Ethics And Advance Directives Ethics Term Paper

Length: 10 pages Sources: 5 Subject: Healthcare Type: Term Paper Paper: #4217204 Related Topics: Virtue Ethics, Medical Ethics, Bioethics, Donald Trump
Excerpt from Term Paper :

According to this second view, contemporaneous autonomy trumps precedent autonomy because honoring precedent autonomy imposes preferences and values of a different person, the formerly competent self (Buccafumi, p. 14).

The role that patient's families, doctors, health aides, pastors, chaplains and administrators, health educators and others play is crucial. Few people have executed an advanced directive, much less appointed a healthcare power of attorney by the time they enter a hospital with a debilitating condition. An informed consent form only marks the fact that a conversation has taken place in a health facility. The process that needs to or ought to take place concerning a patient's wishes and ensure one's wishes are empowered are part of the process involved as one fills out the advanced directive for themselves. In California the state has consolidated statutes for advanced directives and added some rights and included the best features of past laws. A patient may appoint a power of attorney for health care, or use a form to state what one's wishes are, which includes the ability to use extreme life-sustaining measures in having one's life prolonged, and/or have pain relief. An agent may be appointed to make sure these directives are carried out. Advanced directives may also expressly allow the hospital and relatives to use extreme life-sustaining procedures.

To love a person is to learn the song in his heart and to sing it when he has forgotten it," is what Sue Rubin believes the ethics of advanced directives is all about (Rubin, 2001). In other words, when a patient may no longer be able to communicate their wishes, the advanced directive and the agent named in an advanced directive does it for them.

Value assessment in ethics is the first point of departure in the differences of opinion concerning end-of-life decisions. Intervention-based approaches are the most common way that end-of-life scenarios are viewed. When a person sees all the types of medical interventions that may be used during illness and chooses what one would do in certain situations, then records these in detail for their doctors and relatives to use in medical emergencies, it is hard to decide when the actual event occurs what the person may have meant. An procedure-based approach does not ask if there is a point at which the person does not wish to go below. The bottom line is not really visible in an intervention-based approach. The false illusion that one may control every medical procedure one is going to be subjected to before one draws their last dying breath is sadly evident in the intervention-based approach.

Value-based approaches are now becoming more acceptable. It is dynamic and changing, as one experiences life. To allow a patient to change one's directives from time to time is important, as people may make broad, sweeping statements in their directives, yet when one gets down to details, one might make exceptions for certain circumstances. Choking, for example, may not require DNR orders, yet some people have a standing order for DNR in every situation, while others say that they certainly would want to be resuscitated if they choked on a peanut. An incurable, progressive, degenerative disease where treatment only prolongs dying, on the other hand, may present a different scenario where a patient may wish a DNR order to be carried out (Rubin Video).

When one allows relatives to decide and interpret a patient's wishes and make decisions which go against what the surrogate decision-maker or the patient would have wished, it is wrong. For instance, according to Donald "Dax" Cowart, who suffered burns over most of his body as a young man, in 1970, and begged the doctors to stop treatment and allow him to die, he should have had his wishes honored. As an attorney, later, he fought for the right for a patient to determine his or her own treatment or to be allowed to die if they felt this was best. He saw the doctors who treated him against his wishes as being paternalistic and was an early spokesman for the concept of patient individualism and

...

1).

When a patient receives CPR or a life-sustaining procedure against the patient's wishes as expressed in an advanced medical directive, a hospital may be liable. Interns, aides and other personnel who meet an incoming patient with a life-threatening condition need to check to see if that patient has an advance medical directive that may preclude use of some procedures. In a study of the care received by 47 critically ill elderly patients who were received in a hospital, 19 of them had advanced directives. Two of these (11%) received CPR, in spite of the directions in their advanced directives. All other things being equal, the standard of care was not influenced by whether the patient had an advanced directive or not. The conclusion of the study was that an advanced directive does not alter the quality of care given to a patient, but that hospital personnel need to find out if a patient has a legal advanced directive upon admission and abide by it (Goodman, p. 704).

Many hospitals are now putting an ethics committee in place which is available to help patients and families discuss ethical issues regarding the care of a dying patient. If there is disagreement concerning the interpretation of authority in a patient's living the ethical or medical team should meet with the family to clarify what is at stake. Exploration of the family's rationale for disagreeing with the living will is done, examining whether any new concepts have interfered since the living will was put into place and whether or not the family members have different ideas of what should be done. Sometimes the impression of what is occurring is mistaken and a revised look at the patient's best interest is reviewed, given the patient's commitments and values, compared with those of the family. Perhaps the family disagrees with the physician in interpreting the advanced directive. In this case the family, ethical committee and medical team may meet to discuss the exact terminology used in the living will.

Dialogue between all parties involved is crucial, given that the patient cannot be consulted as to proceeding. If the family is simply disagreeing with the living will and wishing to go against it, if it is legally binding, it would be difficult for them to go against it. In this case, the ethics of the family's case is weak, in that they do not wish to honor the patient's last wishes. However, if new knowledge has appeared in the treatment of the patient's condition and in the judgment of the medical team and the family, it would benefit the patient and lead to a sustained, healthy life after treatment, then, as long as it may be interpreted as the patient's wishes in regard to the living will, treatment may be sought. However, if it was the wishes of the patient that their life not be sustained in any circumstances, there is no doubt that the wishes of the patient, no matter how much the family or medical team may disagree, must be abided by.

One study found that a family opposed to the advance directive inhibited the medical team from abiding by the living will (Weiler, p. 6). Because the doctors have to deal with families who are interacting with them moment by moment in the dying patient's behalf, they often give in to a family's decision, rather than going by the advance directive. It is the living that the doctor has to answer to, rather than the comatose patient in these situations. And doctors are not dispassionate. While many doctors know that a situation may be hopeless for the patient, when the family begs to allow the patient to live on, the doctor often errs on their side (Edwards, p. 5).

Medical health care personnel and families sometimes choose to ignore advance directives if they believe what is written is not in a patient's best interest or for religious or moral reasons. If the law is misunderstood, or if there is a question of professional responsibilities or medical ethics, families and medical professionals may not wish to honor it. "It is important for you to know if your doctor will honor your request. If not, you may need to choose another doctor who will honor your request" (Caring, p. 2). The Compassionate Care Helpline advises that people bring completed living wills to their doctor and ask if the doctor has any questions or concerns. They also advise discussing their views of end-of-life procedures with their families to make sure they understand their wishes, so debates and anxiety over what should be done will not arise when the time comes.

In conclusion, medical advance directives have actually only so much power when it comes to their being used during end-of-life scenarios. When a relative of a dying patient faces…

Sources Used in Documents:

REFERENCES WHICH I DID NOT USE (JUST for YOUR INFO, NOT to BE INCLUDED in THIS PAPER)

American Nurses Association. (1985). American Nurses

Association Code for Nurses with Interpretive Statements, Section 1.1. Washington, DC:ANA.

Docker, C. (1995). Deciding How We Die. The use Limits of Advance Directives. [Online]. Available: http://www.finalexit.org/wfn27.3.html.

Fishback, R. (1996). Harvard Medical School Division of Medical Ethics. Care Near the End of Life. [Online]. Available: www.logicnet.com/archives/file2001.php.


Cite this Document:

"Ethics And Advance Directives Ethics" (2008, March 08) Retrieved July 31, 2021, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/ethics-and-advance-directives-ethics-31653

"Ethics And Advance Directives Ethics" 08 March 2008. Web.31 July. 2021. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/ethics-and-advance-directives-ethics-31653>

"Ethics And Advance Directives Ethics", 08 March 2008, Accessed.31 July. 2021,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/ethics-and-advance-directives-ethics-31653

Related Documents
Advanced Directive May Be One of the
Words: 1790 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Healthcare Paper #: 11012901

Advanced directive may be one of the most important and underutilized tools in estate planning and health planning. This is partially due to the stigma that people have about advanced directives, as if, by planning how to deal with health issues, they are somehow going to cause health problems. However, the reality is that most people will encounter at least one medical emergency during their lifetime. In the event that

Ethics in an Organization Ethics Are the
Words: 1738 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Business - Ethics Paper #: 88271645

Ethics in an Organization Ethics are the values and principles that a person utilizes in order to rule his actions and choices. In an association, a code of ethics is a set of moralities that direct the organization in its programs, rules and choices for the corporate. The ethical attitude an association uses to conduct commerce can affect the standing, efficiency and also what is considered to be the bottom line

Ethics Treating Impaired Infants Nearly
Words: 2590 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Children Paper #: 5828803

Newborn pain is an example of an everyday occurrence where achieving neonates' interests are through making them comfortable and pain-free. As the neonatal intensive care nursery gives rise to many potentially painful procedures, a dilemma exists for caregivers in assessing if sick and/or premature infants are in pain (Nagy 1998). Although newborn pain affects the short-term interests there are possibilities that the lasting effects may also be harmful (Spence,

Case Scenario Ethics
Words: 1030 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Healthcare Paper #: 36450235

Ethics State Regulations and Nursing Standards There's a clear nursing standard of practice that needs to be upheld in this case which is the act of following federal laws, largely the Patient Self-Determination Act (PSDA). Passed by Congress in 1990, "the law mandates that in healthcare institutions that receive Medicare or Medicaid funding, patients must be informed in writing upon the admission of 1) their right to accept or refuse treatment, (2)

Advanced Nursing Theory
Words: 701 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Health - Nursing Paper #: 25447419

Advanced Nursing Theory Any scientific discipline necessarily operates under the guidance of theory. Indeed, without theory, science cannot operate. On the other hand, it is also true of all theoretical disciplines that theory cannot exist without practical experimentation to support it. In fact, without the practice and experiments to further provide solid proof for theory, no theory can further develop. In this way, practical experimentation and theory go hand in order

Ethics and Compliance: HP Ethics
Words: 931 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 38970173

Looking at the consolidation of real estate locations and cores sites, HP "consolidated 85 data centers into just 6; driving key initiatives in areas such as energy efficiency, capacity utilization, 24x7 resiliency and service automation. As HP's transformation effort demonstrates, consolidating local and regional data centers can bring substantial benefits. These include lower costs and higher availability; simpler, more cost-effective operations; and automation of routine management functions" (Hewlett- Packard Website.