Pay For Performance, Or Alternately Term Paper

Length: 7 pages Sources: 1+ Subject: Teaching Type: Term Paper Paper: #91543885 Related Topics: Merit Pay, School Vouchers, No Child Left Behind Act, Academic Performance
Excerpt from Term Paper :

Plus most teachers saw the pay for performance system as inevitable, and therefore wanted to be involved from the start of the plan (Gratz, 2005).

The pilot faced many challenges. Not the least, the district was faced with the logistical challenge of linking the students in various databases to the teachers. The internal systems for tracking student progress by teacher simply didn't exist. In addition, non-academic staff members had to have appropriate standards devised, such as nurses (Gratz, 2005).

The Denver pilot program experienced the difficulties that were quite unexpected with the implementation of a pay for performance system. The one result that was expected, improved student performance, was interestingly not due to the financial incentives offered. Instead, it came because of the district's commitment to enhancing the entire teaching process. By doing this, they were able to not only boost test scores, but create more effective schools in the process.

Relevant Considerations in Implementation:

There are certain considerations that must be taken into considerations when implementing a pay for performance system. First, the system must be aligned with the strategic direction of the district. Also, in order to attract, motivate and retain the best teachers available, the system must be competitive in financial rewards (Rishell & Becker, 2004).

Performance measurement and goal setting must be made at the district level, and supported at all levels. From the beginning, these measurements must be determined as well as the degree of judgment employed in making incentive award decisions (Rishell & Becker, 2004). but, to compliment this system, as Denver discovered, the entire teaching process must be supported, including career development and enhanced training for the teachers to facilitate their goal achievement.

Brief Plan for Employee Communication:

From the beginning, employees need to be involved in the development and implementation of the pay for performance system. Communication begins with an open forum meeting to decide what aspects should be measured, what goals are appropriate, and the incentives to be rewarded. Core competencies must be identified by staff members...

...

The formalized plan needs to be explained in detail, clarifying any questions the employees may have. Once the system is implemented, any measurements gathered need to be shared immediately with the employees, such as test scores of students with the appropriate teachers, in order to ensure the maximum motivation.

Impact of Pay for Performance on the Organization:

Performance for pay systems can be a win-win situation ("Pay for performance," 2004). The teachers can benefit from the opportunity for increased financial compensation, the students can benefit from more effective teaching, and the district can benefit from better schools. In addition, this trend of utilizing pay for performance system, is certain to become a more significant factor in the years to come, in attracting, motivating and retaining the best teachers available (Sturman, Trevor, Boudreau, & Gerhart, 2003).

For this reason, pay for performance systems are certain to impact the current HR practices and programs within the district currently. It will become inevitable that the district will be forced to put this type of system in place, to remain competitive, and to ensure compliance with the No Child Left Behind Act. For this reason, it is recommended that a program be implemented as soon as possible.

As mentioned this program should not only be tied to the students' test scores, but should also include career development. An effective program will support the entire educational process, and not simply be test intensive.

The primary concern with this program is the likelihood that teachers will narrow their focus to hyper-focus on testing. Again, by basing part of the measurement on career development, along with test scores, hopefully the system will avoid this pitfall that was experienced in Denver. It may be inappropriate to link salaries such as school nurses, lunch staff and janitorial staff to pay for performance.

References

Brotherton, P. Meyners pays for performance. Journal of Accountancy, 196(1). Retrieved June 13, 2005, from Business Source Premier database.

Gratz, D.B. (Apr 2005). Lessons from Denver: The pay for performance pilot. Phi Delta Kappan, 86(8). Retrieved June 13, 2005, from ProQuest database.

Pay for performance say Kiwi workers. (Jun 2004). New Zealand Management, 51(5). Retrieved June 13, 2005, from Business Source Premier database.

Rishell, M. & Becker, W. (Nov 2004). Pay for performance: The CFO's stake. Strategic Finance, 86(5). Retrieved June 13, 2005, from Business Source Premier database.

Sturman, M., Trevor, C., Boudreau, J. & Gerhart,…

Sources Used in Documents:

References

Brotherton, P. Meyners pays for performance. Journal of Accountancy, 196(1). Retrieved June 13, 2005, from Business Source Premier database.

Gratz, D.B. (Apr 2005). Lessons from Denver: The pay for performance pilot. Phi Delta Kappan, 86(8). Retrieved June 13, 2005, from ProQuest database.

Pay for performance say Kiwi workers. (Jun 2004). New Zealand Management, 51(5). Retrieved June 13, 2005, from Business Source Premier database.

Rishell, M. & Becker, W. (Nov 2004). Pay for performance: The CFO's stake. Strategic Finance, 86(5). Retrieved June 13, 2005, from Business Source Premier database.


Cite this Document:

"Pay For Performance Or Alternately" (2005, June 13) Retrieved August 19, 2022, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/pay-for-performance-or-alternately-66635

"Pay For Performance Or Alternately" 13 June 2005. Web.19 August. 2022. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/pay-for-performance-or-alternately-66635>

"Pay For Performance Or Alternately", 13 June 2005, Accessed.19 August. 2022,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/pay-for-performance-or-alternately-66635

Related Documents
Pay Structure Reflects Four General Architectural Principles.
Words: 623 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Careers Paper #: 98408889

Pay structure reflects four general architectural principles. The first is the minimum and maximum levels of pay within the organization, and to whom those levels go. The second is the general relationship between the levels of pay. In this, the organization must understand the different types of employees that it has, and what the relationship is between those types. The third factor is whether the pay structure should lead the

Teacher Qualifications and Student Performance:
Words: 2864 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 13867347

They computed a variety of measures to determine whether there was in fact a narrowing of a gap between teacher qualifications across wealthier and poorer schools and found that there was. This narrowing -- indicative of changes in hiring practices and policies as a result in NCLB, was positively correlated with improved test scores in those districts with higher poverty populations. The researcher felt there was some possibility, as indicated

Employer, Acme Inc., a Medium Sized Industrial
Words: 1297 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Careers Paper #: 19266667

employer, Acme Inc., a medium sized industrial company, has conducted a Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats (SWOT) Analysis and has determined the strategic goals and objectives for the organization. One of the opportunities identified from the SWOT was the current economy and the high unemployment rate. In addition, a strategic goal was established as a result of the SWOT for Acme Inc. To maintain status quo on recruiting and

Shin Splints From Ecs Conditions
Words: 4210 Length: 15 Pages Topic: Sports Paper #: 40062881

Practical Research Finding Implementation and Experimentation Stage -- Phase I The experimenter did not set out to determine specifically which of the various contributing factors (or combinations of factors) identified by the empirical research of medial tibial stress syndrome was most responsible for the experimenter's symptoms. However, since the initial attempts to resolve the symptoms incorporated changes to all of the external variables except a change in running surface, the experimenter

Piney Woods Hospital Satisfaction Is the Pivotal
Words: 3021 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Healthcare Paper #: 20804499

Piney Woods Hospital Satisfaction is the pivotal problem for Piney Woods Hospital to address. Satisfaction across all stakeholders has a substantive impact on the other key challenges the hospital is facing. When customers are satisfied with the service and care they receive at hospital, they let others in the community know about it. When hospital employees are satisfied, they provide superior hospital services. When physicians are satisfied, they provide excellent medical

Compensation System. A Brief Discussion
Words: 2745 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 69975296

Dental care under MCSS fee schedule for Ontario Works adults; Prosthetic appliances such as back braces, surgical stockings, and artificial limbs (provision, replacement, and repairs); Wheelchairs and repairs for the portion not covered through ADP; Hearing aids and batteries (co-payment under Ministry of Health and Long- Term Care's Assistive Devices Program (ADP) for the provision, replacement, and repairs to hearing aids); Vision care for adults; Dentures where deemed appropriate; Cost of completing other medical forms; and