Financial Development Term Paper

Length: 8 pages Sources: 7 Subject: Economics Type: Term Paper Paper: #51255270 Related Topics: Deregulation, Sharia Law, Financial Ratio Analysis, Saudi Arabia
Excerpt from Term Paper :

Financial Development

Every country has a different level of financial development. The World Bank uses four measures of banking development: depth, access, efficiency and stability. An international banking conglomerate considering expansion will want to understand a country's local banking conditions in order to have the most informed view, to help with making the expansion decision. In this scenario, the countries being evaluated are the United States, Saudi Arabia, Brazil, India, South Africa, Iran, China and Turkey. This report will analyze the banking systems of each of these countries against the World Bank criteria.

Basic Economic Conditions

Before investigating the banking systems in each country, a brief overview will be provided of the prevailing economic conditions in each nation. The size of the economy, measured by GDP and by GDP per capita, is related to the market potential for a bank to enter the country. The more money there is a country, the better it will be for a bank to enter. The following figures were calculated from the CIA World Factbook.

Country

GDP Size (PPP) (billions)

GDP Rank

GDP Growth

GDP per capita

United States

$16,720

1

1.6%

$52,800

Saudi Arabia

$927

19

3.6%

$31,300

Brazil

$2,416

7

2.3%

$12,100

India

$4,990

3

3.2%

$4,000

South Africa

$595

25

2%

$11,500

Iran

$987

18

-1.5%

$12,800

China

$13,390

2

7.7%

$9,800

Turkey

$1,667

16

3.8%

$15,300

UK

$2,387

8

1.8%

$37,300

This figures show that all of the economies selected for study are fairly large. The following should be taken into consideration with respect to these statistics. First, Saudi Arabia's economy has cooled off considerable in the past few years. Second, Turkey's economic growth is highly volatile. It is further worth noting that the economic performance of both Saudi Arabia and Iran is almost entirely related to the price of oil. As oil goes, so too do those economies. There are substantial differences in GINI index in these different countries as well. Most Saudis earn must less than the GDP per capita figure, as wealth is highly-concentrated in that country. In South Africa, there are stark class divisions as well, with the relatively small population of white South Africans living roughly a Western standard of life, but most black South Africans living in poverty. Such great wealth disparities reflect on the size of retail banking markets in particular.

Banking Industry Structure

Before investigating the banking indicators, there is one critical factor that must be considered, which is the openness of the banking system. The United States has an open banking system with fairly little regulation compared with most countries. The retail banking system is somewhat diffuse, but is becoming more concentrated. Thus, it is open for expansion but not as concentrated as the UK market. There are three closed banking systems on this list, in China, Saudi Arabia and Iran, where foreign banks are allowed minimal presence if any, and the banking system is almost entirely populated by state-owned enterprises. Of these countries, South Africa has the banking system most similar to that of the UK in terms of structure and openness.

Banking System Measures

The World Bank provides data on the banking systems of countries around the world. The following chart reflects data from the banking systems of the different countries that have been chosen for analysis, with figures from 2011. There is no real benefit to looking at data past that unless it shows something distinctive about the trend. The current situation and future situation are what matter. Loading up the analysis with superfluous data will undermine the principle of clarity in

...

In the past, regulations meant that retail banks were restricted to the state level, and that there was separation between retail and investment banking. Successive waves of deregulation in recent decades have removed this restrictions, so there is increasing concentration in the U.S. banking industry (Chossudovsky, 2008). Nevertheless, it remains of the most diffuse banking industries in the world.

The U.S. has generally favourable metrics. The country has the second-highest rate of access to banking among nations studied. The U.S. banking access level appears to have reached a saturation point as the trend in access is unchanged in recent years. The deposits are declining in relation to GDP. This measure has to be understood in context, whereby the as the U.S. economy grows (which it is) the U.S. consumer tends to swap savings for spending. Right now, savings rates are declining in the U.S. As the economy improves, explaining the change in this ratio (FRED, 2014). The U.S. banks have moderate performance in terms of efficiency, and they are trending in the wrong direction. This could highlight overcapacity in the industry, when looked at in context of the very high access numbers. The z-score is highest among all nations, indicating that the U.S. has the least stable banking system among these countries. This might seem counterintuitive, but this is an industry that might have capacity industry, where just recently there were hundreds of bankruptcies of banks including high profile ones, and where the government needed to bail out the entire banking system to prevent its collapse. The high level of deregulation has led to excessive risk-taking within the U.S. banking system, and thus its very high z-score. The U.S. Federal Reserve provides data on that nation's banking balance sheet, illustrating that systemwide there is sufficient liquidity, but not an exceptional level by any means (U.S. Federal Reserve, 2014). Overall, the U.S. is going to be a tough market to enter, because of saturation, inefficiency and higher risk of default than in any of the other banking systems. Only the size of the economy and minimal barriers to entry make the U.S. An attractive market.

Saudi Arabia

Saudi has a closed banking system, wherein the banks -- along with most of the major corporations in the country -- are owned by government. There are 13 domestic banks. Saudi banks are also Islamic banks, meaning that entering the Saudi market will require the ability run a bank on Sharia law principles (KSA, 2013). The country has relatively low access, though access is increasing. In addition, Saudi has the lowest score for bank assets/GDP. On the plus side, the Saudi banking system is relatively efficient, and has a decent z-score. The backing of the government, underwritten by oil, helps ensure the stability of the Saudi banking system. The access score highlights potential opportunity, where the country may be underserved, but deposits are low. While deposits and access should be correlated, the causal relationship is not known. It is possible that access is low because bank deposits are low, or vice versa.

Saudi Arabia has relatively low access to its capital markets. Those markets had decent depth in 2007, but since that point, stock market depth in Saudi has collapsed to what is now a very low level. Market efficiency has declined in that same time period, as the infrastructure has remained the same but the amount of money cycling through the market has declined. Not surprisingly, Saudi Arabia's capital markets have seen a decline in stability over this same time period.

Brazil

Brazil has the highest penetration of bank branches, highlighting strong growth. But for Brazilians, access is high, and growing, indicating that the banking system is still being built out, but with access well above most other countries there is also the threat that the industry is over capacity. The high level of deposits relative to GDP, however, indicates that growth in the Brazilian banking system is probably being driven by rising demand. Overhead costs have been volatile in recent years, and are much higher than in other countries. This is to be expected in an economy where the banking system is growing -- new branches cost money, and high overhead costs are an indicator of an inefficient system that may be set to contract. That said, the z-score is reasonable, meaning that there is good stability in the Brazilian banking system.

Access to capital markets in Brazil is only average, and has not changed much. The same can be said for depth measures. Because of the low level of access, market efficiency is relatively low. However, the Brazilian capital markets are relatively stable. Brazil has high wealth…

Sources Used in Documents:

References

Chossudovsky, M. (2008). Global financial meltdown: Sweeping deregulation of the U.S. banking system. Global Research Retrieved December 5, 2014 from http://www.globalresearch.ca/global-financial-meltdown-sweeping-deregulation-of-the-us-banking-system/10588

CIA World Factbook: Various pages. (2014). Retrieved December 5, 2014 from https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/us.html

Dheghan, S. (2014). UK and Iran agree to re-establish direct diplomatic relations. The Guardian. Retrieved December 5, 2014 from http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/feb/20/uk-iran-direct-diplomatic-relations

FRED. (2014). Personal savings rate. Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis. Retrieved December 5, 2014 from http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/PSAVERT/
KSA. (2013). Banking. Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Retrieved December 5, 2014 from http://www.saudiembassy.net/about/country-information/economy_global_trade/banking.aspx
US Federal Reserve. (2014). Assets and liabilities of commercial banks in the United States. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System. Retrieved December 5, 2014 from http://www.federalreserve.gov/releases/h8/current/


Cite this Document:

"Financial Development" (2014, December 07) Retrieved January 18, 2022, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/financial-development-2154301

"Financial Development" 07 December 2014. Web.18 January. 2022. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/financial-development-2154301>

"Financial Development", 07 December 2014, Accessed.18 January. 2022,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/financial-development-2154301

Related Documents
Financial Development and Economic Growth the United
Words: 2291 Length: 7 Pages Topic: Economics Paper #: 20015205

Financial Development and Economic Growth The United States of America has made significant developments with respect to their financial market which in turn has resulted in the form of high economic growth. When we compare the U.S., which has one of the most developed financial markets, to other less developed countries, we find that the United States accumulates capital and grow at a higher rate due to markets being more stable.

Financial Management Is an Important
Words: 1730 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Education - Computers Paper #: 38753081

(2009). Google's Big IPO, Five Years Later. [Article]. Wall Street Journal - Eastern Edition, 254(40), C3. Davis, H.Z., & Peles, Y.C. (1993). Measuring Equilibrating Forces of Financial Ratios. The Accounting Review, 68(4), 725-747. Google Inc. (2012). 2011 Annual Report. Mountain View, CA: Google Inc. Kirby, J. (2009). How Google really does it. (Cover story). [Article]. Canadian Business, 82(18), 54-58. Lee, M.-j. (2010). Measuring the Usage Effects of Tying a Messenger to Windows: A

Financial Systems, Economic Growth, and
Words: 2741 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Economics Paper #: 15183623

This aspect of the study were inclusive of works of "economic historians on the development of financial systems" most particularly the "banking systems" worldwide and exactly what the resulting impact will be. (Rousseau & Sylla, 2001) While the two identified "strands of literature" one dealing with domestic and the other international developments, are no always related to one another" but are however, both elements of the story called financial

Development and Growth in the Field of CED
Words: 1835 Length: 6 Pages Topic: Public Administration Paper #: 56646688

Development and Growth in the Field of CED Development and growth are some of the most commonly used terms in the field of community economic development. The field of community economic development (CED) focuses on promoting the involvement of a community when working with public and private sectors towards the creation of strong markets, industries, and communities. This field also focuses on encouraging the use of local resources in a manner

Financial Management and Analysis
Words: 4130 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Economics Paper #: 20964033

stock market and the Banks promote economic growth and it provides a critique of their functions in transitional economies. Every country depends on its economy for its growth. For a country to be stable it has to be stable in terms of its economy. Bank and stock market contribute to a great extent to the economy growth of every country where it provides firms with opportunity to get funds

Banking Response to the Financial Crisis
Words: 3415 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Sports - College Paper #: 33344151

Financial Crisis The American banking system was in crisis from late 2007 through to early 2009. The subprime mortgage crisis had left many banks with large amounts of so-called "toxic assets" on their books, mainly in the form of subprime mortgages and mortgage-backed securities that were now under water. The mortgage-backed securities were one of the biggest problems, because they were presented as being of investment grade, which did not align