Knowledge Since The Colonial College Essay

Length: 10 pages Sources: 1 Subject: Teaching Type: Essay Paper: #61296774 Related Topics: In Vitro Fertilization, Invitro Fertilization, Adapted Physical Education, Technical Writing
Excerpt from Essay :

" (Downey, 2000, p.307) This aspect of the university, or that of the community is characterized by having less structure that the corporation or collegium of the university and is such that includes everyone as a member as everyone "belongs to and has equity in the university as a community." (Downey, 2000, p.307) This is a community characterized by disorder, ambiguity, and little in the way of definition. The university community is ever-growing and continuously changing and adapting to changes.

V. Synthesis and Evaluation of Three Critical Tensions by the Academic Leader

One critical aspect of the university is that of funding resources. As government funding either increases or decreases for the university so too does the requirements of how that funding will be allocated increase or decrease. As well, the university is forced in times of decreased funding to decrease such as:

(1) the number of employees;

(2) wage and benefits;

(3) the range and quality of university courses and programs. (Downey, 2000, p.308)

When government funding decreases the university is left seeking other sources for university funding. This often leaves the university in a quandary in that the corporate aspect of the university gains strength while at the same time it may necessarily weaken the collegium aspect of the university. In addition, the requirements of the university to become more answerable to the clients or students of the university increases along with an increase in fees and tuition for those attending the university.

Previous governmental requirements and regulations fall by the wayside as the consumer demand becomes more predominant in the university's operational concerns. This gives rise to a growing strength in the community aspect of the university as community stakeholders who are now the primary funding resource for the university have a better foothold on what decisions are made by the university. The university from this view is far more characteristic of a corporate entity that a collegiate academic institution. Downey (2000) notes that in the past the Canadian government has preferred regulatory enforcement rather than competitive accountability and it is noted that Robert Fulford stated as follows:

"Canadians love regulation. What rice is to the Japanese, what wine is to the French, regulation is to the Canadians. When any new phenomenon appears on the horizon, whether it is in vitro fertilization or super-conductivity, our first response is always the same: how do we regulate this sucker?" (Downey, 2000, p.308-09)

Government have a general tendency to place limitations on academic institutions through regulatory means and specifically regulation of "the sphere of decision-making" which is noted to have negatively effect boards of governors in that their function has become primarily ensuring that regulations are enforced through "compliance with increasingly more intrusive and detailed legislation." (Downey, 2000, p.309)

Another factor affecting the university and which has served to weaken the collegial self-determination is the growth of complaints that are "referred for resolution outside the university, to adjudicators, tribunals, human rights commissions, and the courts." (Downey, 2000, p.309) as funding for the university decreases the competing interests of administration, faculty, staff and students becomes more intense with each focusing on their own personal interests. This results in the various sectors of the community external to the university becoming more divided by factors that are gender-, political-, ethnic-, and group-specific. This effectively weakens the strength that the community aspect of the university gained due to weakening collegiate strength in times of decreased funding and ultimately gives more


Naturally this results in a great deal of ambiguity and the leadership of the university faces a great deal in the way of challenge not only in securing funding for the university but in delicately balancing the powers that affect the administration of the university. Downey (2000) states that it is critically important to understand that "none of these three modalities of the university is its essence. It is almost as important to understand that each carries within it the elements of that essence, elements without which the university is in some respect deficient." (p. 309) Historically, all of these elements have never been perfectly balanced however the precarious imbalance of these three elements has never been more pronounced as the "spirit of the times is corporate, not communal, and certainly not collegial." (Downey, 2000, p. 31) the corporate concern is focused on "production of wealth and exercise of power" while communal and collegial are "about the sharing of wealth and power." (Downey, 2000, p.310)

Recently elected governments are characterized by "unambiguous mandates" and have provided the public with an assurance that they will somehow bring about a balance. The truth is that universities are going to be involved in corporate restructuring initiatives which is not a completely negative pursuit for the university if the recognition that there is a potential for tendencies on the collegial and community aspect of the university to become distorted in this process. As well, it is held by some that the faculty has been controlled through the collegium in a manner that has resulted in "abuses, in the neglect of teaching, the pursuit of irrelevant research and scholarship, using tenure to protect the incompetent, and a general failure to make honest and rigorous judgment about each other's work." (Downey, 2000, p.310)

Downey (2000) holds that there are three essential ingredients and states them to include the following:

(1) responsiveness to the economic and social stresses and challenges facing society, the people, organizations and institutions that comprise the university;

(2) a deeper sense of community, which is to say, a stronger sense of academic citizenship and a greater willingness to participate in and contribute to the vita communitatis; and (3) a fresh infusion of idealism, a renewed affirmation of faith in the central, civilizing purpose of the university. (Downey, 2000, p.310-11)

Summary and Conclusion

This work in writing has examined the three aspects of the academic institution of higher education or that of the college university for the purpose of disseminating what direction the academic leadership should take to ensure that the three aspects of the collegium, community and corporate are in the best possible balance with one another since this is vital to the university's survival. As noted in the work of Downey (2000) the ideal of the university appears to have be effectively lost along the way to the rise of the corporate university entity first tossed aside by collegial abuses and the failure for assessment of collegial actors so as to eliminate incompetent faculty and staff.

What is needed is a fresh outlook not only from the collegial viewpoint but as well from the viewpoint of the community and corporate university sector. Changes are inevitable and to avoid change is to avoid progress. The university leadership that will be the most competent and effective is leadership that leads the way through change and who realizes that change is not always negative and many times is the…

Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited

Downey, James. The University as a Trinity: Balancing Corporation, Collegium and Community. Reprinted from Innovative Higher Education, Winter 1996, Human Sciences Press.

Cite this Document:

"Knowledge Since The Colonial College" (2010, August 10) Retrieved May 19, 2022, from

"Knowledge Since The Colonial College" 10 August 2010. Web.19 May. 2022. <>

"Knowledge Since The Colonial College", 10 August 2010, Accessed.19 May. 2022,

Related Documents
Colonial Lit There Are Three
Words: 578 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 70976394

When establishing criteria for curriculum development the three domains should be used in such a manner as to make it a simple matter for students to understand what is expected. In a recent study the researchers discovered that it was "necessary to separate operationally the effects of tension in the cognitive and the affective domains,,because students reacted most productively not to the degree of difficulty and expectation in the course,,but

University Idea the University Is
Words: 2812 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 95210860

And it is to this end that the university is so distinct in the way that it provides a community which is most hospitable to intellectual and emotional growth. Difficulty of Harmonization: Downey (2000) points to a modern vagary of our persistent state of global recession in making the case that it is difficult to find harmony between the stated goals of his trinity. Indeed, though this reflects a certain ideal

Colonial Times for Third Grade
Words: 2318 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Psychology Paper #: 98087593

Additionally, she found that interdisciplinary units proved monumentally successful in helping teach children; for an inclusive colonial times unit, the children could learn about colonial daily life through completion of temporal everyday chores, cooking meals of the day, and involving themselves in the day-to-day activities that affected colonial children. Additionally, through their own student projects, the children might learn to "initiate and manage complex projects" when they are creating student

Colin Legum Africa Since Independence
Words: 971 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Literature - African Paper #: 14322621

Africa Since Independence" Review Africa, as a continent, went through an extended colonial period. Although the entire continent was not involved, the greatest part of the nation was and many achieved independence from other nations in a relatively short span after world War II. Legum says that at the end of the War only five nations had achieved independence (though one, South Africa, was still under a form of dominance)

Economy of Colonial America
Words: 660 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Literature Paper #: 3746668

Colonial Merchants and the American Revolution: 1763 to1776 by Arthur M. Schlesinger. (New York: Facsimile Library, Inc., 1939), 647, (381.0973). This book covers a part of history that is often forgotten - the economic history of the U.S. As it headed into the Revolutionary War. While most people know part of the reason Americans wanted to break from England was outrageous tariffs on imports and exports, the merchants who dealt

American Colonialism Opportunity in Colonial
Words: 1853 Length: 6 Pages Topic: Mythology - Religion Paper #: 54310205

William Penn, a Quaker whose father had been an Admiral in the King's Royal Navy, was given a large piece of land as payment for a debt owed by the Crown to his father. Penn had suggested naming the new territory Sylvania, meaning wood, but the King added his surname, Penn, as a tribute to William's father (Uden). Penn considered his venture a "Holy Experiment" and sought to establish