Insurance Policies The Tragic Circumstances Term Paper

Length: 8 pages Sources: 6 Subject: Business - Law Type: Term Paper Paper: #88452607 Related Topics: Hurricane Katrina, Louisiana Purchase, Tort Law, Commercial Law
Excerpt from Term Paper :

However, as Schwarcz notes, the reasonable expectations doctrine fails in practical use for several reasons. Whie th doctrine may have widespread support from insurance law commentators, "Only a handful of state courts follow the rule, and the case law endorsing it is confused and inconsistent. Moreover, contract law scholars have largely debunked the contracts-of-adhesion argument on which the reasonable expectations doctrine was originally justified. They have established that neither consumer assent nor government regulation is necessary to lead firms to design efficient standard forms when market forces work sufficiently well" (Schwarcz para. 5). Because the doctrine has a record of stunted evolution in the courts and because there has been an academic undermining of its core rationale, many view it to be both antiquated and largely irrelevant. Still, the reasonable expectations doctrine has served as the primary theoretical and doctrinal construct for the judicial regulation of insurance over the past forty years, so the demise of the reasonable expectations doctrine has corresponded with the demise of judicial intervention in the content of insurance policies, a move which satisfies only insurance companies.

Schwarcz thus proposes that limited judicial regulation might be in the best interests of insurance consumers and that using product liability as the underlying doctrine may produce better results. Products liability law first clarifies the normative case for why courts should occasionally deviate from insurance policy terms, and it also provides a practical and theoretically sound doctrinal structure for implementing this principle. As Schwarcz notes, products liability law first suggests that informing consumers about product information is not as easy as the reasonable expectations doctrine supposes:

Because consumers can only digest a limited amount of information, requiring firms to perfect consumer information is not sensible. Instead, products liability law requires firms to inform consumers about particularly important safety risks and to provide instructions in an easy-to-read and obviously visible manner. (Schwarcz para. 7)

One major element in the development of insurance policy has been the campaign waged by the insurance industry to keep the courts from making insurance policy or for keeping judges adhering to pro-business policies.

The industry has spent millions on a massive public-relations campaign against "runaway jury awards" and "greedy trial lawyers" as a way of pressuring states to restrict citizens' rights to sue:

In California, insurance companies...


Similar campaigns are under way in states like West Virginia, where such laws are still on the books. Meanwhile, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce plans to fork over $40 million this year in lobbying for federal restrictions on citizens' legal remedies. Much of that money comes from insurance companies. (Mencimer 60)

As Mencimer notes, lawsuits and the threat of high damage awards "are often the only recourse consumers have, not only to learn about insurance companies' business practices but also to prevent insurance companies from abusing them with abandon" (Mencimer 61).

The various federal and state laws are both confusing and contradictory and largely shaped for the benefit of the insurance companies. Strict contract law is often the base for insurance law, which is why the exact language of policies is scrutinized so closely and why what is in the contract counts for more than what insureds may be told or how the companies may manipulate the consumer to sell policies on the one hand and to avoid paying claims on the other.

Works Cited

Chu, Kathy. "State Farm Agrees to Pay Up for Katrina in Mississippi." USA Today (23 Jan 2007). August 11, 2007.

Hartwig, Robert P. "Hurricane Katrina Insurance Issues: Robert P. Hartwig." Congressional Testimony (28 Feb 2007). August 10, 2007.

Homeowners Drop Insurance After Katrina." Associated Press/AP Online (19 March 2007). August 10, 2007.

Hurricane Katrina Victims Denied Insurance Claims." Insurance Related News (08 March 2007). August 11, 2007.

Judge Blocks Katrina Insurance Settlement." On Deadline (26 Jan 2007). August 11, 2007.

Kunzelman, Michael. "Groundbreaking Trial Could Help Decide Katrina Insurance Claims." (11 July 2006). August 9, 2007.

Lee, Anita. "Sisters Sue Insurance Companies, Claim Fraud." The Sun Herald. August 10, 2007.

Mencimer, Stephanie.:Insurance Impunity."

The American Prospect, Volume 14, Issue 7 (July-August 2003),. 60-61.

Schwarcz, Daniel. "A Products Liability Theory for the Judicial Regulation of Insurance Policies."

William and Mary Law Review, Volume 48, Issue 4 (2007). August 9, 2007.

Why Are Hurricane Claims Being Denied?" Resource 4 (2005). August 11, 2007.

Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited

Chu, Kathy. "State Farm Agrees to Pay Up for Katrina in Mississippi." USA Today (23 Jan 2007). August 11, 2007.

Hartwig, Robert P. "Hurricane Katrina Insurance Issues: Robert P. Hartwig." Congressional Testimony (28 Feb 2007). August 10, 2007.

Homeowners Drop Insurance After Katrina." Associated Press/AP Online (19 March 2007). August 10, 2007.

Hurricane Katrina Victims Denied Insurance Claims." Insurance Related News (08 March 2007). August 11, 2007.

Cite this Document:

"Insurance Policies The Tragic Circumstances" (2007, August 11) Retrieved September 17, 2021, from

"Insurance Policies The Tragic Circumstances" 11 August 2007. Web.17 September. 2021. <>

"Insurance Policies The Tragic Circumstances", 11 August 2007, Accessed.17 September. 2021,

Purpose of

The documents we provide are to be used as a sample, template, outline, guideline in helping you write your own paper, not to be used for academic credit. All users must abide by our "Student Honor Code" or you will be restricted access to our website.

Related Documents
Health Insurance and How It Effects the Elderly
Words: 2024 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Healthcare Paper #: 93220883

Misconceptions and Confusion in Healthcare Coverage Among Elderly Populations A small podiatry practice in Northeastern Missouri becomes the scene of a tragedy which takes place in plain sight, as there is not a day that goes by where at least one or more patients will be charged for their office visit despite mistakenly believing they would be covered. Unanticipated medical costs can be devastating even for adults in their prime of

Enron Was the Seventh Largest
Words: 27112 Length: 98 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 47234018

Enron could engage in their derivative trading strategy with no fear of government intervention because derivative trading was specifically exempted from government regulation. Due in part to a ruling by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission's (CFTC) chairwoman, Wendy Graham, derivatives remained free of regulatory oversight. Ms. Graham, wife of Texas senator Phil Graham, made this ruling 5 weeks before resigning as chairwoman of the CFTC and joining the Enron Board

Economics Finance MBA Level
Words: 13568 Length: 50 Pages Topic: Economics Paper #: 39727750

Disrupting America's economic system is a fundamental objective of terrorists Even as the world continues to struggle with the terrible shock from the September 11 attacks in New York and Washington, one principle lesson has already become clear: disrupting our economic system is a fundamental objective of terrorists. Prior to September 11, our economic environment was certainly not immune to terror, in comparison to many other nations; we lived relatively terror-free. Now,

Death of a Salesman: Questions
Words: 965 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Family and Marriage Paper #: 72466894

Act 2. Discuss the scene between Willy and Ben, consider what advice Willy is asking of Ben, note Bens reply "let me think about it." What might miller be suggesting by it? What importance does this scene have in the play? What themes are evoked in it? Ben's relationship with his brother Willy throughout the play exemplifies Willy's longing for the success that never comes. Ben profits from diamond mines, while

Frivolous Lawsuits Hurt Our Country
Words: 3456 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Business - Law Paper #: 61916780

Frivolous Lawsuits The author of this report is charged with comparing and contrasting two example lawsuits that many people would deem frivolous. One of the cases relates to a man that apparently thought that the Winnebago motor homes could drive and steer themselves on par with the self-driven Google cars that are coming out just now in 2015. The other case pertains to a man that literally sued for $54 million

Suicide Marilyn Monroe, Ernest Hemingway, George Sanders,
Words: 2270 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Psychology Paper #: 5767147

Suicide Marilyn Monroe, Ernest Hemingway, George Sanders, and Virginia Woolf- what do all these people have in common? Death by suicide. Hard as it may be to swallow, the fact remains that these very famous people who were viewed as successful and had the world at their feet, took their own lives in a fit of depression, anger, melancholia and out of sheer hopelessness. But this phenomenon is not exclusive to