Joyce Carol Oates, "I, The Term Paper

Length: 4 pages Sources: 3 Subject: Business - Law Type: Term Paper Paper: #38576463 Related Topics: Autobiographical, Atheist, Racial Discrimination, Trial Brief
Excerpt from Term Paper :

The system, the attorneys and the jury seem to be too biased in their assessment of the case, obviously swerving from the real purpose that any trial should have, that is, reaching justice. Racism which is inherently present even in modern, present-day society is even a part of the system of justice, as Oates observes. Instead of a fair outcome, the result of the trial is the huge confusion that accompanies the way in which the facts are presented for the jury and the public. Thus, Oates feels that playing the role of a jury member in a trial can be at most a very frustrating experience that can make one lose the faith in humanity and its values. Also, the author underlines the importance of the concept of justice and the way in which it loses meaning in the system. There is also a slight religious undertone attached to the main purpose of the essay. As an atheist, Oates does not touch the Bible when she has to take an oath a member of the jury, but the gesture has obviously a larger significance. The principle of justice according to the Christian religion is certainly not respected during the trial, and not even pursued by the ones involved in the process.

The conclusions that Oates draws from her experience as a juror are also very significant. She remarks thus that, in the absurdity of the system of justice the purpose, paradoxically, does not seem to be the establishment of justice in any way. When the whole of the proceedings in the trial seem to be biased and corrupted, it is very hard to decant the truth. Also, the fact that discrimination, as one of the most absurd and unjust attitudes can be found at all levels of the system, enhances the improbability of actually reaching a just verdict for a crime. As Oates sees it, justice is already a difficult objective to attain in the maze of the human affairs, but the biased and unrighteous system only makes the process more difficult.

Thus, Oates rounds the purpose she had established for herself in writing the essay, by questioning...


The jury itself, as Oates contends, should be judged in its turn by another jury, since the fairness of the process is doubtful.

The reaching of justness seems to be deferred continuously in this process, since the people involved do not act fairly and do not judge without prejudice and subjectivity, as they should.

Thus, in her autobiographical essay, Joyce Carol Oates gives an account of one of her experiences with the legal system in America, and emphasizes the corruption and the racism that permeate it. Her observations as a member of the jury clearly underlie the fact that, for the individual, the legal system can be destructive instead of beneficent. The racism and the other prejudices are serious flaws in the structure of the system of justice which is supposed to reestablish a state of balance and fairness and not to uproot any hope for justice. Oates' essay is clearly intended as a warning addressed to the public to militate against injustice and maybe to try to bring a change to the present state of affairs. The intention of the author is thus both to meditate on her own experience and to share her convictions with her readers. The sketch is thus not merely autobiographical or subjective, even though it treats of a personal experience of the author. Oates aims in fact at giving an interpretation of the way in which the legal system works in contemporary America, supporting it with very concrete detail from her own experience. From it all, the principle of justice emerges as a main point of Oates' discussion: her conclusion is that the concept of justice itself seems to have ironically disappeared, engulfed in the system. The purpose of the trial is thus lost during its process, as the ultimate decision is influenced by a number of factors and biases.

Works Cited

Friedman, Ellen G. "Invisible Writer: A Biography of Joyce Carol Oates." Studies in the Novel, Vol. 31, 1999.

Kloberdanz, Kristin. "Joyce Carol Oates." Book, May 2001.

Oates, Joyce Carol.


Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited

Friedman, Ellen G. "Invisible Writer: A Biography of Joyce Carol Oates." Studies in the Novel, Vol. 31, 1999.

Kloberdanz, Kristin. "Joyce Carol Oates." Book, May 2001.

Oates, Joyce Carol.


Cite this Document:

"Joyce Carol Oates I The" (2007, August 30) Retrieved December 1, 2021, from

"Joyce Carol Oates I The" 30 August 2007. Web.1 December. 2021. <>

"Joyce Carol Oates I The", 30 August 2007, Accessed.1 December. 2021,

Related Documents
Joyce Carol Oates: A Stylistic
Words: 1500 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Literature Paper #: 90183805

Although one could write a gritty, objective tale about either boxing or farm workers, and although Joyce could have interviewed either the authors she critiques or the boxers she chronicles, her concerns are now more of a metaphysical nature, and her prose reflects this -- Joyce is now less a writer in the field of contemporary journalist, than a cultural critic who considers her subjectivity a strength rather than

Joyce Carol Oates Sees "The Picture of
Words: 652 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Literature Paper #: 62673179

Joyce Carol Oates sees "The Picture of Dorian Gray" as a revelation as to another side of Wilde; one that questioned the aestheticism professed by Lord Henry and other characters in the novel. She claims that the book evokes Faust and the devil, as the portrait of Dorian Gray was surely evil and the aesthetic beauty of Dorian corrupted by demonic influence. In this light, A Picture of Dorian Gray is

Joyce Carol Oates and the Traits of
Words: 2672 Length: 6 Pages Topic: Literature Paper #: 96500688

Joyce Carol Oates and the Traits of the Mid-Twentieth Century Writer Just as society changes over time, writing changes over time. Writers today rarely write in the same forms as Shakespeare once did. As well as style, the subjects of writing change, with this expected since society has changed over time. For example, it is hardly likely that Shakespeare would have written about the issue of feminism. Even looking at writing

Joyce Carol Oates Story, Where Are You
Words: 544 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Literature Paper #: 52552379

Joyce Carol Oates story, Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been? The writer of this paper explores why society sometimes punishes those who are different using the story as an example. Society has always treated people who are differently with a less welcome attitude than those who are like everybody else. It has held true in almost every life setting from school classrooms, to work environments to social gatherings.

Worried About You, by Joyce Carol Oates.
Words: 348 Length: 1 Pages Topic: Family and Marriage Paper #: 5536695

Worried about You," by Joyce Carol Oates. Specifically, it will summarize the story, and the characters in the story. "We Were Worried about You" is a story of family, but it is also a story of what people ignore in their lives, and how it affects them. WE WERE WORRIED ABOUT YOU The characters in Oates short story are seemingly a normal and happy middle class family. They identify with their

Mulvaneys the Narrator of Joyce Carol Oates'
Words: 768 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Literature Paper #: 15168507

Mulvaneys The narrator of Joyce Carol Oates' novel We Were the Mulvaneys is youngest son Judd. In this particular passage from near the end of the novel, Judd Mulvaney is contemplating his life and the truth of human nature and human existence. In order to convey the importance of Judd's discovery, Oates utilizes certain literary devises which are intended to inform the reader and to manipulate how that reader sees