Mishnah Represents The Attempt At Essay

Length: 5 pages Sources: 4 Subject: Mythology - Religion Type: Essay Paper: #63364246 Related Topics: Bath, Worship, Expert Witness, Colonization
Excerpt from Essay :

Labor relations are mentioned in almost all five sections of the idolatry chapter. In the first section, Jews are listed as possible helpers for Roman basilica-builders, bath-builders, scaffolds, or stadiums. Gentiles are not mentioned as possible construction labor for the Jewish population. On the other hand, Jews do appear to play a key role as merchants during the Roman Empire. Several passages in the chapter on idolatry relate to what can and cannot be sold to a Gentile, and when. Rules establish boundaries between the business partners, so that they are not on equal footing. The authors of the Mishnah are either reacting to or creating social stratifications that are necessary for the preservation of group identity. The social stratifications and normative boundaries might also have been important for the economic cohesiveness of Jewish communities during Roman times. In other words, the taboos against the selling of certain goods might also have been a way to maintain self-sustaining Jewish communities by keeping certain goods within them.

Ritual purity remains the central concept of the Mishnah chapter on idolatry, however. Jews may help Romans build their baths, but not the part of the bath house where the idol is kept (I, 7). No Jew can aide a Gentile in the construction of a basilica. That basilica is bound to be tainted with idols. Jewish artisans and craftsmen cannot manufacture any objects that might be use to adorn Roman deities. Again these labor-related taboos are not solely for the purpose of establishing rules for religious purity. They are also a means of segregating labor and defining how Jewish labor can and cannot be sold on the common market.

The Jewish perspective of Gentiles during the time of Mishnah authorship was prejudicial. Gentiles are "suspected of bestiality," and therefore Jewish ranchers should not leave them alone with their cattle (II, 1). A Jewish daughter cannot serve as a midwife to a Gentile mother because the child being brought into the world...


Ironically, it seems, a Jewish baby can suckle a Gentile wet nurse. Drinking the milk of Gentiles seems like it should be a ritual taboo but it is not. The contradiction can be explained in relation to the desire to strengthen and preserve the Jewish population. If a Jewish baby lost its mother, then it is in the best interests of the community to keep that baby alive by whatever means possible. Thus, suckling from a Gentile wet nurse is acceptable. On the other hand, a Jewish wet nurse is prohibited from suckling a Gentile baby. The Gentile baby is the taboo object, treated almost like an idol.

Jewish dietary laws (kashrut) are clarified also in the second section of the Mishnah idolatry chapter. Rules related to cheese making and pickles seem arbitrary and often contradictory. They are meaningful more on a symbolic level, enabling the Jewish community to establish clear boundaries of when and how to share food with others. Breaking bread and supping with others is a major social function. Distinguishing between Gentile and Jewish food is important for maintaining social boundaries. Likewise, wine is a target of taboo in the Mishnah. Jews cannot drink from Roman libation wine. Even flasks and funnels that have touched libation wine are considered to be contaminated (V. 7).

In spite of the negative implications of the stereotypes and insults in this chapter, the relationship between the Jews and Gentiles under Roman rule was relatively amicable. Jews and Gentiles do regular business with each other and even live side by side (III, 6). Granted the Jew wants nothing to do with the idol worship that characterizes Roman religion. One section refers to wartime in terms that suggest that the two communities bond together, and even share their food (IV, 6). Mistrust between Gentiles and Jews seems to be a major theme in the Mishnah, yet on closer examination, mistrust is not directed at the Gentiles per se. What seems like mistrust is only another means of retaining Jewish cultural identity. For example, if a Jew did not observe how a wine was produced or how a cheese was made, it can be assumed that that product is not made according to Jewish custom. Gentile doctors, customers, and neighbors are all mentioned as if the two communities lived side by side but within a self-segregated society. Notions of cleanliness and ritual purity defines members of the in-group vs. The out-group, not…

Cite this Document:

"Mishnah Represents The Attempt At" (2010, November 09) Retrieved October 3, 2022, from

"Mishnah Represents The Attempt At" 09 November 2010. Web.3 October. 2022. <

"Mishnah Represents The Attempt At", 09 November 2010, Accessed.3 October. 2022,

Related Documents
Hebrew Marriage Beliefs Judaism Believes
Words: 2943 Length: 7 Pages Topic: Mythology - Religion Paper #: 12148278

This obscure, nameless darshan's interpretation of B. Yevamot 62b has been particularly enduring, yet, according to Satlow, "while such an interpretation of this sugya makes a good sermon, it makes poor history ... The sugya as a whole is in fact an attempt to answer the question, Why should a man marry" (Satlow pp). And the answer that it gives is much more complex than recognized by "our" darshan

Sketches of Jewish Social Life,
Words: 5878 Length: 18 Pages Topic: Mythology - Religion Paper #: 7035364

However, Edersheim also points out that Jews were more child-centered than their contemporary cultures. One example of the Jewish reverence for children is that only Jews and one other culture had prohibitions against infanticide, while other cultures openly permitted the practice. In chapter seven, Edersheim goes on to discuss the raising of Jewish children. Different ages of children had different roles and expectations. Children learned early on the protection of

Religion/Israel L. Jones Role of
Words: 2790 Length: 9 Pages Topic: Mythology - Religion Paper #: 52405505

However, prior to the creation of Israel the numbers were much higher (currently approximately 300,000 Palestinian Christians live in the U.S. alone (2004). Interestingly, the Israeli Army does not differentiate between Arab Christians and Arab Muslims in their occupation activities. In fact, in many areas Palestinian Christians are particularly hit by civilian casualty occurrences (Halter, 2001). In fact, Palestinian Christians identify so strongly with the Palestinian cause that statements

Israel at the Time of
Words: 3488 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Mythology - Religion Paper #: 28229354

The Sadducees were composed of the upper class of Jews in Palestine, who were willing to turn away from Jewish traditions and extend cooperation to Rome. The conflict between the Pharisees and the Sadducees played a pivotal role in some of the social and cultural disputes that occurred during Christ's lifetime. The political system of Rome had an economic impact on Jews, which impacted their cultural and religious practices. The

Temple- Its Ministry and Services
Words: 6010 Length: 18 Pages Topic: Mythology - Religion Paper #: 32390774

An additional type of offering was the peace-offering, which represented a feast where God was a guest and the host. Peace offerings were accompanied by meat and drink offerings. For all offerings, repentance was necessary. In chapter seven, Edersheim describes a night in the temple. Edersheim points out the connection between Temple services and the Book of Revelations, which he suggests indicates that the Book of Revelation and the Fourth

High Degree of Misinformation I Had Received
Words: 3132 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Mythology - Religion Paper #: 33587097

high degree of misinformation I had received from traditional teachings about the church and the beginning of Christianity. Moreover, I was struck by the notion that most other people in the Western world receive this same degree of intentional misinformation, so much so that I have even heard people defend the idea that knowledge of the historical church is irrelevant to modern Christianity. Reading through the class material, I