Auer (2005: 6) addresses Kalleberg's point in this regard with an assertion that the common assumption is that the twin factors of globalization and technological advance would fundamentally change the employment relationship and its expectation of longevity.
Auer's view is somewhat less gloomy than that of Kalleberg in terms of the possibility of flexible, non-standard jobs not only supplementing the more standard, full-time variety, but also becoming standard themselves. In addition to providing greater employee satisfaction, standard, long-term jobs also influence the desire of employees to begin families, which in turn has a significant impact upon the economy. Individuals with greater certainty regarding the future of their income tend to be better consumers of goods and services than those who do not have such certainty.
In investigating labor relations among different countries, Auer makes the distinction between countries that have stable job prospects, and those who generally do not. However, he also emphasizes that the variable elements of the labor market have been fluctuating with the rise of globalization. While globalization has therefore not only influenced the nature of work itself, elements such as gender, age and sector composition, where even long-term jobs have been opened to differentiation in terms of various minority groups (Auer 2005: 7).
In contrast to authors such as Kalleberg, Auer also cites research to indicate that long-term employment has generally increased rather than made way for short-term, uncertain employment. At the same time, part-time employment opportunities have increased, but not replaced long-term employment.
The author mentions elements such as the value employers attach to their long-term workers, along with the importance that employees attach to their union relationships in terms of encouraging the global trend to maintain longer-term working relationships. Although there is greater flexibility and differentiation in response to globalization, this is not to say that part-time and temporary work has replaced the longer-term relationships between employers and employees.
If Kalleberg's assertions are however to be taken into account, it is clear that companies enjoy a large amount of flexibility that was not previously the case. Companies can indeed expand and hire more workers with much greater ease than the case was in the past. On the other hand, it is also true that labor relations are indeed protected by the existence of unions and government requirements.
International Manifestations of Employment Relations
Dickens (2003: 5) also cites evidence to indicate that the part-time work paradigm across the world has increased, but indeed that this phenomenon has not seen a uniform increase in all countries. Indeed, this type of employment has declined in Denmark, while factors such as regulatory models, collective bargaining and social norms significantly influenced the development of this type of work in countries such as New Zealand and the Netherlands.
Ogura (2005: 9-10) also emphasizes that, in the Anglo-Saxon model, both full-time and part-time employment are very much a collective part of the current business paradigm. The voluntary, short-term employment contract is for example based upon a model in which there is a low degree of employment protection, creating a relatively mobile workforce. More long-term employment contracts include benefits such as health insurance, pension, and paid leave. In countries such as the United States, part-time employment is a fairly common phenomenon as compared with full-time employment.
Ogura however mentions that the European model tends to include a stronger paradigm of employment protection, which is subject to the law and collective labor agreements. Concomitantly, there is a low level of labor mobility. Working conditions are also generally determined by means of collective bargaining.
A very interesting view of globalization can be seen when comparing developing countries with more developed ones. Whereas developed countries such as the United States have made the most of the opportunities offered by globalization in terms of cheap, temporary labor and global expansion, developing countries such as Korea have regarded the phenomenon with suspicion. According to Lee and Lee (2003: 506),...
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now