Sign Up Now
Get instant access to over 1 million+ study documents
OR
Already registered? click here to login
By creating your account, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and student honor code.
The hospital should always defer to the patient and family that has an advanced directive in place, and if the patient cannot speak for themselves but has an advanced directive, then a proxy must make the decision. The only case where the hospital should be allowed to make the decision on futile care is in the absence of a proxy, in the absence of an advanced directive, and only if it is in the best interest of the patient.
In this psychological-based model, the healthcare professional and hospital is put in the position of negotiating with the family and/or patient. Burns and Truog (2007) state that in these situations the healthcare professional should always follow the wishes of the patient's family in futile care efforts (Burns & Truog, 2007). However, that view places a burden on the healthcare professional to compromise medical principles when that professional deems the care to be inappropriate and ultimately unnecessary (Forde, 1998).
In brief, there may be situations that are very clearly defined as situations where futile care is not warranted; in other situations the issue may not be so easy to determine and requires more objective clarification. Marsden (1995) examined data from a six-year time period of cardiac arrests for the Scottish Ambulance Service. The finding was that those patients with a non-shockable rhythm never survived resuscitation attempts. The results of the Marsden study led to the development of guidelines for ambulance personnel in Scotland given in the form of a quick algorithm that could be used on scene (Marsden, Ng, Dalziel, & Cobbe, 1995).
Conclusion
The hospital, in designing a futile care policy, must adhere to state ethical standards and state laws. In the State of Massachusetts, for example, it is punishable...
Therefore it is the onus of the hospital to have a bioethics committee to oversee compliance of its healthcare professionals with state regulations and in keeping with the wishes of the family and patient in question. Clearly there will be gray area in attempting to figure out what the right thing to do is in certain situations, yet having compliance guidelines such as advanced directives, adherence to state laws, and recognizing the autonomy of patients and the rights of families will ultimately dictate the outcome in futile care cases.
References
Burns, J., & Truog, R. (2007). Futility: A Concept in Evolution. Chest, 1987-1993.
Forde, R. (1998). Who is to define the futility of treatment -- the patient or the physician? Tidsskr nor Laegeforen (Norwegian), 2652-2654.
Jonson, a., Seigler, M., & Winslade, W. (2002). Clinical Ethics 5th ed. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill.
Lachman, V. (2009). Ethical Challenges in Health Care: Developing Your Moral Compass. New York, NY: Springer Publishing.
Massachusetts Office of Health and Human Services. (2011). Decision-making Guidelines. Retrieved January 18, 2011, from Massachusetts Office of Health and Human Services: http://www.mass.gov/?pageID=eohhs2terminal&L=6&L0=Home&L1=Provider&L2
Medical procedures, like chemotherapy and radiation, are frequently used to alleviate pain and symptoms and for cure. Intravenous medications tackle pain but are also costlier than other forms. The appearance of new and costlier drugs blurs the fine line between life-saving and mere comfort-giving. Chemotherapy can shrink a tumor to allow swallowing and radiation can ease or reduce pain. If the hospice is not well financed, one or two
(Menzel, 1990, p. 3) Fisher, Berwick, & Davis alude to the idea of integration in health care, with providers linking as well as creating networks of electronic medical records and other cost improvement tactics. The United States and other nations over the last twenty or so years, have begun a sweeping change in health care delivery, regarding the manner in which health information is input, stored and accessed. Computer use
Medical Futility in Nursing Care CARING AND CHOOSING Bioethics is described as both a field of intellectual inquiry and a professional practice that examines moral questions affecting various disciplines (Arras, 2007). These disciplines include biology, medicine, law, public health, policy and ethics. In these disciplines are scholars, teachers, and clinical practitioners, including nurses. Their work has recently been subjected to an unprecedented turn in perspectives concerning relevant issues and behaviors. Among these
PPSPA bills would have enabled federal regulation to perform this more efficiently than present regulation efforts exerted by the States and the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education or ACGME. Restrictions to the ACGME self-regulation will be a problem only it they already exist. The problem is really that Congress is reluctant to pass laws to federally mandate these restrictions. Opponents to these restrictions teem the political milieu at
Critical Thinking Case Study Faith Community Hospital is a not-for-profit health care services organization that is currently facing a situation, which may compel it to resort to stringent cost cutting measures just to break even, and that too providing the average reimbursement rate does not change. Financial problems, however, are just one of the several problems that Faith Community Hospital must resolve in order for the organization to maintain and further
Quality Improvement Program Needs Assessment and Quality Improvement Plan Paula Stechschulte, PhD, RN Quarter This paper discusses the process of drafting a quality improvement plan at a community level medical facility, a plan that is aimed at reducing days under urinary catheter and also reducing the rates of infections associated with the said catheters. As a high rate of incidence of infection related to catheter usage is costly for the hospital, this implementation