¶ … Mourning and Melancholia," the "father of psychoanalysis" meditated on how the human psyche deals with loss. While melancholia and mourning share many of the same surface traits, the two are very different.
Mourning," he wrote, "is regularly the reaction to the loss of a loved person." Freud believed that the normal way to deal with grief is to mourn and after a period of time, the loss will be overcome. If anything interferes with mourning, the result can be damaging.
Melancholia, on the other hand, is identified by Freud as a pathological illness, which results from an inability to recover from a loss and return to normalcy. Therefore, "the complex of melancholia behaves like an open wound," a wound that will not heal.
Douglas Crimp, an art critic, used Freud's essay in promoting AIDS activism. In 1989, Crimp wrote and essay of his own, titled "Mourning and Militancy" which implied that gay men are denied many of the necessary aspects of Freud's mourning process because they are victims of the shadow of AIDS and homophobia.
Crimp believes that the "violence of silence and omission" of prejudice against homosexuals causes a chronic melancholy. Freud believed that the mourning process involves disconnecting from emotional attachment to the deceased and a sort of taking into ourselves and becoming the thing we miss in the other. Crimp confirms this belief; saying that the gay community shows that melancholia does indeed take place when normal mourning is interrupted.
Freud distinguishes between the mourning of loss and the entrance into the withdrawn depression that characterizes melancholia. In this decisive essay, Freud wrote:
As we have seen, however, melancholia contains something more than normal mourning. In melancholia, the relation to the object is no simple one; it is complicated by the conflict due to ambivalence. The ambivalence is either constitutional, i.e. is an...
For this reason, the exciting causes of melancholia have a much wider range than those of mourning, which is for the most part occasioned only by a real loss of the object, by its death. In melancholia, countless separate struggles are carried on over the object, in which hate and love contend with each other."
Freud said that melancholia is similar to mourning in that it is a reaction to the loss of someone. However, he believed that the two were very different in viewpoints. "In mourning, it is the world which has become poor and empty; in melancholia, it is the ego itself."
This means that a person who is mourning experiences grief over the loss of someone or something beloved. Melancholia is grief over the loss of the ego. Melancholia produces a wound that is unable to close, whereas mourning helps heal the wound. With the process of mourning, the participant goes through a death process for the living in which the participant travels the cycle of adjustment when a loved one is lost.
In the death process, the dead may or may not find permanent rebirth, but one loses self-awareness and so achieves a temporary rebirth at least. In the mourning process, one must find rebirth. If they are unsuccessful, says Freud, they enter a cycle of melancholia instead.
Freud believes that, from early childhood, most people have a need to be artistic. He also says that a sense of loss enables an artist to see things differently. The artistic vision rules his life. The artistic is neither completely normal nor neurotic, but rather endowed with a creative personality and passion that allows him to distinguish his grief feelings of melancholia from his grief feelings of mourning.
The artist longs for normalcy and is constantly fought by his need for…
Grief Freud's theory of Grief and bereavement Grade Course Id, Ego and the Superego or the conscious and the unconscious mind are some of the terms which are well-known by almost every individual. These words not only point out to the field of Psychology but also to the man who coined them and proposed a new realm of theories behind each of it; Sigmund Freud. He is famous for being the father
psychoanalytic as portrayed by H. Segal. It has sources. Psychoanalytic approach to aesthetics can best be understood by understanding the theory/ies that guide us on the study of this particularly complex discipline. The theory and guidelines of psychoanalytic approach enable us to offer some insight into the worlds of literature, art and music, and on the other hand, it also allows us to better understand artists' perception and inner approaches
Death and Dying This report aims to compare Sigmund Freud's hypothesis on the grieving cycle and Elisabeth Kubler-Ross' stages of dying. All men, women and children on the face of this planet eventually lose a loved one and they will also come to a point where they realize their own demise; yet, grieving and death are still not fully understood. Both Freud and Kubler-Ross made amicable attempts to solve the issues