Decisions in Paradise III With Paretto Analysis
Decisions in Paradise II
Cesar a Rivera
Decisions in Paradise II
This is Nik's problem
Nik has landed on Kava an island that is faced with numerous challenges including tidal waves/tsunami; typhoons/hurricanes; tornadoes; floods; fires; volcanic eruptions; earthquakes; HIV / AIDS; petroleum spill; high risk for avian flu; and terrorism, and has been asked to helped establish a business there. Aside from the above problems that impact the potential business, other challenges include the location and site being a mess; HR procedures being chaotic, disrupted and confused organizational structure; and conflicting and conflicted workforce due to diverse composition, beliefs, attitudes, and ideologies. Employees in the past, the wrong mix and too many, barely stayed and so business management and environment became increasingly chaotic.
Nik's tasks, according to Alex, consist of establishing a greater presence in Kava. Ways of establishing that presence would be up to Nik's volition and may take various forms, based on "what's good for the company and what's good for the people of Kava." Nik is expected to team up with Alex and analyze, synthesize, and prescribe regarding that decision." In short, Nik's tasks consists of stabilizing the situation, correcting past damage, and structuring the business -- its planning, managerial, leadership, and controlling aspects -- so that the business gets off to a promising start. Given the current situation and history, this is a tall order.
The outcome, according to Alex, would be "to develop and manage a very effective, as well as highly efficient, organizational structure and processes. That includes all aspects of the company; marketing, finance, purchasing, technology, human resources, physical resource, transportation, strategic planning, leadership, etc."
If Nik wishes to retain his job, he is faced with the inordinate challenge of transforming 'Paradise lost' into Paradise regained'. The decision-making methods that will help him do it is the following:
The Pareto Analysis is ideal for this situation since it helps prioritize tasks in order of importance. For Nik faced with an overwhelming surplus of responsibilities, the Pareto analysis would help him prioritize the various challenges that will most dramatically improve the situation.
Also called the 80-20 rules, the Pareto Analysis is also applicable since it serves to encourage poor Nik in his predicament. 20% of causes, according to this method generate 80% of the results; we just need to find those most significant 20% determining factors.
1. Nick would list all the problems that he would have to solve. Included here, for instance, would be attracting a compatible and steady workforce and motivating the diverse ethnic group of effectively work together for the good of the company.
2. For each stated problem, Nik would identify the fundamental cause as far as he is able. Brainstorming with Alex could help here. Lack of consistency with the organization, for instance, may be traced to the country's problems with terrorism.
3. Nik would then score each problem, the scoring method depending on the particular problem. For instance, in terms of improving customer satisfaction, Nik might score on the basis of incoming complaints, or complaints eliminated by solving the problem.
4. Nik would group problems under their root course. For instance, one or more problems that are linked to organizational mismanagement would be placed under that category.
5. The scores of each cause group would be totaled, and groups (or tasks) prioritized according to groups with higher scores receiving foremost priority.
6. Nik now has to deal with the causes of these problems starting with the top-most challenges first. Those problems with the least scores may be negligible or may have nullified themselves by the time Nik works his way to them.
Emotion often gets into the way of forming rational decision. Nik's first impetus when faced with the situation was to flee. Fleeing, however, as Alex pointed out, would make him lose his job. Faced with an overwhelming multiplicity of tasks and with internal and external confusion, Nik may likely fall into a scramble and mess up his assignment. After all, others before him had tried and failed. Nik's best and, possibly, only option, therefore, is to reduce his emotional situation to logical and mathematically structures of thinking.
Decision-making strategies, as per Lenz and Engledow (1986), result in...
The business is counting on Nik to help them out. By using the Paretto analysis, Nik can make sense of the situation, prioritize challenges, and, with Alex's help and with the help of other friendly organizations mentioned in the case history, plunge ahead.
Pareto Decision Analysis
Problem (Step 1)
Cause (Step 2)
Score (Step 3)
Location and Site Being a Mess
Lack of Organization
HR procedures being chaotic
Lack of Organization
Disrupted/Confused Organizational structure
Lack of Organization
Conflicting and Conflicted Workforce
Bad Employee Choice
Human Resources Failure
Human Resources Failure
Chaotic Business Management and Environment
Lack of organization
Root Causes of the Problems
1. Lack of Organization-16
2. Human Resources Failure-4
3. Diverse Composition-4
4. Human Resources Failure-4
Priorities Based Upon the Paretto Analysis for Nik
1. Establishment of Workflow
2. Employee Hiring/Retention
3. Human Resources and Internal Relationships
The present top down model of leadership is not working, Nik needs help in dealing with the stresses of his job. A collective-participative leadership model would likely work most effectively because Nik needs to involve lower rank and file employees while still maintaining the overall control of the situation ("Leadership Management") .
Nik and the company will derive the most benefit from better organizational efficiency. Some of this is due to growing pangs, but some is due to inefficient organization. Therefore, this author's approach to the problems is very much one of occupational safety flowing from a systems analysis of the organization's structure and efficiency.
The biggest causes flow directly from the site location being a mess and in a state of disorganization. The Kava office has very limited resources, but what it has are not being used efficiently enough. For there to be a justification to ask for more funds, what money is available has to be used efficiently.
The office is currently set up in a trailer which is a problem, in case of a tornado or a typhoon. However, since weather and geography is a factor that has to be dealt with on a regular basis, the real root cause is organization. Employees as well as the customer's safety is a concern. Also a portable office does not look presentable for potential customers or new employees. When considering the number of times Kava was affected by tornadoes, typhoons, or earthquakes, the information needs to be verified with the National Weather Service, or a similar scientific organization. Another known fact about Kava is the high number of people infected with HIV / AIDS. The number of cases is quantifiable by verifying with a local department of health. Again, all of these flow from office and organizational routine. It should not be a requirement of the CEO to remind the lower managers to check the weather or other reports or to look after basic health issues. Such factors are just part of doing business in Kava and if the company I not up to it, then perhaps they should pack up and go home.
The biggest issue, organizational efficiency can be remedied by the gradual modification of the company structure. However, there are immediate problems that have to be dealt with. Organizational efficiency has to be radically improved immediately for the survival of the company as an organization.
Companies are constantly faced with a number of internal and external factors that can affect their overall goal planning and procedures. Much of the lack of efficiency and organization is due to a disjointed work flow situation. Once the work flow is set up correctly, many problems will work themselves out almost immediately. As new problems arise, work flow needs to be changed and developed to meet those challenges.
Evaluating Resources and Actions Required for Decision Implementation Solution(s):
Work Flow Streamlining
As the organization grows, it will depend upon the work…
The effect is impressive, a typhoon induces the energy equivalent to 10000 nuclear bombs, producing several dozen meters waves, washing up coasts, buildings and basically all the constructions set under the action of the storm. The cause of the natural disaster is simple - the converging winds which gather power from Ocean coasts and conglomerate into a huge natural force that sweeps away all natural or artificial environment. There
Hurricanes & Typhoons Hurricanes and Typhoons Hurricanes and typhoons both fall under the classification "tropical cyclone," which is the generic term for what the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) calls "a non-frontal synoptic scale low-pressure system." To a lay person, this definition could be difficult to understand. But meanwhile, to simplify the definition, this "non-frontal synoptic low pressure system" must have wind speeds up to 74 MPH or higher, and be over
Nik and the following is my problem. I have been assigned to a beautiful island in order to help my team, Alex and Chris, set up their work site. Kava, the island itself, is battered with more challenges that I have ever lived with that include tidal waves/tsunami; typhoons/hurricanes; tornadoes; floods; fires; volcanic eruptions; earthquakes. Add to this mixture HIV / AIDS; petroleum spill; high risk for avian flu;
Organizational Accountability Review of Taiwan's Disaster Management Activities In Response To Typhoon Morakot Taiwanese System of Government 174 Responsibility of Emergency Management in Taiwan 175 Disasters in Taiwan 175 Citizen Participation 189 Shafritz defines citizen participation as follows: 192 Public Managers, Citizen Participation, and Decision Making 192 The Importance of Citizen Participation 197 Models of Citizen Participation 199 Citizen Participation Dilemmas 205 Accountability 207 Definitions of Accountability 207 The Meaning of Accountability 208 The Functions of Accountability 213 Citizen Participation and Accountability 216 Accountability Overloads
" The trade winds are also responsible for transporting water vapor, causing rain in Indonesia. The net effect of the trade winds is positive. However, the trade winds can have some very negative impacts, as well. In the summer, trade winds can turn into the hurricanes or typhoons, which can take a devastating toll on property and life. In fact, the trade winds are responsible for causing typhoons, which are
Although it had lost some pop, Andrew was still a Saffir-Simpson Hurricane Scale Category 3 hurricane on the second go around. but, the first round was enough to know that Andrew was bad. From a business perspective, Hurricane Andrew crippled the offshore oil facilities on its second approach throughout the gulf coast and in Louisiana where the storm added another billion dollars in damage. These financial losses did not even