Sign Up Now
Get instant access to over 1 million+ study documents
OR
Already registered? click here to login
By creating your account, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and student honor code.
Compassion and Ethics in Healthcare
Do you agree with Mark's decision not to tell Annie about the seriousness of her illness?
Often, families tend to ask physicians to withhold a serious or terminal prognosis or diagnosis from the patient. In this case, Mark's motive is laudable; he wants to spare Annie the possibly harmful experience of hearing the painful or difficult facts. However, this fear seems to be unfounded. For instance, the physician's thoughtful discussion with Mark, reassuring him that the disclosure will be conducted in a sensitive manner, could help allay this concern (Ozawa-De et al. 146). Nevertheless, in this scenario, Mark has revealed to the physician that disclosure of the diagnosis might cause real and predictable harm; hence withholding is appropriate.
Should the physician have spoken to Annie as to the seriousness of her illness?
I believe that the physician has the right to withhold information about the seriousness of Annie's illness. In many cases, experts have proven that disclosing such sensitive information is dangerous and harmful to the patient. From this perspective, all physicians have sworn in the Hippocratic Oath of keeping the health of their patients as their primary consideration. Here, the principles of non-maleficence and autonomy come into...
Autonomy refers to the patient's right to make informed decisions independently while non-maleficence refers to the physician's duty to do no harm. In Annie's situation, there is a conflict between these two predominant medical principles. As such, the principle of non-maleficence is viewed as predominant. The physician is expected to assess Annie and decide whether autonomy weights much greatly or if the non-maleficence principle weighs heavily. It must be noted that the Hippocratic Oath holds that even if there is a possibility to do harm to Annie (the patient) then it ought to be avoided at all costs. This includes psychological trauma due to diagnosis disclosure (Wendy 159).
The physician has the right to withhold the information because the society has ascribed the role to medics of deciding the importance of autonomy and competency. Competency is the capacity to reason, weigh and make reasonable decisions regarding the benefits and risks of treatment. Annie's case is a perfect case example in which diagnosis information should be withheld.
Describe the ethical dilemmas in this case?
Most people would react negatively to this nondisclosure. Nevertheless, in many nations, the expectation that patients have the right to information has never been the norm and still, it is…
Work Cited
Ozawa-De Silva, Brendan R. et al. Compassion and Ethics: Scientific And Practical Approaches To The Cultivation Of Compassion As A Foundation For Ethical Subjectivity And Well-Being. Journal of Healthcare, Science and the Humanities, 2012, Volume II (1): 145-161
Wendy J. Austin. The Incommensurability of Nursing as a Practice and the Customer Service Model: An Evolutionary Threat to the Discipline. Nursing Philosophy, 2011, vol. 12(3): 158-166
Corporate Governance and Ethical Responsibility Dr. DoRight recently hired President "Universal Human Care Hospital," oversees departments 5,000 employees 20,000 patients medical facility. He provided a broad set duties oversight numerous departments, including business development, customer services, human resources, legal, patient advocacy, a . Corporate Governance and Ethical Responsibility Duty of loyalty owed to internal and external stakeholders According to Heath (2006) , duty of loyalty entails good faith and honesty in best interests of a
Ethical-Legal Nursing Discussions - Part II Moral Distress and Moral Integrity Comment by Ileana: OverviewMoral Distress in Advanced Practice NursingThe meaning of moral distress has been changing in nursing. No definition fits all dilemmas. Moral distress includes cultural beliefs, religious beliefs, educational level, and outside forces that influence thinking. It is important to learn that moral distress is an emotion managed by coping and emotional intelligence. Analyze the difference between moral distress
Ethical Dilemma in Nursing: Case Analysis Ethics is a significant portion in any profession. In nursing professional ethics is part of the daily practices of nurses. Nurses require building up skills to react ethically to mistakes and make ethical choices (Finkelman & Kenner 2012, p.182). Particularly, nurses require the knowledge of ethical reflection in order to discern moral dilemmas and injustices. Nevertheless, a nurse practitioner is required to stick to ethical
Reflection Paper: The Future of Nursing (and Me)The future of nursing is uncertain but the field undoubtedly holds exciting opportunities and challenges. With advancements in healthcare technology and evolving patient needs, nurses are expected to play an increasingly vital role in care delivery. Nurses will likely take on expanded responsibilities, such as providing more comprehensive primary care, embracing telehealth, and contributing to innovative healthcare solutions. Moreover, the nursing workforce will
Applying "Ethical conflicts for new financial planners" to nursing The healthcare industry is increasingly faced with demands that it operate more like a for-profit business with a careful eye upon cutting costs. Reviewing managerial concepts intended for business organizations in general can be useful for healthcare institutions such as hospitals, provided the need for quality is not forgotten. This can be seen in the article "Ethical conflicts for new financial planners"
Scientific research facilitates acquisition of true knowledge, whose highest level is being able to examine scientific issues (Glickman et.al 2009). If knowledge constitutes a universal human property thus greatly impacting overall societal development and wellbeing, the key goal of science will clearly be the truth. Moreover, science’s credibility with the masses is reliant on upholding the highest standards of ethicality when conducting research. Sticking to such guidelines helps prevent deviation