Inmate Rights In Other Countries Thesis

Length: 7 pages Sources: 12 Subject: Criminal Justice Type: Thesis Paper: #27442433 Related Topics: Prisoners Rights, Other, Another Country, Juvenile Detention
Excerpt from Thesis :

In fact, while Great Britain is liberal in many areas, prison rights does not seem to be one of them. Prisoners commonly appeal conditions to the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), which has a much more liberal stance on human and inmate rights than those of Great Britain. For example, "On its 2005 visit to UK prisons, the European Committee for the Prevention of Torture (CPT), was highly critical of the observed lack of time out of cells, the sharing of cells, the very small size of cells, and the lack of exercise and activity" (Eady, 2007, p. 272). Thus, prisons in Great Britain have not progressed nearly as much as many wish they had in the area of human rights. Another writer puts it more succinctly. She writes, "Although England has a clearly identifiable prisoners' rights lobby, the political impetus towards legislative reform remains conspicuously absent (Lazarus, 2006, p. 767). Thus, many European countries are far more advanced than Great Britain and the United States when it comes to prisoner rights.

Germany

German prisons have come a long way in only a short amount of time. Just a few decades ago, German prisoners enjoyed few prisoners' rights. Another writer notes, "At the time, prisoners were not seen as full bearers of basic rights, and no primary or secondary legislation determined their legal status" (Lazarus, 2006, p. 747). Legislation since then guarantees German prisoners basic rights, but terms and conditions are still harsher in Germany than in many other European states. However, Germany does have sound laws that regulate these rights, in contrast with England.

South Africa

In South Africa, several groups have become increasingly concerned about the "erosion" of prisoners' rights in the country, and several groups have formed to address this issue. Legislation had been passed in 1998 in an attempt to oversee and define prisoners' rights in the country, but it was largely unimplemented. One issue is overcrowding, as an author notes, "On average, South African prisons are 68% over capacity, although there are individual prisons that are close to 300% over capacity" (Muntingh, 2004). This overcrowding clearly leads to prisoner rights issues, and has been the source of human rights concerns in the country. In 2004, the South African Constitutional Court gave all South African prisoners the right to vote in the country's elections, and in that, they are far ahead of the United States, where incarcerated inmates cannot vote, and in some states, even convicted felons who are out of jail cannot vote. Voting is one of the basic rights a democracy provides, and taking away voting rights is certainly an issue for prisoner rights groups in this country.

In conclusion, prisoners' rights are a very volatile issue around the world. Some countries offer few rights to their incarcerated, while others attempt to maintain a high standard of human rights even in their prisons. America seems to attempt to meet human rights organizations definitions of inmate rights, but cases indicate that...

...

It costs the taxpayers money in the courts and in successful lawsuits, but it also indicates that the country is not as concerned about some areas of human rights as many democracies tend to be. Prisons were created to help isolate criminals from society, but they were also created to help reeducate and rehabilitate prisoners so they could live meaningful, crime-free lives. Ignoring prisoners' rights is a negative influence on inmates and their rehabilitation, and more attention to prisoners' rights could lead ultimately to less need for recidivism and crime in this country.

References

Beck, a.J., Harrison, P.M., & Hughes, T.A. (2004, July). Implementing the 2003 prison rape elimination act in juvenile residential facilities. Corrections Today, 66, 26+.

Budzenski, S. (2006). Tug of war: The Supreme Court, Congress, and the circuits -- the Fifth Circuit's input on the struggle to define a prisoner's right to religious freedom in Adkins v. Kaspar. St. John's Law Review; Vol. 80 Issue 4, 1335-1360.

Carlton, B. (2006). Review of intractable: Hell has a name, life inside Australia's first super-max prison. Social Justice, 33(4), 191+.

Chin, a. (2003). Increasing the accountability of state actors in prison systems - a necessary enterprise in guaranteeing the Eighth Amendment rights of prison inmates. Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology, 93(4), 913+.

Collins, W.C. (2007) Jails and the Constitution: An overview. Second Edition. Retrieved 18 Sept. 2008 from the U.S. Department of Justice: National Institute of Corrections Web site: http://nicic.org/Downloads/PDF/Library/022570.pdf.1-104.

Eady, D. (2007). Prisoners' rights since the Woolf Report: Progress or procrastination? Howard Journal of Criminal Justice; Vol. 46 Issue 3, 264-275.

Editors. (2001). No escape: Male rape in U.S. Prisons. Retrieved 18 Sept. 2008 from the Human Rights Watch Web site: http://www.hrw.org/reports/2001/prison/report.html#_1_2.

Guidice, R. (2002). Procreation and the prisoner: Does the right to procreate survive incarceration and do legitimate penological interests justify restrictions on the exercise of the right. Fordham Urban Law Journal, 29(6), 2277+.

Kautzer, C. And Mendieta, E. (2004). Law and resistance in the prisons of empire: An interview with Angela Y. Davis. Peace Review; Vol. 16 Issue 3, 339-347.

Lazarus, L. (2006). Conceptions of liberty deprivation. Modern Law Review; Vol. 69 Issue 5, 738-769.

Mendoza, L. (2003).…

Sources Used in Documents:

References

Beck, a.J., Harrison, P.M., & Hughes, T.A. (2004, July). Implementing the 2003 prison rape elimination act in juvenile residential facilities. Corrections Today, 66, 26+.

Budzenski, S. (2006). Tug of war: The Supreme Court, Congress, and the circuits -- the Fifth Circuit's input on the struggle to define a prisoner's right to religious freedom in Adkins v. Kaspar. St. John's Law Review; Vol. 80 Issue 4, 1335-1360.

Carlton, B. (2006). Review of intractable: Hell has a name, life inside Australia's first super-max prison. Social Justice, 33(4), 191+.

Chin, a. (2003). Increasing the accountability of state actors in prison systems - a necessary enterprise in guaranteeing the Eighth Amendment rights of prison inmates. Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology, 93(4), 913+.


Cite this Document:

"Inmate Rights In Other Countries" (2008, September 18) Retrieved October 23, 2021, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/inmate-rights-in-other-countries-28080

"Inmate Rights In Other Countries" 18 September 2008. Web.23 October. 2021. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/inmate-rights-in-other-countries-28080>

"Inmate Rights In Other Countries", 18 September 2008, Accessed.23 October. 2021,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/inmate-rights-in-other-countries-28080

Related Documents
Right to Counsel and the Death Penalty in Michigan
Words: 4461 Length: 15 Pages Topic: Criminal Justice Paper #: 13682228

Death Penalty in Michigan There are, at present, 38 states with the death penalty and 12 without (deathpenaltyinfo.org 2004). Michigan is one of the 12. From 1976, there have been 906 executions in the U.S.: 517 were white, 310 blacks; 57 hispanic; and 22, other races. More than 80% of these cases involved white victims, although only 50% of murder victims were white. Case studies on race showed that 96% had

Human Rights and Child Prostitution in Haiti
Words: 6002 Length: 20 Pages Topic: Government Paper #: 23312990

Human Rights and Child Prostitution in Haiti The Republic of Haiti is a Caribbean country occupying smaller portion of Hispaniola Island. It shares the island with Dominican which is equally another Caribbean country with population of just over 600, 000. In 2011, the population of the Republic of Haiti hit 9 million-mark with chances of a tremendous growth projected in the subsequent years. With the capital located at Port-au-Prince, the country's

Prisoners Do Have Some Rights, It Is
Words: 621 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Criminal Justice Paper #: 60493154

prisoners do have some rights, it is worth noting that their rights are extremely circumscribed, particularly when contrasted with that of the average citizen who is not incarcerated. The most salient right that prisoners have is afforded by the Eighth Amendment of the United States Constitution, which strictly forbids cruel and unusual punishment (Dolovich, 2009, p. 881). As such, prisoners are entitled to a minimum standard of living. However,

What Rights Prisoners Should Have
Words: 1505 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Criminal Justice Paper #: 89038397

Rights Should Prisoners Have? Discussions of human rights frequently focus on the rights that people should have in a free society. They look at the types of rights that free people should be able to exercise without interference from their government. However, not all discussions of human rights focus on the rights of the free. Instead, some discussions look at the rights that duly convicted criminals should have. Some scholars

Criminal Justice System in Two Countries
Words: 4897 Length: 12 Pages Topic: Criminal Justice Paper #: 49687414

Criminal Justice System Ever since gaining independence status, both Mozambique and Zimbabwe have come under the scanner for violation of human rights incidences and extrajudicial excesses. The under trials, often arrested without formal sanctions have been continually processed through undemocratic norms and subjected to undue treatment when in confinement and under the control of policing authorities in spite of the fact that statutory provisions in the constitution provide assured guarantee

Prison Inmates Jail or Imprisonment
Words: 1424 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Criminal Justice Paper #: 60614335

In the United States alone, sexual attacks in prison are considered rape when penetration occurs. It is estimated that inmates are approached with unwanted sexual advances over 80,000 times per day (Anderson, 2001). Other more shocking statistics are (Anderson, 2001): There is an estimated 300,000++ instances of prison rape a year. Among this, 196,000 are estimated to happen to men in prison while 123,000 are estimated to happen to men in