Leadership Style Approach: Business-Business Theory Essay

Length: 4 pages Sources: 1+ Subject: Leadership Type: Essay Paper: #91089076 Related Topics: Leadership Experience, Strain Theory, Decision Making Style, Independent Contractors
Excerpt from Essay :

¶ … Leadership Style Approach

GM502-xx (xx = section #)

Leadership Theories and Practice l

Drill Sergeant (Northouse, 2012)

Mark Young, a professional painter who previously worked as an independent contractor lands a job as the head of the painting department in a large health facility. He starts of as a task-oriented leader, geared towards goal attainment at the expense of the personal and work-related needs of his employees. With time, however, Mark relaxes his style of leadership, and begins to interact more with his subordinates - both at the professional level and personal level. He enjoys seeing his employees develop professionally, because such personal development drives the success of the department as a whole. In fact, he aids in such development by delegating some of his duties to subordinates. The department's performance has improved substantially since Mark took over, and a fair share of this improvement can rightly be attributed to his interactive style of leadership.

Based on the short passage above, I would describe Mark as a democratic leader. He exhibits a democratic style of leadership, where although he exercises control and has the final say, he readily invites the contribution, views and opinions of his subordinates; and through delegation, accords them ample opportunities to showcase their skill and creativity (Daft, 2014). In my view, the outings are meant to i) obtain first-hand information on what the employees want, how they want the department to be run, as well as their honest views and opinions about some key decisions affecting the department; and ii) to build and maintain a positive leader-follower relationship.

However, Mark does not start of as a democratic leader. His style of leadership evolves from an autocratic one, which is based on giving orders and never taking in the views and opinions of subordinates. He moves from being task-oriented to being people-oriented, where he uses people, as opposed to power, to drive success.

Generally, therefore, I would regard Mark a relationship-oriented leader, one who focuses on addressing the needs of his employees, both within the workplace and outside the workplace so as to build and maintain healthy interpersonal relationships. His strategy, in my view, is to create a satisfied and motivated workforce, and then use this positive attitude to drive success. He focuses on not only building positive relationships between himself and employees, but also between employees themselves, which is why he takes them for these interactive outside- the-workplace outings in groups. However, he also does not compromise performance for relationship maintenance. This is evident from the fact that the department's performance has been outstanding - 92% according to customer ratings. Towards this end, I would give him a score of (9, 9) -- a team manager who emphasizes the need to have strong interpersonal relationships, and at the same time, stresses the need for exceptional performance.

CASE 4.2: Eating Lunch Standing Up (Northouse, 2012)

Susan Parks is the manager of an equipment store dealing in running shoes and other sporting accessories. Her employees describe her as a no-nonsense manager focused on maintaining the organization's pattern of growth and positive reputation. Most of her employees think that she never has time to interact with them, leave alone listen to their concerns, views and opinions. Rumor has it that she rarely has time for herself, and often takes her lunch standing up. To most people, she is so driven by performance and a thirst to get the job done that she has no time to find out what her subordinates want, what they expect from their leader, or what their views are on key issues affecting the store. Susan's life is seen to revolve around getting the job done, addressing the needs of customers, and caring for her family -- her employees are not part of her to-do list, and most of them think that she is difficult to deal and relate with. All the same, some of her employees find her style of leadership admirable because it creates a feeling that she knows what she wants; and that thus, the store runs in a rather efficient and organized manner whenever she is in control.

The passage above portrays Susan as an autocratic, task-oriented leader who is focused on getting the job done through power and dictatorial tactics (Daft, 2014). She does not see the need to involve her subordinates in the decision-making process, and there is no evidence to suggest that she emphasizes the need for them to develop professionally. To her, employees...

...

She is the boss, and subordinates simply have to respect that by doing what she says and what she expects of them (Daft, 2014).

Well, this style of leadership has attracted profound reactions from her employees. This is because given the high level of competition in the marketplace, companies are increasingly using employee incentives and benefits, including a role in decision-making in a bid to appease and retain their employees. As long as other companies within the industry are being granted this kind of appreciation, Susan's employees are also deemed to expect the same of their leader.

In this regard, Susan needs to change her leadership styles if she is to retain her employees and evade the unnecessary costs of employee turnover, which would only put a negative strain on the very profits she has worked so hard to maintain. She ought to change her leadership style in line with the changing labor force trends, particularly because most of her employees are college students, who happen to be victims of peer pressure more than older adults are, who also expect more in terms of understanding from their employer, and who believe they have the qualification and theoretical knowhow to handle the job and do not need to be told what to do. Changing to a more embracing and more interactive leadership style would make her a more effective leader, and employees would feel satisfied with their jobs because they feel valued and appreciated (Daft, 2014).

Style Questionnaire

Assess Your Leadership Style

My leadership questionnaire yielded a task score of 43 and a relationship score of 38. I consider these results quite accurate - particularly given that most of my peers regard me as a 'workaholic with no social life'. All the same, this score implies that in a leadership position, I would focus more on getting the job done by having everyone play their respective part effectively and do exactly what is expected of them; and less on building positive interpersonal relationships and having positive attitudes and job satisfaction drive results. On Blake and Mouton's leadership grid, I would give myself a score of (5,5) -- a middle-of-the-road manager who places moderate emphasis on both results and people. However, I understand that moderate is mediocre given the high level of competition in the marketplace today, and I will, therefore, have to boost both my task, and relationship skills if I am to be an effective leader.

Recommendations

Alternate Courses of Action CASE 4.1

Democratic leadership, such as that exhibited by Mark has several advantages, which include building a strong work ethic, instilling a spirit of commonality and solidarity among employees and their leaders, bringing about good business fit, and encouraging innovation. However, it is not without its share of disadvantages, including time wastage in decision-making, and the risk of subordinates getting so close to the leader that they lose respect for him/her, or begin to compromise performance in the belief that the leader would overlook the same for the sake of maintaining the relationship. To prevent this, Mark needs to be able to clearly distinguish between those decisions that are urgent and perhaps cannot wait for consultations to be done, and the not-so-urgent ones that could be delayed until such consultations are done. Further, he needs to ensure that he establishes boundaries that employees are required to observe in the regular conduction of their duties. This way, organizational operations would run smoothly, and as long as employees feel that the leader has an incentive to include them in the decision-making process, they are likely to have no problem being excluded in case a decision is urgent. Moreover, as long as boundaries exist, and everyone is doing their job as expected, performance at the individual and the aggregate level is deemed to be maintained.

Alternate Courses of Action CASE 4.2

Susan needs to change from the current autocratic style of leadership to a more democratic, people-oriented style, failure to which she risks incurring the unnecessary costs associated with employee turnover and a damaged reputation. She needs to emphasize the importance of employee development by providing training facilities for professional development. Further, she needs to start interacting with her employees more, say through regular in-house forums, conferences or meetings at the store where employees can present their views or concerns and receive responses regarding the same. Joining subordinates for tea during breaks would go…

Sources Used in Documents:

References

Daft, R. (2014). The Leadership Experience (6th ed.). Stamford, CT: Cengage Learning

Northouse, P. (2012). Leadership Theory and Practice (6th ed.). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.


Cite this Document:

"Leadership Style Approach Business-Business Theory" (2014, November 25) Retrieved January 21, 2022, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/leadership-style-approach-business-business-2153134

"Leadership Style Approach Business-Business Theory" 25 November 2014. Web.21 January. 2022. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/leadership-style-approach-business-business-2153134>

"Leadership Style Approach Business-Business Theory", 25 November 2014, Accessed.21 January. 2022,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/leadership-style-approach-business-business-2153134

Related Documents
Leadership Behavioral Approach "Leadership Is the Lifting
Words: 1821 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Leadership Paper #: 59525585

Leadership Behavioral Approach "Leadership is the lifting of people's vision to a higher sight, the raising of their performance to a higher standard, and the building of their personality beyond its normal limitations" (Drucker, 1985). Ability to inspire others in a shared vision is one of the quality features of a leader. Leaders have cleared visions and communicate these visions to their subordinates to enhance corporate values. The objective of this essay

Leadership Business and Rhetoric Perception of Leadership Styles...
Words: 834 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Leadership Paper #: 61730111

Leadership, Business and Rhetoric (Perception of Leadership Styles and Trust across Cultures and Gender) I agree with most of the author's findings especially those that relate to gender, culture, trust and likelihood of voting influenced the outcome of the Democratic Party primaries in 2008. This was prominently displayed from the numerical display of predictable voting patterns in some states and these states had predominant cultures and races that made it possible

Leadership Styles in the 21st
Words: 2982 Length: 11 Pages Topic: Leadership Paper #: 35080326

It has been suggested further that the transformational leadership is a special type of transactional leadership because both leaderships are goal oriented. The difference comes from the way methods used to motivate people and the goal sets (Hater & Bass, 1988). Thus, one model is based on the leader's power to inspire followers and the other is based on the leader's creativity regarding the reward system. The goals are

Leadership Styles Among Male and Female Principal and How Teachers...
Words: 14019 Length: 50 Pages Topic: Leadership Paper #: 37659084

Leadership Styles Among Male and Female Principal It is the intention of this research to study the leadership and cognitive styles of teachers and instructors of both genders within the educational system and their preference for types of leadership in a principal of that institution. The research will include teachers and educators from all levels of the educational system from grade school to high school. The study will also include teachers and

Leadership Styles and Job Satisfaction
Words: 1689 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Leadership Paper #: 69800571

Hence, a more corporate attitude is being embraced by pro-vice-chancellors, but the salient question in this article is this: will a university be better off with corporate-style, bureaucratic leadership, or with leadership that pursues academic excellence and a pure mission of educating students? Wang, Yong, and Poutziouris, Panikkos. (2010). Leadership Styles, Management Systems and Growth: Empirical Evidence from UK Owner-Managed SMEs. Journal of Enterprising Culture, 18(3), 331-354. Doi: 10.1142/So21849581000604. What these authors

Leadership Styles: How to Be a Good Leader
Words: 2995 Length: 6 Pages Topic: Leadership Paper #: 15677157

Leadership Styles: How to Become an Effective Leader Power Perspective and Leader as Representatives Extrovert and Introvert Emotional Intelligence (EI) Competencies to Leadership Effectiveness Task-Oriented Leadership Satisfaction and Performance Four Dimensions of Leader-Member Exchange Authentic leadership and Servant Leadership Creating Social and Organizational Identity Goal Orientations Transformational Leaders Enhancing the Goal-Setting Process Leadership Styles As the workplace turns out to be increasingly complex and multicultural, the cry for effective leadership has been answered by a growing popularity of leadership studies in various