Pedagogical comparison of Murdick and Longman composition textbooks
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
¶ … Theory
A Comparison and Critique of Two Standard College-Level English Composition Texts: A Pedagogical Review
Two very different yet similarly structure college-level English composition texts were selected for comparison in this brief overview. The first of these, William Murdick's a Student's Guide to College Composition, contains no readings (though it is not short on brief textual examples, some excerpted from published works and others the creation of the author) but is instead a purely instructional volume. It progresses from the presentation of a basic understanding of what is meant by and required in a college composition to the development of arguments and the incorporation of additional sources, to the last half of the book which is devoted to several sections on major compositional assignment types (personal narratives, literary criticism, etc.). The author presents the information in a comprehensive yet semi-informal and familiar manner, aiming primarily at accessibility.
The second text is somewhat more established and more formal in its approach, and is also four times longer.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.