Inherit The Wind "Give Me That Old Movie Review

PAGES
3
WORDS
1108
Cite

¶ … Inherit the Wind "Give me that old time religion," proclaims the first strains of the soundtrack of "Inherit the Wind," a 1960 Hollywood dramatization of a Broadway play of the same name. Yet the film "Inherit the Wind" is not about the revivalist tent revival meeting that opens up and sets the scene of the film's narrative framework. Rather "Inherit the Wind" is primarily a courtroom drama that pits faith against reason in the form of two esteemed lawyers. The film's plot thus revolves around the John Scopes 'Monkey' trial and the issues the trial raised about science, faith, and religion in the American educational system. This real-life event took place in the Bible Belt of America during the turn of the century.

A biology teacher named John Scopes at a local high school in the small town of Hillsborough had the audacity to teach evolution to his high school class, and was thrown into jail as a result. Thus, the main topic of the film asks the viewer the teacher was right to violate the statute of his locality. One way to view this issue, as suggested by the film, is that parents have a right to have some local control over what their children learn in their local schools -- the ordinary people of Hillsborough have a right to be ordinary, and to teach their children about religion as they chose, as guaranteed by the First Amendment's protection of such a freedom. However, the defense attorney portrayed by Spencer Tracey, Drummond, sees such local ordinances as violating both the teacher Scopes' own freedom of expression and also the ability of human intellectual progress to penetrate the consciousness of the...

...

No American town can live in the past, Drummond believes.
Ironically, although the town defends its right to set local standards, it ferries in a well-known progressive but religious attorney, named Brady, to lead the prosecution of the teacher John Scopes. The noted politician and former Democratic Progressive Presidential contender says that he fears the moral impact that teaching evolution to impressionable minds will have upon the youth of America. The plot film begins with the first days of the trial, and the publicity the Scopes trial has drawn for 'Heavenly Hillsborough, the buckle of the Bible Belt.' Thus, ass well as dramatizing the subject of evolution, the film also shows the ability of a small town to capitalize upon media attention within its district, to draw money and tourism to the tiny municipality. Some parents may cry out that they wish to protect their children from the larger world, but everyone seems to want publicity and money, and not to be sheltered from national celebrity.

Suddenly, all of Hillsborough is agog at receiving such eminent guests as Drummond and Brady, and does its best to solicit the attentions of the media, embodied by the cynical Northern reporter played by Gene Kelley. Most of the media and even some of the ostensibly religious townsfolk do not seem to care very much whether the teacher is thrown in jail or fined for attempting to exercise his freedom of speech and bring the minds of young people into a more questioning engagement with their faith and with the nature of modern science. They are merely excited by the prospect of money, scandal, publicity, and above…

Sources Used in Documents:

Conclusion -- What does the film teach?

The film ends with a reflective note, not so much pondering the expansion of human knowledge, but the limits of human knowledge, even in light of new knowledge about human evolution. Although the teacher loses, Brady ends the film a broken man, sorrowful about his evident inability to really 'show up' Drummond in the latter's examination of his beliefs. According to Lewis L. Gould's text America in the Progressive Era 1890-1914, the 'real' prosecuting attorney in the Scopes Trial was a model for Brady, and similarly ended his life a broken man, a failed presidential candidate whose attempts to rebuild his reputation as an advocate for America's heartland met with a dismal failure.

Thus, the film certainly serves its ostensible purpose not merely to entertain but to increase the audience's knowledge of the American experience during the Progressive Era. The film shows the widening chasm between the sophisticated East, embodied by the reporters, and America's religious and faith-based heartland -- denied the urban economic opportunities and success of the cities, faith becomes the main crutch of the participant's existence, as well as a healthy American desires to capitalize upon celebrity. The film also gives the viewer a greater and more complex appreciation the political, economic, social, and cultural heritage of the United States. It reminds the viewing audience that America is both a secular nation in its laws and is based upon the adversarial debate of the trial system, yet America also an intensely populist nation in its common culture and public dialogue, with a vibrantly religious people. The major forces shaping the contemporary world within the dueling historical perspectives of religion and science, between different American regional cultural orientations in regards to religion, and a growing awareness of the early history of celebrity and the popular press' role in framing emotional and scientific debates are all present in the film version of "Inherit the Wind." The film both reflects upon and evaluates the human experience of two lawyers coming to the end of their careers, as well as how the issue of evolution in school was just beginning, like the summer of Hillsborough itself, to heat up and burst into tears, sweat, and flames in the American consciousness.


Cite this Document:

"Inherit The Wind Give Me That Old" (2005, June 24) Retrieved April 26, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/inherit-the-wind-give-me-that-old-65275

"Inherit The Wind Give Me That Old" 24 June 2005. Web.26 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/inherit-the-wind-give-me-that-old-65275>

"Inherit The Wind Give Me That Old", 24 June 2005, Accessed.26 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/inherit-the-wind-give-me-that-old-65275

Related Documents
Messiah in Old Testament the
PAGES 25 WORDS 7201

In Genesis 3:15, God said, "I will put enmity between you and the woman, and between your offspring and her offspring. He will bruise your head, and you will bruise his heel." According to some biblical experts, this is an oblique reference to the coming of Messiah. This is taken by many as one of the earliest Messianic prophecies describing Satan's brief victory over the Messiah and the Messiah's ultimate

Young Goodman Brown Nathaniel Hawthorne's "Young Goodman Brown" is a strange and unsettling story of a young man who travels through a wood overnight and allows his experience to change him forever. There are many themes in this short story, including the age-old theme of good and evil, but a close reading of the work can make the reader thing Brown's journey is a symbolic acting out of his own sinful

Apparently Plath wrote the poem during her stay in the hospital, which can be a depressing place notwithstanding all the nurses and orderlies dressed in white. The appendectomy followed a miscarriage that Plath had suffered through, so given those realities in the poet's life -- especially for a woman to lose a child she had been carrying -- one can identify with the bleak nature of the poem. Confronted

Isaiah 57 Can Be Divided
PAGES 10 WORDS 3043

In verse 13, God directly challenges the false Gods to save the Israelites. God tells them that their idols will do them no good and that he can and will destroy them. God also reiterates his promise to the righteous that he will keep them safe and the land will be theirs. This verse demonstrates God's ultimate authority and superiority over the old pagan gods. It proclaims his undisputed position

Good Man is Hard to Find by Flannery O'Connor. Specifically, it will focus on the use of comedy/humor, foreshadowing, and irony in the work. Flannery O'Connor is one of the South's most well-known writers, and nearly all of her works, including this short story, take place in Southern locales. Her work embodies the Southern lifestyle, which includes close family ties, attention to family roots, and a more laid-back and

Multi Ethnic Literature
PAGES 12 WORDS 3326

Multi-Ethnic Literature The focus of this work is to examine multi-ethnic literature and focus on treating humans like farm animals that can be manipulated for various purposes. Multi-Ethnic literature offers a glimpse into the lives of the various writers of this literature and into the lives of various ethnic groups and the way that they view life and society and their experiences. Examined in this study are various writers including Tupac