Intrastrate Acquisition Of People's Natural Research Proposal

Length: 8 pages Sources: 10 Subject: Business - Law Type: Research Proposal Paper: #52966006 Related Topics: Mergers And Acquisitions, Antitrust, Natural Resource, Administrative Law
Excerpt from Research Proposal :

" (Schlossberg, 2004)

FERC analyzed while making a review of the electric utility mergers proposition, the transaction being proposed "likely effect" on (1) competition;

(2) rates; and (3) regulation. (Schlossberg, 2004)

There are stated to be "no antitrust exemptions for transactions subject to FERC review and such mergers are regularly reviewed by either the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) or the Division." (Schlossberg, 2004) The Securities and Exchange Commission had previously held jurisdiction for reviewing acquisitions of stock of electric utility companies however, the authority provided under the Public Utilities Holding Company Act of 1935 was repealed in 2005.


The work of Trujillo (2006) entitled: "State Action Antitrust Exemption Collides with Deregulation: Rehabilitating the Foreeseability Doctrine" states that a capitalist society that has policies which were established for the purpose of regulating "the promotion of competition in traditionally regulated industries such as the electrical market seems counterintuitive. Yet, it is a reality in the United States. In particular, traditionally rate-regulated industries, such as electricity, have been "deregulated." In this context, deregulation means opening up certain components of the industry to competition. However, regulatory mechanisms in place to prevent abuses of the competitive process are also driving this competition, resulting in a "regulated deregulation." (Trujillo, 2006)

Specifically industries that have been historically rate-regulated (electricity) "have been 'deregulated'. In this context, deregulation means opening up certain components of the industry to competition. However, regulatory mechanisms in place to prevent abuses of the competitive process are also driving this competition, resulting in a "regulated deregulation." (Trujillo, 2006)

The recent moves for deregulation of the electricity markets have emphasized that "free markets thrive where competitive structures in place do not suppress competition." (Trujillo, 2006) Before the passing of the Public Utilities Regulatory Policy Act (PURPA) in 1978 "electricity in the United States was provided by a vertically integrated firm, which provided transmission, distribution and


As a result, the electricity market has consisted of a structural design supporting regulatory entities that supervise and monitor the generation, transmission, and distribution of electricity to end-users. Market monitoring and intrusiveness on the part of state legislatures and regulatory agencies permeate such structures and, therefore, cannot sustain competition without additional policies intended to promote competition." (Trujillo, 2006) This only served to "re-regulate" a market that was already regulated. (Trujillo, 2006, paraphrased)

"Attempts by states to implement "pro-competition" policies without restructuring traditional regulatory paradigms have been problematic for courts." (Trujillo, 2006) Trujillo states that added to this is the tendency of courts in deferring "to agency rulings" which represents a shift in the "jurisdictional parameters" resulting in having "…empowered the state regulatory commissions." (Trujillo, 2006) Trujillo relates that antitrust law serves to "de-concentrate these industry structures and prevent price fixing where regulation cannot." (2006) Broad application of state action immunity is stated by Trujillo to have the power to "preserve old regulatory structures where regulated entities such as utilities would continue to dominate the electrical market, eliminating any possibilities of consumers benefiting from deregulatory measures promoting competition - lower prices and choices." (2006)


The objective of this work was to examine a recent merger and toward this end, this work examined the merger of Equitable Resources, Inc. And the Peoples Natural Gas Company, a subsidiary of Dominion Resources, Inc. And found that this merger was claimed by the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) to violate Section 5 of the Federal Trade Commission Act and Section 7 of the Clayton Act." (2007) The Court eventually ended the merger's implementation. This case related to State Action immunity and specifically as related to deregulation of already regulated industries such as utilities in that these companies may not legally merge under the guidelines of the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) in cases where their merging would effectively put an end to competition in the specific industry of the merger. This study found that broad application of this type of state action immunity would effectively serve to strengthen the already regulated structures and that the older entities within this system would continue to dominate the market as they have historically and traditionally done. There is conflict in various areas of governance and regulation in this area of the law.


Ewing, Saul (2007) FTC Complaint May Seek to Erode 'State Action' Immunity of Utilities. Staying…

Sources Used in Documents:


Ewing, Saul (2007) FTC Complaint May Seek to Erode 'State Action' Immunity of Utilities. Staying Ahead Bulletin April 2007. Utility Law. Online available at:

Schlossberg, Robert S. (2004) Mergers and Acquisitions: Understanding the Antitrust Issues. American Bar Association 2004. Google, Books Online available at:

Trujillo, Elizabeth (2006) State Action Antitrust Exemption Collides with Deregulation: Rehabilitating the foreseeability Doctrine. Fordham Journal of Corporate & Financial Law. Online available at:

Cite this Document:

"Intrastrate Acquisition Of People's Natural" (2009, April 18) Retrieved October 24, 2021, from

"Intrastrate Acquisition Of People's Natural" 18 April 2009. Web.24 October. 2021. <>

"Intrastrate Acquisition Of People's Natural", 18 April 2009, Accessed.24 October. 2021,

Related Documents
Deregulation Act of 1978 Before
Words: 1384 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Transportation Paper #: 73665032

They have, on average, a thirty-five to forty percent increase in the number of scheduled departures and hub-and-spoke operations have made an increased number of destinations available to them. Airlines have cut frills during our current economic downturn, but the success of no-frills, low-cost airlines such as Southwest Airlines which do not offer many traditional amenities indicates that a substantial proportion of passengers are more swayed by price than

Deregulation and Marketing Strategy
Words: 548 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Business - Advertising Paper #: 6988059

Marketing Strategies Changed Since Deregulation The objective of this study is to describe how marketing strategies have changed since deregulation. It is reported that over the past 25-year that the transportation system in the United States has undergone dramatic changes in both "size and form as it carried ever-increasing numbers of passengers and volumes of freight, both domestically and internationally." ( ) The demand for transportation services has been due to

Deregulation Under the Trump Administration and Its Impact on the...
Words: 2006 Length: 7 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 81227752

Deregulation under the Trump Administration and Its Impact on the Non-Profit Sector Introduction President Trump touted deregulation as one of the issues he would push for during his campaign leading up to the 2016 election. Once placed in the White House, he held true to his push for deregulation and that policy has had some impact on the non-profit sector in the US. This paper will show how that impact has benefited

Banking Deregulation
Words: 769 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Economics Paper #: 55513989

Deregulation The Glass-Steagall Act of 1933 was the first major attempt at regulating the financial industry. The Act was passed by President Roosevelt with the objective of restoring public confidence in the banking system. Glass-Steagall sought to, among other things "prevent the undue diversion of funds into speculative operations," in response to the market crashes that had sparked the Great Depression (Maues, 2013). The reason for this was simple -- speculation

Impacts on Commercial Airline Industry As Result of Deregulation
Words: 1227 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Transportation Paper #: 27784082

Airline Deregulation Impact on Commercial Airline Industry as a Result of Deregulation The airline industry in the United States began functioning almost as soon as the Wright brothers made their first flight at the Killdevil Hills in North Carolina. In 1903, mail began to be carried by airplanes over short routes, so the United States government created an agency to help regulate how this was accomplished to make it safe for carriers.

Role of Government Intervention: Regulation and Deregulation
Words: 1090 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Economics Paper #: 94185809

Regulation and Deregulation Prior to the 19th century, most people would have voiced their support for the "concept of laissez-faire, a doctrine opposing government interference in the economy, except in" the maintenance of law and order (U.S. Department of State, 2014). The turn of the 19th century, however, saw attitudes begin to change, and labor movements as well as small entrepreneurs asking the government to intervene, following the apparent failure of