The behavior engaged in was not illegal. Nor is it illegal to be a transgendered individual. The company's actions were discriminatory. He was not fired because he was a poor employee but because of his actions away from the job.
Who are the stakeholders, and how are they impacted by this situation?
The stakeholders were Peter Oiler, his manager and Winne Dixie. Peter Oiler faced the prospect of not having a job and being ostracized in the community. The manager faced the consequences of loosing a good employee in Mr. Oiler and having to deal with the consequences if he chose not to fire Oiler. Winn Dixie would be affected if Oiler's lifestyle somehow reflected badly on the company/. It may also be the case that Winn Dixie would be negatively affected if customers saw the way this outstanding employee was treated and decided that the company was discriminating against him.
Do you agree with the federal judge's decision? If you were the judge, what would you do?
The judge had no choice if the wording of the law is such that transgender people were not protected under the law at that time. I would probably have to rule the same way but I would make it clear that just because no law exist for that type of discrimination, the way the firing of the employee was still discriminatory.
A recently passed ordinance in New Orleans prohibits discrimination against...
However, the Winn-Dixiebranch that fired Oiler is located just outside that jurisdiction. Does this affect your answer to #2?
No. Discrimination is discrimination.
For what after-hours behavior do you feel it is appropriate to terminate an employee? For what after-hours behavior is it not appropriate? Where do you draw the line, and how would you describe that line if you were developing a policy to put into an employee manual?
IT would be appropriate to terminate an employee for off the job behavior that is illegal such as selling drugs, murder, stealing, fraud and things of this nature. In such cases the off duty behavior of employees could definitely affect the business. It is not appropriate for employers to terminate employees for engaging in activities that are not illegal and for which the company's name will not be adversely affected. The problem is that some legal activities might indeed affect a company's image. Company's have to establish what activities are acceptable and what activities are not acceptable and make these activities known to employees. A list of such activities should be established in the employee handbook and if they are violated the employer should have the right to terminate or suspend the employee. The line would be whatever activities I knew would be detrimental to the ability of the business to make a profit.
Ethical systems can be principled, but still contain reasonable exceptions without being purely relativistic. I acknowledge that there are many different types of moral situations under which one must apply one's principles. Q2: Support My moral system most closely mirrors what could be called a 'virtue ethics' position: I believe in moral standards, but I believe that learning how to be a virtuous and compassionate person who is empathetic to others
Business Ethics Ethical Egoist- Egoism can be either descriptive or normative. Descriptive egoism holds that for each individual, there is only one ultimate aim -- survival and the betterment of the sole individual based on their own hierarchical principles. Normative egoism has the individual making claims about what should be done to do the "right" thing, rather than what one does. As well, ethical egoism insists that for an action to
Medical Coding Ethics Ethical Concerns in Health Care Delivery: Focus on Medical Coding and Billing Practices The objective of this study is to examine ethical concerns medical coding and billing in the physician office. Medical coding and billing has become very complex in light of health care reform. Recently, Christopher Gregory Wayne, reported to be "dubbed the Rock Doc" was arrested on a dozen charges of Medicare fraud" when he was accused
Operations Management Business Ethics Ethical issues impact business on multiple different levels, and sometimes businesses can find it difficult to make ethical or appropriate decisions. One recent headline-making case highlights how difficult ethical decision-making can be for real-life businesses faced with real-life scenarios. After an African-American waitress received a bill that had "None, Nigger" written in the tip line, she posted the tip on her Facebook page. She removed that post, but
Reynolds and Bowie (2004) show that the three most important criteria of a Kant-based ethics system are to "act as though the maxim of your action were to…become a universal law of nature," to "act so that you treat humanity…always as an end and never as a means only" and "act as if your maxims should serve at the same time as universal law for all rational beings." These
Social Worker Ethics Ethical dilemma: Privacy and Confidentiality One of the most difficult situations for a social worker is when he or she must deal with confidentiality issues regarding a minor. For example, if a social worker is counseling an adolescent girl with an eating disorder in the context of a family intervention, the girl's understandably concerned parents may wish that the social worker disclose what the girl says during private therapy sessions.