 2006; Alspach, 2007 as qtd in Sheridan-Leos) while performing their dignified role as healer and givers of care. The message is simple, clear and strong: lateral violence among nurses is ironic but real and serious.

The Rationale

LV is animosity felt and addressed to one nurse by another (Sheridan-Leos, 2008). Griffin (2004 as qtd in Sheridan-Leos) described it as the content of nonverbal gestures, verbal affront, undermining behavior, keeping information away, sabotaging, infighting, scapegoating, disrespect for privacy, backbiting, and breaking confidences. It can also border on physical hostility (Longs & Sherman, 2007 as qtd in Sheridan-Leos). It has been a long-standing issue in the nursing community and profession. There are a number of theories on its origin, but the most widely accepted version is the oppressed group model (Robertts, 1983 as qtd in Sheridan-Leos). This model states that nurses are an oppressed group by domineering others (DeMarco & Roberts, 2003). It explains that oppression often occurs when a more powerful and dominant group of persons take advantage of those less powerful than them. Nurses have been construed as an oppressed group because they are mostly women who are subordinated to male physicians and administrators (Farrell, 1997 as qtd in Sheridan-Leos). Those who inflict LV consider the traditionally amiable and admirable traits of caring and compassionate nurses as less important or even meaningless when compared with medical practitioners who are the prominent figures in health care (Woelfle & McCaffrey, 2007 as qtd in Sheridan-Leos). Nurses indeed lack autonomy and control over their own work. They thus lack self-esteem and must yield to aggression to get things done in the hope of a change. This submissive-aggressive syndrome occurs when a nurse feels losing power and must regain it by overpowering others through hostility (Bartholomew, 2006). Roberts (1983 & 2000 as qtd in Sheridan-Leos) applies Freire's theory in suggesting that oppressed nurses thus exhibit similar behaviors, such as low self-esteem and self-rejection. LV develops from that lack of self-esteem and respect from others in their


The oppression theory describes such nurses not only as powerless but also oppressed in their work environment. They feel alienated with little work control. Instead of addressing the problem and risking the ire of her superior, these nurses project their hostility towards other nurses in their own level Non-verbal abuse creates stronger impact than verbal abuse (Sheridan-Leos).

Concept Analysis

This above rationale is consistent with the concept analysis conducted on the origins of LV. These are role issues, oppression, strict hierarchy rule, disenfranchising work practices, low self-esteem, self-perception of powerlessness, anger and positions of power (Embree & White, 2010). This concept analysis guides organizations in its elimination and in arming nurses with skills to crush it. Target outcomes are an improved nursing work environment, better patient care, and retention of nurses (Embree & White).

Very Real, Very Serious

Researchers led by Stanley (2008) responded to the disturbing phenomenon and conducted a survey on the incidence and severity of LV among 663 nurses at a Southeastern tertiary care medical center recently. Results showed that 46% of the participants witnessed LV and described the incidents as "very serious" or "somewhat serious" while 65% of them reported observing frequent LV among their fellow workers. The survey also recommended education and effective leadership as approaches in reducing or preventing LV that should be implemented promptly (Stanley et al.).

A Silent Indoctrination Process

The usual victims are both new and experienced nurses who must undergo a kind of "rite of passage" (Mitchel et al., 2013). Fudge (2006 as qtd in Mitchel et al.) reported that both horizontal and vertical violence have been occurring for years but have been catching serious attention only recently. Studies say that about 50% of health care workers are even physically attacked in their practice. Nurses are subjected to violence thrice more than any other professional. Statistics also reveal that a huge 62% of new nurses suffer verbal abuse. They and nursing students and new hospital faculty members have no choice but to keep quiet and submit. With their compliance to the wishes of their predators, workplace violence of this kind may never be fully unearthed and reported. New nurses are in constant demand as they must replace those who retire. Many of these newcomers who are taken in are compelled to leave because of LV although their rights are guaranteed by the American Nurse Association. This oppressive situation leads to costly and serious nursing errors and damages their morale. It also increases incidents of burnout, frustration and reduced motivation for work (Mitchel et al.).

Factors, which contribute to LV in nursing, include a discontinuity in values among the four generational levels, the challenges of new technology and increased patient level of acuity (Mitchel et al., 2013). Longos and his team (2011) identified these generations as veterans born between 1925 and 1945, baby boomers born between 1946 and 1964, Generation X born between 1965 and 1980, and Millennium born between1980 and 2000. High-level negative and serious effects of LV or workplace violence include demoralization, poor performance, poor patient care, Even mere witnesses get affected and develop negative physiological, psychological and behavioral reactions. Murray (2009) says that LV can create a fear of loss of one's career advancement and opportunities, loss of job, serious or chronic illnesses and stress (Mitchel et al.).

Verbal Abuse Most Prevalent

A study conducted by Rowe & Sherlock (2005) found that occupational burnout inclines nurses to commit verbal abuse. Nurses themselves were the most frequent source at 27%, patients' families at 25%, doctors at 22%, patients at 17%, residents at 4%, and interns at 2%. Among nurses, the most frequent sources were staff nurses at 80% and nurse managers at 20%. The study concluded that verbal abuse is a very costly issue to all involved, especially the nurses. They become more stressed and dissatisfied with their jobs, unable to finish their tasks, or regret giving quality care to patients (Rowe & Sherlock).

The Solution: Patient Advocacy

Open awareness of this horrible practice began when Meissner aired the accusation 25 years ago (Sauer, 2012). Fortunately, the means to breaking this hideous cycle are available to the victims. They can apply the principle of patient advocacy to protect themselves and fellow workers in the profession against all negative behaviors against them. They have to decide that they will not tolerate these indignities any more. They should act in concert rather than keep silent. Those not affected should extend support to the victims and confront their aggressors. They should record the incidents and the witnesses and then report these to their superiors. It is utterly…

Sources Used in Documents:


Embree, J.C. And White, A.H. (2010). Concept analysis: nurse-to-nurse lateral violence.

Vol. 45 # 3, Nursing Forum: PubMed. Retrieved on May 29, 2014 from

Mitchel, A., et al. (2013). Workplace violence among nurses: why are we still discussing this? Vol. 4 # 4, Journal of Nursing Education and Practice: Science Education.

Retrieved on May 29, 2014 from
Journal: |Times Publishing LLC. Retrieved on May 29, 2014 from -- educational-approach
Rowe, M.M. And Sherlock, H. (2005). Stress and verbal nursing: do burned-out nurses eat their young? Vol. 3 # 3, Journal of Nursing Management: PubMed. Retrieved on May 29, 2014 from
Journal of Emergency Nursing: Elsevier. Retrieved on May 29, 2014 from
Sheridan-Leos, N. (2008). Understanding lateral violence in nursing. Clinical Journal of Oncology Nursing: High Beam Research. Retrieved on May 29, 2014 from
# 11, Issues in Mental Health Nursing" PubMed. Retrieved on May 29, 2014 from

Cite this Document:

"Care Or Conflict Lateral Violence In Nursing" (2014, May 31) Retrieved May 23, 2022, from

"Care Or Conflict Lateral Violence In Nursing" 31 May 2014. Web.23 May. 2022. <>

"Care Or Conflict Lateral Violence In Nursing", 31 May 2014, Accessed.23 May. 2022,

Related Documents
Nursing Communication Plan Improving Communication
Words: 1266 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Health - Nursing Paper #: 42269369

"As such, the one caring and the one cared-for, both connect in mutual search for meaning and wholeness, and perhaps for the spiritual transcendence of suffering" (Cara 2010). Support groups can be particularly effective in dealing with cultural and generational barriers that can exist between members of the organization. Older nurses often are impatient with younger nurses, and young nurses have historically bourn the brunt of lateral violence. Through informal

Workplace Violence Among Nurses Patients Nurses Physicians and Nurses...
Words: 1812 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Health - Nursing Paper #: 63481145

Nurse Violence Workplace Violence: A Discussion Regarding the Healthcare Field Workplace violence is defined as "violent acts (including physical assaults and threats of assaults) directed toward persons at work or on duty" by the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH). This same organization also recognizes the increase in workplace violence in the healthcare field in the past few years, and the necessity to implement policies that address these disturbing trends. Furthermore, the

Workplace Violence
Words: 583 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Health - Nursing Paper #: 31999369

Workplace violence in the nursing field makes it difficult if not impossible for a nurse to do their job. Whether the bullying is lateral or vertical, the results are consistently the same: decreased self-confidence, fear, and work-related stress. Although highly discouraged by hospitals, incidents still happen regularly. This paper will focus on the reasons why bullying happens, how bullying can be avoided, and the actions hospitals should take to protect

Health Care Policy Analysis
Words: 3276 Length: 12 Pages Topic: Healthcare Paper #: 3867431

RN Risk prevention policy in practice The proposed study looks at lateral violence in U.S. healthcare institutions, through the scope of policy formation as it pertains to medical malpractice and organizational behavior in healthcare institutions. In recent years, investigations into lateral violence (LV) in the practice setting have become increasingly important as professional liability to 'duty' in patient care has been put under the microscope. In Tarasoff v. The Regents of the

Disaster Management
Words: 962 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Human Resources Paper #: 64130173

Workplace Issues/Disaster Management -- Journal Review Nursing profession faces pervasive horizontal violence and there is even a saying "nurses eat their young." Nurses should take efforts to bring a change in their existing professional culture. They can begin by sharing tips to overcome bullying and model positive behaviors. Nurses can exchange their experiences in horizontal violence through multiple workshops across the country. They have also examined different roles such as discussing

Organizational Values Organizational Foundations Visiting
Words: 625 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Health - Nursing Paper #: 33035227

It provides health-related advice on its website that all readers can benefit from, not simply those who use its services. As well as reaching out to the wider population of patients, it honors those within its fold who serve the organization with nights such as its "Celebrating Our Talent" ceremony designed to honor organizational members who have shown excellence in their duties (Boyd 2012). The climate at the organization stresses