Legal Environment In Healthcare And Administrative Responsibility Term Paper

Length: 4 pages Sources: 1+ Subject: Engineering Type: Term Paper Paper: #2327677 Related Topics: Biomedical, Biological Engineering, Ovarian Cancer, Patient Advocacy
Excerpt from Term Paper :

Healthcare -- Administration and Legal

Many vectors -- science, research funding, social acceptance or rejection -- influence how and whether medical technology is eventually adopted into medical praxis (Hogle, et al., 2012). Undergirding the choices and changes is a shared body of ethical standards and law, the establishment of which is often not consensual or efficacious. Any emerging technology can encounter unanticipated social resistance and ethical concerns that can change the course of how medical science research progresses (Hogle, et al., 2012). Medical technology often poses questions about access to expensive innovations and considerations about race, gender, and social justice that are inseparable from the socio-economic levels of patients (Hogle, et al., 2012). In contemporary society, there are the inevitable considerations about patent issues, clinical practice, and the commercialization of medical innovations (Hogle, et al., 2012). The recent court decision finding in favor of Myriad Genetics, Inc. provides a good platform for discussing the differences in biomedical decision-making from clinical, ethical, and legal perspectives.

The distinction between the clinical, ethical and legal aspects of biomedical decision-making. Legal decisions can have substantive and lasting impacts on clinical practice, as the recent case decision Association for Molecular Pathology et al. v. United States Patent and Trademark Office et al. illustrates (Stempel, et al., 2012). The biotechnology industry did not anticipate this decision -- and though it could well be overturned following appeal -- the decision has the capacity to change the way patents for genes...


Clinical laboratories that are currently engaged in the development of single-gene genetic tests will be directly impacted by the decision (Stempel, et al., 2012). The move toward whole-genome analysis could make the policies regarding patent protection for single genes less relevant, and some experts believe the patents could even pre-empt whole-genome sequencing (Cho, 2011; Stempel, et al., 2012). Moreover, the genomic technology literature suggests that patents more effectively act as incentives in pharmaceuticals than as incentives for innovation in the field of genetic diagnostics (Cho, 2011).

The court upheld Myriad Genetics right to patent the isolated genes (BRCA1 and BRACA2) that account for most of the breast cancers and ovarian cancers that are inherited (Stempel, et al., 2012). However, the court did not uphold Myriad's argument to patent the analytical methods used to compare DNA sequences (Stempel, et al., 2012). Opponents of placing patents on genes assert that it will constraint patients' access to medical tests and treatment, and that it will restrict scientific research (Stempel, et al., 2012).

Indeed, the ACLU argues that the Myriad patents permit the company to have a monopoly on the BRCA testing in the U.S. Moreover, according to the National Comprehensive Cancer Network, the fact that Myriad's tests do not look for large rearrangements of the genes has resulted in revised treatment guidelines for BRCA genetic testing. So, now, in addition to the $3,000 Myriad BRCA genetic test, physicians will order a second test that costs an additional $700 -- a cost that insurance companies may not cover.

The court decision is considered by biomedical research companies to be a win. Patent attorneys explain that the value of DNA-based inventions is derived from the idea that DNA claims can be patented. At issue is the consideration that isolated genes -- those removed from the body -- are sufficiently changed with regard to chemical structure that a…

Sources Used in Documents:


Cho, M. (2010, November 1). Patently unpatentable: implications of the Myriad court decision on genetic diagnostics. Trends in Biotechnology, 28(11), 548-551. Retrieved / pii/S0167779910001411?_returnURL=

Hogle, L., Tobin, S., Gaba, D. And Yock, P. (2012). Web-Based Research Integrity Training for Biomedical Engineers and Medical Device Researchers (Public Health Service). Stanford Center for Biomedical Ethics. Palo Alto, CA: Stanford School of Medicine. Retreived / programs/science_and_society.html

Morrison, E. (2011). Ethics in health administration: A practical approach for decision makers. (2nd ed.). Sudbury, MA: Jones and Bartlett.

Stempel, J., Steenhuysen, J., Wallace, J., Grebler, D. And Orr, B. (2012, August 16). Myriad wins gene patent ruling from U.S. appeals court. Thomson Reuters. Retrieved

Cite this Document:

"Legal Environment In Healthcare And Administrative Responsibility" (2012, November 25) Retrieved July 4, 2022, from

"Legal Environment In Healthcare And Administrative Responsibility" 25 November 2012. Web.4 July. 2022. <>

"Legal Environment In Healthcare And Administrative Responsibility", 25 November 2012, Accessed.4 July. 2022,

Related Documents
Business Plan for a Healthcare Organization
Words: 5548 Length: 18 Pages Topic: Business - Management Paper #: 71867156

Health Care Organization Strategic Plan: The Case of Samaritan Medical Centre Strategic Planning and Organizational structure Organization Structure Strategic Planning and Organization Structure Present strategy of the Organization Environmental Analysis and Setting Strategic Goals for Samaritan Medical Center Internal Environment Analysis External Environment Analysis III Financial Analysis of Samaritan Medical Center Budget Strategy Assumptions The elements of a projected budget Implementation of Strategic Management Communication of the Plan to the Employees Evaluation and Control of Strategic Plan Strategic Planning and Organizational structure The process of

Health Care Management Obstacles to Change in
Words: 1164 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Healthcare Paper #: 70802908

Health Care Management Obstacles to change in Health Care management. There are a nearly infinite number of things that can go wrong for a health care manager, and out of the two major problems that can arise, staff relationship problems and stresses over financial constraints, the more trying of the two managing the financial interests of the facility within the constraints from senior staff and management. The health care facility is in

Health Care Administration Profession As a Health
Words: 737 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Healthcare Paper #: 44999127

Health Care Administration Profession As a health care manager, the reason for choosing this profession and the day-to-day activities which fill my schedule are often vary different. As a health care professional, I entered this profession to make a contribution to the health and well being of my fellow soldiers. I chose to become a part of the support system which keeps the military functioning, and able to freely commit themselves

Healthcare - Unions Implications of
Words: 2117 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Healthcare Paper #: 32690040

Because unions retain the exclusive right to negotiate on behalf of its members, the individual worker may have little recourse to easily address incompetent leadership. The Disadvantages of Unionized Labor for Healthcare Employers: The primary disadvantages of unionized labor for healthcare employers correspond to the relative loss of control over issues and workplace elements commonly transferred to workers (through their unions), which accounts for the traditional resistance with which many employers

Health Care Reform Federal Deficit the American
Words: 4331 Length: 15 Pages Topic: Healthcare Paper #: 22551835

Health Care Reform Federal Deficit The American Health Care Crisis and the Federal Deficit The United States spends more than any other country on medical care. In 2006, U.S. health care spending was $2.1 trillion, or 16% of our gross domestic product. At the same time, more than 45 million Americans lack health insurance and our health outcomes (life expectancy, infant mortality, and mortality amenable to health care) are mediocre compared with

Health Care A the Different
Words: 2409 Length: 9 Pages Topic: Healthcare Paper #: 52518976

Day treatment programs can provide services at less cost because the patient goes home at night after being treated during the day, which often is used for rehabilitating chronically ill patients (Sharfstein, Stoline, & Koran, 1995, p. 249). The mere fact of having more choice benefits some patients by giving them more say in their care. Patient-focused care involves a method for containing in-patient costs for hospitals and for improving