Globalization And Human Resources And Immigration Policy Essay

Length: 2 pages Subject: Careers Type: Essay Paper: #55322072 Related Topics: Illegal Immigration, Title Vii, Immigration, Discrimination In The Workplace
Excerpt from Essay :

¶ … unfair" are value judgments -- by definition they cannot be facts. Is it an unfair employment practice for an employer to prefer a U.S. citizen? Any preference not rooted in empirical analysis is unfair -- only hard empirical facts are neutral in that sense.

But it is not actually legal to discriminate on the basis of national origin, as per the Civil Rights Act of 1964, Title VII. So such a policy would, for a company that is affected by the law, be illegal. The company is obligated to hire the best candidate who is legally allowed to work in the United States, regardless of their citizenship status. So it's unfair and illegal.

As to whether this is a wise policy or not, it rather depends on one's perspective. Title VII was written as more of a social policy than an employment policy, but of course it directly affects employment. As a matter of eliminating discrimination in the workplace, it's a good policy. But government sets employment policies for other reasons, and since we are discussing foreign workers, the policy is intended to increase and improve the pool of labor available to American corporations. On that score, the policy is effective, because it arguably creates more opportunities for the U.S. To skim top talent away from other countries by giving those high-quality workers more opportunity...


If the objective is to improve the prospective immigrant pool, the policy is effective as well. It contrasts with the family focus of other immigration policy, but the non-discrimination rule does create opportunities for companies to hire high-quality immigrants for jobs in the U.S.

I will take the statement that TN workers from Canada or Mexico can work in the U.S. easier than people from other countries at face value. Yes, this makes sense, especially in light of NAFTA. Politically, those are the two countries with which the U.S. should have the best relations, as they are our neighbors. Further, more of their best workers can be attracted to the U.S., and the proximity makes them more likely to do it. Economically, there are two ways to look at it. First, with NAFTA there is already relatively smooth movement of goods and capital between the three countries, so it makes sense that labor can also move smoothly. Arguably, NAFTA does not go far enough in this regard, relative to something like the EU. However, the other view is that any preference is going to give rise to economic inefficiency. If the U.S. theoretically set a quota of 500,000 immigrants in a given year, the economically optimal choice is to bring in the 500,000 best. Favoring one country over another serves as a barrier to this, and will create deadweight loss.

Foreign nationals who attend university in the U.S. should have advantages over others. Basically, after four years, those people will have better contacts in the U.S., may have already proven their ability to work, may have received some form of taxpayer financing,…

Cite this Document:

"Globalization And Human Resources And Immigration Policy" (2015, July 28) Retrieved January 18, 2022, from

"Globalization And Human Resources And Immigration Policy" 28 July 2015. Web.18 January. 2022. <>

"Globalization And Human Resources And Immigration Policy", 28 July 2015, Accessed.18 January. 2022,

Related Documents
Human Resources International Human Resource Management International...
Words: 3525 Length: 12 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 60424343

Human Resources International Human Resource Management International Business HR: Vital and Pivotal During the 20th century, the human resources (HR) function has become quite skilled at managing human capital which is frequently defined as the skills, knowledge and experience of individual workers within a company. Human resources management has never been more vital to organizations than it is today as more and more businesses are going global. For globalizing companies, experienced, informed and

Human Resources Management Has Changed
Words: 567 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Careers Paper #: 56697943

Human resource managers must help their companies become more sensitive to the issues of sexism, religion, sexual orientation, marital and family status, age, and other life experiences. The economic position of most companies has shifted drastically in the past decade. One of the strongest forces influencing the way we do business is the phenomenon of globalization, a process in which companies in countries around the world are increasingly linked. A

Human Trafficking the State Department of the
Words: 6416 Length: 20 Pages Topic: Business - Law Paper #: 99928662

Human Trafficking The State Department of the U.S. Government has for the past ten years issued an annual report on the state of laws governing human trafficking. The latest report shows that most of the world's industrialized countries have enacted laws to protect against human trafficking. This includes recognizing that human trafficking is a problem and having taken steps to address the issue (Wu & Zifcak, 2010). Most countries in the

Globalization and Organized Crime Globalization
Words: 3395 Length: 12 Pages Topic: Criminal Justice Paper #: 51194259

Thus, many shipments go to another destination before the United States or Europe in order to throw law enforcement off of the trail. For cocaine coming out of Colombia, West Africa and Venezuela, home to rogue states and dictatorships, have become popular transit hubs. The increased transportation of goods accompanying globalization has increased opportunities for maritime piracy. Organized crime is exploiting the increasingly dense international flow of commercial vessels. Maritime

Globalisation Is the Process by
Words: 1970 Length: 6 Pages Topic: Anthropology Paper #: 67095451

Immigration policy, distance and financial constraints reduce the flow of people. Religions are notoriously difficult to pass from culture to the next because of the deep level of personal involvement. Languages are passed to outsiders only when pragmatic, as in the case of lingua francas. As long as the barriers to passing important cultural artifacts between cultures remain, globalisation will remain in evidence mostly with what can be transferred

Globalization Is Becoming a More
Words: 2419 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Anthropology Paper #: 2472929

McDonaldization Directly linked with cultural globalization and actually deriving from the basic concepts at the forefront of globalized culture - glocalization and grobalization - is McDonaldization. The term is generically used to present the strategies implemented by the American fast food chain in 'conquering' the world, strategies which are now more broadly applied by other companies in various industries. And their strategies are worth analyzing. In Russia for instance, the