Performance Evaluation Case Analysis Essay

Length: 4 pages Sources: 3 Subject: Business Type: Essay Paper: #50103969 Related Topics: Evaluation, Harvard Business School, Performance Management, Critical Analysis
Excerpt from Essay :


Financial -- Above par

Strategy Implementation -- Above Par

Customer Satisfaction -- Below Par

Control -- Par

People -- Above Par

Standards -- Above Par

Overall Evaluation -- Above Par

The overall approach for feedback is to be honest. You are an adult, dealing with an adult. We need to treat it like a management issue, not a human resources issue. Optimizing the customer service score, for example, may not be the best way to run the branch.

The approach is to walk through each of the points on the form one by one initially, giving more or less equal time to them all. So there will be an initial, structured sequence that we use, and we would want to use the same one for all of our managers. But after that, the discussion needs to be unstructured, because that is where the really good exchange of ideas comes from.

Then, because customer service is the only Below Par rating, that will receive special attention. First, James probably understands the point of improving customer service scores, but it is worth reviewing this. Customer service is linked not only to corporate priorities but it serves a specific purpose within Citibank's strategy. The branch performs well financially because James is a good manager and because there are a lot of wealthy people in the client base. It is those wealthy individuals that drive the branch's financial results. But competition for those customers is going to be intense. Strategically, the key to sustainable success at this branch is to sustain high customer service scores, especially among the wealthiest clients.

Here is the rub -- James is a pro, so he is going to want to understand the data a little deeper. First, there was a lot of variability in the customer service scores. The "Below Par" rating is because, on average, the score was below par, but there is a fair bit of volatility...


If James is going to improve, we need to be able to help him with meaningful information, not just a letter grade.

The bottom line is that the methodology is weak -- it is not aligned with the overall strategy for this branch. This is why his overall evaluation is going to be "Above Par." A survey of 25 randomly-selected customers makes little sense for a branch where the top 10% or so of customers is driving revenue and profit. Further, they are probably the busiest customers, and the least likely to answer a survey. The customer service scores -- in the absence of actually having this data -- may well reflect that the branch is driving its financials by delivering exceptional service to the high net worth customers, perhaps at the expense of the low net worth customers. If that is the trade-off that James is making, we need to know that, so this will have to be part of the discussion. While all branches have x percentage of clients driving revenue, this branch is likely to have a disproportionate amount. I would measure this branch against other branches with equivalent customer bases -- so ritzy residential areas, or financial district branches in New York, Chicago, San Francisco, etc. You really have to compare like to like.

The desired end result of the discussion is to understand why the data is the way it is, and to get a better sense of how James is approaching this issue. Naturally, we want even the little old ladies to be happy with our branch, but we need to be aware of the trade-offs and ensure that what James is doing in the way of trade-offs is not negatively affecting the shareholders' wealth. If he needs an extra ATM or an extra teller to make all the little old ladies and clock punchers happy, that's our job as regional managers to make that happen -- the branch is making a lot of money for us so it is not a problem to provide them with the resources that they need. But this…

Sources Used in Documents:


Davila, A. & Simons, R. (1997). Citibank: Performance evaluation. Harvard Business School 9-198-048

Cite this Document:

"Performance Evaluation Case Analysis" (2015, July 25) Retrieved January 16, 2022, from

"Performance Evaluation Case Analysis" 25 July 2015. Web.16 January. 2022. <>

"Performance Evaluation Case Analysis", 25 July 2015, Accessed.16 January. 2022,

Related Documents
Performance Evaluation Critique Several Years Ago Arrow
Words: 3136 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Business - Management Paper #: 35958127

Performance Evaluation Critique Several years ago Arrow Electronics instituted an Employee Performance Review (EPR) system. However, the process was not providing the CEO. Steve Kaufman, the results that he had hoped for when it was instituted. The original goal of the EPR system was to help identify those individuals within the company whose performance was outstanding and whose career should be accelerated. It was also designed to pinpoint those who would

Performance Evaluation Explain Three Points
Words: 996 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Careers Paper #: 58630771

Once this happens, is when these kinds of attitudes can begin to affect others around them. Compare and contrast at least three common performance evaluation methods used to analyze performance data after it has been gathered. Three different performance evaluation methods include: self-evaluation, the 360 degree approach and critical incident analysis. Self-evaluation is when the employees will rate their performance. This can be used with the manager's evaluation to understand what

Performance Evaluation Methods for Instructors: Similar to
Words: 1224 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 64977993

Performance Evaluation Methods for Instructors: Similar to the workplace, performance evaluation is an important aspect for the classroom environment in which the instructor is the rater and the students are the ratees. In today's classroom, instructors use basic combination of papers, tests, exams, cases, and class participation as the basis for assessment and then provide the formal appraisal in the form of a grade. Notably, a comprehensive student appraisal consists of

Performance Evaluation of How Hedge
Words: 19967 Length: 80 Pages Topic: Economics Paper #: 59799025

As a consequence, investors may suffer. Importance of the Study It is necessary and pertinent to discuss the importance of any study, and this particular study is important to many people across many countries. Not only does it have importance for people who are trusting people with their pension and hedge funds in Germany, but it also has importance for people who are considering a career working with these funds and

Performance Appraisal Survey Analysis
Words: 612 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Careers Paper #: 98441253

Performance Appraisal: There are many different types of performance appraisals available. Among the more common include: Comparative Standards -- This type of performance appraisal compares employee's performance with others in a group Group Ranking Order -- In this type a supervisor places each employee in a classification, such as top 1/2 of employees. Usually someone has to be assigned in a bottom fraction of the group. Individual Ranking -- This is the most commonly

Dell Computer Case Analysis
Words: 635 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 80689880

Dell Computer Corporation: Strategy and Challenges for the 21st Century, by Thompson and Gamble. This case analysis will evaluate a variety of factors including, the role of Michael Dell as CEO, and his strategy. Further, a brief SWOT analysis will be given, and a competitive strength assessment will compare Dell to major competitors. Advantages of Dell's strategy and an assessment of the company's financial performance will be given. Finally, a