Verified Document

Labor And Union Studies Essay

¶ … Conflict, Debate or Struggle in the Contemporary U.S. Labor Movement The work of Rutkowski and Dirkin (2010) reports that a kosher food company in Williamsburg is "locked in a battle with former workers who charge they were stiffed out of overtime pay - and then fired when they complained." The investigators for the National Labor Relations Board is stated to have found that Flaum Appetizing Corporation "illegally booted the workers, and ordered the company to cough up around $260,000 in back pay." (Rutkowski and Dirkin, 2010) However, owner of the company, Moshe Grunhut is stated to have "refused to comply -- saying he won't' pay the workers because they're undocumented immigrants." (Rutkowski and Dirkin, 2010)

Methodology

The methodology employed in this study is one of a qualitative nature that has involved a review of the literature in regards to case of failure to pay overtime on the part of Flaum Appetizing Corporation. Literature that has been reviewed includes interview and report statements made by the previous employers of the Flaum Appetizing Corporation as well as other parties that possess information that is relevant to this particular study.

III. Interviews

According to one report, the employees who were fired state that they worked as much as "80 hours a week for minimum wage with no overtime…" (Parks, 2010) One interviewed employee states as follows:

"I worked 11 years for that company and I never received a dollar of overtime or one holiday or one sick day, nothing," said Gustino Romero, 32, of Bushwick. "I worked from 7 in the morning until 10 or 11 at night. ... We always asked for [overtime], but they said no." (Parks, 2010)

Another employee who was interviewed is reported to have stated as follows:

"The manager called us cockroaches, tarantulas, all kinds of offensive names. The truth is we were unfairly exploited." (Maria Corona, 36, of Williamsburg, said frequent insults from her boss made the situation worse) (Parks, 2010)

It is reported that at the time the workers made an attempt to form and union and to go...

illegally." (Parks, 2010) According to Grunhut: "I treat my workers with respect and dignity." (Parks, 2010) Grunhut blames the unions for making the situation such an issue and has requested that the NLRB "…let him off the hook for the back pay, and the two sides are scheduled to appear before the board again Dec. 8." (Parks, 2010)
Efrem (2010) reports that "Juan Romero emigrated from Mexico in 2005 and worked at Flaum for three-and-a-half years before he was fired" and that Romero stated as follows:

"We were really worried being without work. We didn't have money, and we couldn't even pay the rent. I did receive support from the union to make it through, but… we were really desperate after we got fired," (Efrem, 2010)

Romero is reported to send a large amount of his pay back to his family at home and states that he is "…disturbed by the Jewish community's response to the plight of the discharged workers" (Efrem, 2010) specifically stating as follows:

"It's frustrating when I hear, 'All we care about is that we get our food, and we're not interested in anything else,' [The American legal system] should protect us more and not be in favor of the companies that are making money off of us. "I don't think this is about principles for Flaum. I think it's all about the money, and that's why I think we will prevail, because for us it's all about dignity, and in the fight between money and dignity, dignity wins." (Efrem, 2010)

IV. Actions Taken to Address the Problem

It is reported that the workers have held protests at kosher supermarkets that sell Flaum's pickles, as well as hummus and other products and have additionally gained the cooperation of an Orthodox Jewish group…

Sources used in this document:
References

Efrem, Maia (2010) Fired Workers Protest, Prepare for NLRB Hearing in Two-Year Union Fight. The Jewish Daily Forward. 4 Aug 2010. Retrieved from: http://www.forward.com/articles/129832/

Brandworkers Focus on the Food Chain Files Class Action Lawsuit Against Beverage Distributor. 1 February 2010. Brandworkers International. Retrieved from: http://www.brandworkers.org/en/news?page=1

Kosher Business Refuses to pay $250,000 in back wages to fired workers (2010) Workers of the World 27 Nov 2010. Retrieved from: http://www.iww.org/en/node/5278

Rutkowski, I and Durkin, E (2010) Kosher business refuses to pay $260,000 in back wages to fired workers. Daily News. 26 Nov, 2010. Retrieved from: http://www.nydailynews.com/ny_local/brooklyn/2010/11/26/2010-11-26_his_blood_sweat__tears_kosher_biz_refuses_to_pay_260g_in_back_wages
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Labor and Union Studies in Washington and Oregon State
Words: 3095 Length: 11 Document Type: Research Paper

Labor and Union Studies in Washington and Oregon States The United States labor movement has its roots in the complex trappings of the industrial revolution. Laborers were just starting to come to the United States from foreign countries because they had learned that there were many jobs available for even the most unskilled worker. People were also moving from rural areas in America to the cities in an attempt ti have

Labor Union & the American
Words: 1061 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Surveys have found that the public find business leaders to be more trustworthy than union leaders and many members of non-union families disapprove of unions. Other factors include the increased trend towards smaller sizes of new factories. Moreover, the American workforce has changed significantly in terms of composition, i.e. age, sex, education and race. Some cyclical phenomenon in the political, social and economic environment in the U.S. has also

Labor and Union Studies Define
Words: 4045 Length: 10 Document Type: Thesis

All of the employees on an airplane, for example, could form themselves into a vertical bargaining unit if they chose, the unit including stewards and stewardesses, as well as pilots. Similarly, in a school, teachers, janitors, and office staff could all form a vertical unit. In contrast a horizontal bargaining unit unites all those who perform similar work. The fact that the pilots at Spirit Airlines belong to a

Labor & Union Studies Discharge
Words: 1249 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

In refusing to bargain or negotiate with Mr. Bolton, attorney for Mr. Allen, the Postal Service was upholding its contract with the Union to consider the Union the sole bargaining agent for Mr. Allen and other rural mail carriers. The Union's claim that management discounted the information provided by Mr. Bolton because he was a non-bargaining agent is a gross misrepresentation of the occurrence; no real information was provided by

Labor and Union Studies Canadian
Words: 1618 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

In 2007, it established that about two thirds of Canadians concur that immigration has a very affirmative or rather affirmative influence on Canada. Immigrants' view their choice to come to Canada as affirmative as well. While those coming into the country in 2000 were not pleased about their financial outcomes, the majority of the two thirds who stayed had a fairly affirmative feeling about their choice to come to

Labor Union Democracy
Words: 643 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Labor Democracy Labor Unions a are combination of seemingly contradictory elements. On the one hand, labor unions are conceived of like an army with soldiers of labor winning battles in conflict with management. On the other hand, the membership looks upon them much like the high school debate team where everyone on the team expresses themselves. The leadership of the union many times feels like elected colonial militia officers with dozens

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now