Future Legislation: The Impact On Thesis

Length: 14 pages Sources: 10 Subject: Healthcare Type: Thesis Paper: #21191836 Related Topics: Radiation, Title Vii, Pharmaceutical Industry, Medicare And Medicaid
Excerpt from Thesis :

The independent physician groups and hospitals provide services under the organization's guidelines, but they may also care for patients who are not members. (1997)

While managed care does offer employers more control in choosing the specifics of the health care plan provision at the same time the insurance companies and the profit-drive health-care organizations possess a strong role. Opponents of the government having a primary role in health care financing state that managed care "raises the specter of rationing, lower quality, less freedom to choose physicians, interference with physicians' clinical autonomy, reduced access to specialty care and teaching hospitals, and increased government regulation." (Gottlieb and Einhorn, 1997) Further criticism has been stated in relation to the financial mechanisms employed by managed-care plans geared toward efficiency due to the risk of providers relating to penalties or rewards based on some measures of efficiency.

While health care providers are expected "to provide a wide range of services, recommend the best treatments, and improve the patient's quality of life. However, to keep costs down, they must limit the use of diagnostic services and specialty care, increase efficiency, and shorten the time spent with each patient." (Gottlieb and Einhorn, 1997) According to the American Medical Association there are ethical implications relating to the managed care financial arrangements. Also stated to be fundamental issues in this debate is the fact that "...academic medical centers do not fit naturally within managed-care systems because their missions are so different from those of largely service-oriented managed-care institutions." (Gottlieb and Einhorn, 1997) in fact, the expenses associated with maintaining research and education quality has resulted in many academic medical centers selling the hospital segment of their business.


The David and Lucille Packard Foundation journal 'The Future of Children' Vol. 8, No. 2 states that managed care has "...revolutionized the health care system in America." (1998) Managed care is described as a "vast array of financing and health care delivery practices that are designed to limit costs and ration care." (David and Lucille Packard Foundation, 1998) it is additionally related that healthcare providers and insurers have "created cost0conscious health insurance plans and employers and individuals are subscribing to them at unprecedented rates." (Ibid, 1998) Characteristics common to managed health care plans are inclusive of those as follows:

1) Strong financial incentives for members to obtain health care from only selected providers and hospitals that follow the rules established by the plan.

2) Reliance on gatekeepers, preauthorization, and other techniques to control access to specialty care, diagnostic tests, and hospitalization.

3) Shared financial risk among doctors, the health plan, and other health care professionals through the use of capitated payment methods or bonuses and penalties. (David and Lucille Packard Foundation, 1998)

According to this study reported in 1998, managed care has the potential of improving "delivery, quality and financing of health care services..." (Ibid) Additionally provider networks have served to improve both access to and coordination of care and in addition "the use of financial incentives to providers and members may promote preventive health care." (Ibid, 1998) the information systems which are very sophisticated have the potential to bring about improvement to accountability to customers through costs and services being monitored as well as the health of the managed care system members. Managed care has served to:

1) Reduce overall health care costs;

2) Stimulate the growth of for-profit health care;

3) Stimulate the growth of 'for-profit' health care;

4) Improve the access to preventive health and specifically for children who are privately insured;

5) Decrease access to preventive health care for children enrolled in Medicaid; and 6) Reduce access to specialty care for all insured children with an illness that is 'chronic or disabling'. (Ibid, 1998) critical feature of the revolutionary managed care system is the opportunity that presents in the creation of a managed care system that 'works for children'. The features of such a system are stated as follows:

1) a "medical home" that provides accessible,...


(Ibid, 1998)

The work of Seymour H. Levitt (2000) entitled: "Impact of Managed Care on Scholarly Activity and Patient Care: Case Study of 12 Academic Radiology and Radiation Oncology Departments" published in the Journal of Radiology reports a study in which "Six departments of radiology and six departments of radiation oncology from areas with low, medium, or high managed care penetration were asked to complete a questionnaire designed to address the impact of managed care on research and scholarly activity. Information, when available, was taken from fiscal years 1993 and 1998." According to Levitt site visits were made to the 12 departments which were then followed up with questionnaires. Findings of the study show that the departments that had "medium to high managed care penetration" had reported a higher level of dissatisfaction "in their ability to remain active in their education and research goals." (2000)

The results of this study indicate "...that for the period surveyed, the departments needed to increase clinical time to make up for decreasing patient care revenues. In turn, this has reduced the time and money devoted to scholarly activities. Information from this study will be used to develop a trends database for all U.S. radiology and radiation oncology departments. This, together with a more comprehensive study by the RSNA, will assist in measuring the current and potential long-term impact of managed care and other system changes on the practice of radiology and radiation oncology." (Levitt, 2000)

Levitt states that in the current focus held in health care on the marketing and economics of health care that the discussion surrounding health care is quickly becoming "one solely of dollars, policy, budgets and marketing strategies." (2000) This puts the primary purpose and mission of medical care, which is providing care to ill people at risk and diminishes this central purpose. According to Levitt (2000), health care professionals are "being challenged to clearly and strongly define" precisely who they are and what they do in order to "prevent this erosion of the central purpose" of the mission of those in the health care profession as they go about shaping the profession's future in the health care environment characterized by "rapid changes." (Levitt, 2000)

The health care professional's primary responsibility is to its patients and in order to make provision of the "best technology and clinical experience" to patients it is necessary that the health care professional of today "support and participate in scholarly activities" that serve to best inform the health care profession of the best methods of caring for their patients. The following figure is stated by Levitt to illustrate the relation of quality patient care to organizations that sponsor educational and research activities.

Relation of Quality Care to Organizations that Sponsor Educational and Research Activities

Source: Levitt (2000)

Levitt reports that centers of education and research and academic health centers are "under threat from the combined dominance of managed care and legislation results from the 1997 Balanced Budget Act. The revenue that is received from patient care that has been provided at academic health centers and that has been derived from research has been historically utilized in supporting academic health center activities which includes education in basic and clinical science and this revenue is stated by Levitt (2000) to contribute "up to 90% of the budget" however, "with the current focus on cost and budgets, serious problems are occurring within these institutions that are regulating research and education to secondary status..." This has resulted in health care that is high quality in nature being threatened.

In the absence of a strong focus on research and development towards testing new technology and pharmaceutical benefits and risks future health care quality is at risk. Undermining the current and future skill and problem-solving abilities of physicians is the lack of a strong commitment to education. Because previous studies which have cited the adverse effect of managed care on scholarly pursuits have been for the most part merely "anecdotal" the RSNA developed a "two phase project to systematically and scientifically examine the impact of managed care on the scholarly activities of departments of radiology and radiation oncology in the United States." (Levitt, 2000)

Levitt states that the goals of the questionnaires in this study were to "...establish a trends database for all radiology and radiation…

Sources Used in Documents:


The Future of Managed Care (2003) Online available at http://www.ncmedicaljournal.com/jan-feb-03/ar010303.pdf

Levitt, Seymour H. (2000) Impact of Managed Care on Scholarly Activity and Patient Care: Case Study of 12 Academic Radiology and Radiation Oncology Departments. Journal of Radiology 2000;216:618-623. Online available at http://radiology.rsnajnls.org/cgi/content/full/216/3/618

Gottlieb, Scott and Einhorn, Thomas a. (1997) Current Concepts Review - Managed Care: Form, Function and Evolution. The Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery 79:125-36 (1997). Online available at http://www.ejbjs.org/cgi/content/full/79/1/125

Jennings, Mary Carol (2008-2009) 2008-2009 Legislative Agenda American Medical Student Association - Prepared by the 2008-2009 Jack Rutledge Legislative Director of the American Medical Students Association. Online available at http://www.amsa.org/legislativecenter/0809LegislativeAgenda.pdf

Cite this Document:

"Future Legislation The Impact On" (2009, January 18) Retrieved October 22, 2021, from

"Future Legislation The Impact On" 18 January 2009. Web.22 October. 2021. <

"Future Legislation The Impact On", 18 January 2009, Accessed.22 October. 2021,

Related Documents
Future of Radio What Is
Words: 4053 Length: 12 Pages Topic: Communication - Journalism Paper #: 33134248

He doesn't mention Apple's iPod, iPod Touch, and iPad, but those devices also pose a challenge for traditional radio broadcasting. People can "…select music that suits their individual tastes and many have wider repositories of music in their own libraries" -- thanks to the iTunes and similar services -- than are offered on the playlists of radio broadcasters (Picard, p. 1). Moreover, Satellite and Internet radio are offering "hundreds of

Legislation of Foreign Nurses Practicing in the United States
Words: 2042 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Health - Nursing Paper #: 16385907

Legislation of Foreign Nurses Practicing in the United States The United States Health Care system is undergoing a major crisis of nurse-staffing shortage. A survey conducted by the American Hospital Association -- AHA of 715 hospitals performed during spring 2001 showed that a vacancy of 126,000 positions of registered nurses prevails through out the nation. The International Council of Nurses -- ICN, a federation of 125 nursing organizations indicated it to

Legislation on Foreign Nurses Practicing in the United States
Words: 1310 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Health - Nursing Paper #: 50385245

Legislation Pertaining to Foreign Nurses Practicing in the United States Discuss the process that this legislation will go through, referencing the steps to the legislative and administrative process The Rural and Urban Health Care Act of 2001 (S 1259 and HR 2705) dramatically expanded the existing H-1C temporary nursing visa program established in 1999. Before, there were only three ways that foreign-educated nurses could get permission to enter the United States to

Future of Nursing in Texas
Words: 2033 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Health - Nursing Paper #: 59858365

Texas is one of the strictest states in the country for nurse practitioners who want to open their own clinics, requiring them to find a physician with the willingness and time to follow a complex set of rules. Those rules include requiring the physician to delegate prescriptive authority, review patient charts, make on-site visits or practice within a certain geographical distance of the nurse practitioner. It's a system many nurse

Future of Healthcare Workers Running
Words: 1902 Length: 6 Pages Topic: Health - Nursing Paper #: 59764202

Many of them who have worked for 20 years as nurses have gone up the managerial or corporate ladder. More and more nurses have chosen more paper work and less patient care by becoming supervisors, administrators and nursing directors and then retire or else proceed to another career if they are not yet retiring (Benjamin). Compounding the problem of shortage were a lack of surgical educational content and clinical experiences

Future Challenges Facing U.S. Healthcare: One of
Words: 965 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Healthcare Paper #: 13187939

Future Challenges Facing U.S. Healthcare: One of the major issues that the United States has encountered in the recent years is the country's healthcare system especially in the wake of the need for healthcare reforms. However, even with the ratification of healthcare reform policies by the Obama administrations, the country's healthcare system is likely to continue facing some challenges in the future. Current Healthcare Problems in the U.S.: The current healthcare system in