Challenges Facing ICS Implementation Essay

Crisis Management ICS in New Orleans and Toronto

In both the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina and the outbreak of SARS in Toronto, the Incident Command System (ICS) had to implemented, yet both instances presented challenges to its implementation. In the former, the convergence of disparate agencies fueled an already chaotic situation, as few of the agencies were ICS prepared. In the latter, the outbreak was fueled by intensive, fear-causing media coverage, which ICS had to counter with education, patience, and endurance. In each case, the need for central command was essential but so was the ability of all agencies and workers to be "on the same page." This paper will compare and contrast both of these incidents and show how ICS was affected and had an impact.

Pre-Katrina, ICS in New Orleans was only being used for fire-related incidents. The emergency operations center (EOC) was not trained in ICS, thus EOC ended up being a liability rather than an asset. The challenges that the hurricane brought to the ICS concept was mainly that few were prepared to put the concept into practice. ICS training, therefore, had to be given on the spot. However, little on-site coordination among various departments added...

...

For ICS to work properly, it must be understood, embraced, and utilized by all agencies concerned. At Katrina, this was not the case -- few agencies were ready and prepared, other than the U.S. Coast Guard, which had a "spirit of mission" -- essentially meaning that the Coast Guard understood its role, had the capacity to carry it out, and displayed unity of purpose and preparedness (Samaan, Verneuil, 2009). ICS was part of its organizational culture. It should have been part of every agency's organizational culture, so that each was on the same page throughout the incident (Banerjee, n.d.), but because of a lack of planning and organization, ICS implementation sputtered from the outset.
In Toronto, the situation was different in that the chaos was caused not so much by the lack of ICS but by the over-attention given by the media to a relatively small outbreak of SARS. ICS had to contend with frenzy that was somewhat fabricated by the media, whereas in New Orleans the frenzy was real and partly caused by the unpreparedness of several agencies to handle ICS.

In Toronto, mass media portrayed the outbreak of SARS in near-apocalyptic…

Sources Used in Documents:

Reference List

Banerjee, H. (n.d.). Hurricane Katrina and New Orleans ICS Experience. NIDM.Gov.

Retrieved from http://nidm.gov.in/idmc2/PDF/Presentations/ICS/Pres5.pdf

Hawryluck, L., Lapinsky, S., Stewart, T. (2005). Clinical review: SARS -- lessons in disaster management. Critical Care, 9(4): 384-389.

Samaan, J., Verneuil, L. (2009) 'Civil-Military Relations in Hurricane Katrina: A


Cite this Document:

"Challenges Facing ICS Implementation" (2015, January 17) Retrieved April 26, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/challenges-facing-ics-implementation-2148276

"Challenges Facing ICS Implementation" 17 January 2015. Web.26 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/challenges-facing-ics-implementation-2148276>

"Challenges Facing ICS Implementation", 17 January 2015, Accessed.26 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/challenges-facing-ics-implementation-2148276

Related Documents

Operational issues of IT Department NHS Organization UK The objective of this report is to provide a proposal to reduce the IT operational costs. National Health Service (NHS) is a biggest healthcare service provider in the UK, and the organization delivers both primary and secondary healthcare since its formation. The UK government major objective for forming NHS is to provide the affordable and quality healthcare delivery for all social class in the

Intel Reform Over the Past
PAGES 9 WORDS 3379

The historical experiences of Cuba, Chile, Turkey, and even the Iran Contra affair fueled the discussions over a tighter control exercised over the Agency's structure and strategies. However, the Cold War demanded for secret operations especially taking into account the high degree of uncertainty that characterized the political environment at the time. The ideological confrontation between the West and Communist forces was often defused on the territories of third

mobile phone and telecommunications industry is one of the fastest changing industry in the world. Within short periods of time, new technologies and designs are appearing on the market and it is often a challenge to keep pace with them. Further more, the latest change have shown a certain translation from the primary objective of such a product, communicating at all times, transforming it into a product that carries

First, as Personal Trainer expands globally, the system will be available through web browsers anywhere in the world. Second, the ease of completing system upgrades across all users at the same time needs to be taken into consideration, and the use of the Web-based system architecture hosted on a Software-as-a-Service (SaaS) platform is critical. Third, by taking this approach Susan can b e assured there will be higher levels

According to Reidenberg (2000: 1318), policy in the United States protects personal information according to a market-dominated paradigm, where limited statutory and common law rights are granted for information privacy. In Europe, on the other hand, the privacy protection norm is dominated by privacy rights. The European Union, for example, requires Member States to include comprehensive statutory protections for its citizens when it comes to privacy rights. The fact that

Centralization Structure of the Model and its Operationalization The Model In the wake of a highly volatile economy, organizations must find ways to improve their bottom lines and profitability through new and innovative means. Many businesses realize that one of the most important assets that they possess is intellectual capital in the form of intellectual assets and human capital. As businesses struggle to revitalize their assets and assess their value, they are