Just War Order ID: Iraq Essay

Length: 8 pages Sources: 5 Subject: American History Type: Essay Paper: #83616831 Related Topics: Pearl Harbor, Al Qaeda, Cold War, Pakistan
Excerpt from Essay :

First, the relative quiet produced by the surge permits the United States to withdraw its forces far more safely than if the country were in flames; if this opportunity is seized, the surge will have made an important contribution" (Zelleke & Dujarric 2008). The United States has ultimately striven to bring regional stability to Iraq and to Afghanistan, not to establish a permanent presence, and such stability is to be welcomed by all, particularly those who live in these nations who desire peace.

The means of a just war must be limited by proportionality to the offense.

The offense is a potentially future attack, "one we have good reason to believe is coming, then we can prevent it with what it takes to prevent it in proportion to how reasonably we can expect it and what means would be involved in such a potential attack" (Pierce 2005). Given the extent of the offense in 2001, the United States' response seems moderate -- had Iraq been attacked in a similar fashion, how would Saddam have responded, given his treatment of innocent Kurds and innocent civilians who opposed his own rule?

There should be no intentional and direct attack on noncombatants.

Firstly in both Iraq and Afghanistan, the United States never knowingly, deliberately targeted non-combatants. And while war always has unfortunate causalities, and yes "an invasion means that innocent civilians will die, without doubt," that is by itself not an argument (Pierce 2005). The question is always: what is the alternative: civilians were dying of hunger and disease and in Saddam's jails and suffering "life-long debilitating disfigurement, rape, humiliation, and simple day-to-day" misery and fear (Sjostrom 2009). Although regrettable incidents are inevitable in every war, including losses due to friendly fire, the amount of unproductive death, destruction, and oppression waged by Saddam is not comparable to the unfortunate effects of an invasion, brought upon by his own actions.

War should not be prolonged when there is no reasonable hope of success within these limits.

Even the most vociferous critics of both wars concede that there have been notable successes. Human rights have improved in Iraq -- the minority ethnic group of the Kurds no longer lives in fear of their lives. While Osama Bin Laden remains at large, prominent terrorists from his group have been apprehended and brought to justice, and there have been no comparable attacks upon U.S. soil since 2001. Moreover, invading Iraq has been a way to "break out of the impasse of the dual containment of Iraq and Iran pursued by the Clinton administration. By establishing a pro-American government in Baghdad, the United States would gain leverage against Tehran" (Zelleke & Dujarric 2008).

Today, the United States must proceed undaunted, and will, especially in Afghanistan...

...

In fact, not only can few "doubt that Afghanistan was a just war," as "Al Qaeda had the run of the country under the hyper-religious Taliban, but "from what we know from hastily abandoned Al Qaeda documents and computers," evidence suggests that before the United States invaded, "Afghanistan had become even more of a dangerous haven for international terrorism than we had thought" (Greenway 2005).

The even better news about Afghanistan today is that not only do the American public continue to support this war, because of the searing memory of 9/11, war in Afghanistan continues to enjoy wide international support. Given the poor conditions for the average individual in Afghanistan, the effects, sad to say, of war, may even improve circumstances there: "according to a United Nations report, Afghan living standards are the sixth worst in the world, ahead of only five basket cases in sub-Saharan Africa. Almost every statistic is bad. Average life expectancy is 44.5 years compared with 60.8 in neighboring Pakistan and 70.1 in Iran. Gross domestic product per capita is $190 compared with $408 in Pakistan and $1,652 in Iran. Infant mortality is also higher than the toll in any of Afghanistan's neighbors, and the literacy rate is only 28.7%. One in four Afghans is unemployed. Corruption is rife. Discredited warlords remain in control of vast regions. The government's writ runs very thin outside of the capital, and a low-level insurgency grinds on. Perhaps most serious of all for Afghanistan's long-term prospects, the country is now the world's largest producer of opium" (Greenway 2005).

With improvements in living standards Afghanis have and will continue to welcome United States support. With improvements in living standards and human rights, Iraqis will likewise, as the U.S. strives to create a functional government that is friendly to ethnic minorities, Iraq's neighbors, and to the international community as well as the United States. In Afghanistan, "slowly the warlords are being co-opted by the central government and relinquishing power. Likewise, amnesty for Taliban fighters, if not for top leaders, is showing promise" (Greenway 2005). Going to war is never pleasant, and while the sacrifices Americans have had to make the world a more stable place in Afghanistan and Iraq may have been bitter, they were also, and continue to be necessary -- although these areas of the world may not be perfect, how much more imperfect they would be, had action never been taken.

Works Cited

Greenway, HDS. (2005, March 31). Afghanistan, the poor stepsister to Iraq. The Boston Globe.

Retrieved April 12, 2009 at http://www.boston.com/news/globe/editorial_opinion/oped/articles/2005/03/25/afghanistan_the_poor_stepsister_to_iraq/

Pierce, Jeremy. (2005). Just war theory and Iraq. Parablemania. Retrieved April 12, 2009 at http://parablemania.ektopos.com/archives/2005/12/just_war_theory_1.html

Principles of just war. (2009). Mt. Holyoke. Retrieved April 12, 2009 at http://www.mtholyoke.edu/acad/intrel/pol116/justwar.htm

Sjostrom, William. (2009). Ten reasons why America should invade Iraq

Atlantic Monthly. Blog archive. Retrieved April 12, 2009 at http://www.atlanticblog.com/archives/iraq.pdf

Zelleke, Andy & Robert Dujarric. (2008, July 31). The success of the surge. The Boston Globe.

Retrieved April 12, 2009 at http://www.boston.com/bostonglobe/editorial_opinion/oped/articles/2008/07/31/the_success_of_that_surge/

Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited

Greenway, HDS. (2005, March 31). Afghanistan, the poor stepsister to Iraq. The Boston Globe.

Retrieved April 12, 2009 at http://www.boston.com/news/globe/editorial_opinion/oped/articles/2005/03/25/afghanistan_the_poor_stepsister_to_iraq/

Pierce, Jeremy. (2005). Just war theory and Iraq. Parablemania. Retrieved April 12, 2009 at http://parablemania.ektopos.com/archives/2005/12/just_war_theory_1.html

Principles of just war. (2009). Mt. Holyoke. Retrieved April 12, 2009 at http://www.mtholyoke.edu/acad/intrel/pol116/justwar.htm


Cite this Document:

"Just War Order ID Iraq" (2009, April 12) Retrieved October 26, 2021, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/just-war-order-id-iraq-23036

"Just War Order ID Iraq" 12 April 2009. Web.26 October. 2021. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/just-war-order-id-iraq-23036>

"Just War Order ID Iraq", 12 April 2009, Accessed.26 October. 2021,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/just-war-order-id-iraq-23036

Related Documents
War in Afghanistan Following the
Words: 3674 Length: 13 Pages Topic: Terrorism Paper #: 30447159

Fallout A section of commentators have taken issue with the manner in which the federal government denied suspected terrorist the due process of law as stipulated under the constitution. The government even commissioned the establishment of a torture chamber in Guantanamo Bay. This amounts to gross violation of human rights and civil liberties. There is another clause in the patriot act dubbed "enhanced surveillance procedures," which allows federal authorities to gather

War in Iraq
Words: 2058 Length: 7 Pages Topic: Military Paper #: 73827712

Iraq War- Why America Should Have Never Gone to War With human rights violation reaching its peak in Iraq and with pictures of Iraqi prisoners proving that U.S. soldiers are committing worst possible war crimes, every American is facing a dilemma: should we support the government or should we not. Everyone is asking the same question, what is America's point for continuing war in Iraq? Does America need to be in

War on Terrorism: Though It
Words: 2809 Length: 9 Pages Topic: Terrorism Paper #: 18337894

Diplomacy: The establishing of healthy diplomatic relationships with other nations is an important tool in guaranteeing a safer nation with peace. In efforts aimed at improving the diplomatic ties with some Middle East countries like Pakistan, the United States embarked on strategies of cooling hostilities with these countries. For a long period, some Middle East countries have been considered as nations which sponsor terrorism particularly against the United States. This notion

War, Violence, and the Nation
Words: 986 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Military Paper #: 7003750

It explains how an Iraq War Vet became a military consultant in Hollywood. It quotes a professor who says that as the war goes on, the stories of war will become the fabric of American culture and identity. For example, many popular television programs began to incorporate the Iraq War into their stories. These include the episodes from ER, Las Vegas, Extreme Makeover, comedy Arrested Development, and soap opera

War on Terrorism Vs. The Bill of
Words: 1448 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Terrorism Paper #: 16121609

War on Terrorism vs. The Bill of Rights Conveniently capitalizing on the fear of another terrorist attack, the United States Department of Defense and other branches of the federal government have erected a series of security measures since September 11. The most notable of these is the so-called USA PATRIOT Act (HR-3162), passed in October of 2001. The whopping acronym stands for "Uniting and Strengthening America by Providing Appropriate Tools Required

ID: 76142 Paper Type: Pages:
Words: 1141 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Mythology - Religion Paper #: 36212911

For example during the Iran-Iraq War, many Shiites died against other Shiites from Iran, but Saddam Hussein still treated the Shiite minority poorly. They were a politically oppressed group. Also, in other countries with a Shiite minority, there is a growing concern that Iran controls the loyalties of the groups. This helps to explain the recent outburst in Iraqi violence in which Shiites and Sunnis admit to the hatred and would refuse to even help